What can we really learn from positron flux 'anomalies'?

Abstract

We present a critical analysis of the observational constraints on, and of the theoretical modeling of, aspects of cosmic ray (CR) generation and propagation in the Galaxy, which are relevant for the interpretation of recent positron and anti-proton measurements. We give simple, analytic, model independent expressions for the secondary pbar flux, and an upper limit for the secondary e+ flux, obtained by neglecting e+ radiative losses, e+/(e+ + e-)<0.2\pm0.1 up to ~300 GeV. These expressions are completely determined by the rigidity dependent grammage, which is measured from stable CR secondaries up to ~150 GeV/nuc, and by nuclear cross sections measured in the laboratory. pbar and e+ measurements, available up to ~100 GeV, are consistent with these estimates, implying that there is no need for new, non-secondary, pbar or e+ sources. The radiative loss suppression factor f_{s,e+} of the e+ flux depends on the e+ propagation in the Galaxy, which is not understood theoretically. A rough, model independent estimate of f_{s,e+} 1/3 can be obtained at a single energy, E\sim20 GeV, from unstable secondary decay and is found to be consistent with e+ measurements, including the positron fraction measured by PAMELA. We show that specific detailed models, that agree with compositional CR data, agree with our simple expressions for the e+ and pbar flux, and that the claims that the positron fraction measured by PAMELA requires new primary e+ sources are based on assumptions, that are not supported by observations. If PAMELA results are correct, they suggest that f_{s,e+} is slightly increasing with energy, which provides an interesting constraint on CR propagation models. We argue that measurements of the e+ to pbar ratio are more useful for challenging secondary production models than the positron fraction.

16 pages, 10 figures, minor revisions, accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (21)

• Observation of an anomalous positron abundance in the cosmic radiation
• Measurement of the Cosmic Ray e+ plus e- spectrum from 20 GeV to 1 TeV with the Fermi Large Area Telescope
• A new measurement of the antiproton-to-proton flux ratio up to 100 GeV in the cosmic radiation
• Probing the ATIC peak in the cosmic-ray electron spectrum with H.E.S.S
• Parameterization of Gamma, e^+/- and Neutrino Spectra Produced by p-p Interaction in Astronomical Environment
• The origin of the positron excess in cosmic rays
• Constraints on WIMP Dark Matter from the High Energy PAMELA $\bar{p}/p$ data
• Dark Matter Interpretations of the Electron/Positron Excesses after FERMI
• Measurements of cosmic-ray secondary nuclei at high energies with the first flight of the CREAM balloon-borne experiment
• Galactic secondary positron flux at the Earth
• High-energy antiprotons from old supernova remnants
• Testing astrophysical models for the PAMELA positron excess with cosmic ray nuclei
• The galactic antiproton spectrum at high energies: background expectation vs. exotic contributions
• Inhomogeneity in the Supernova Remnant Distribution as the Origin of the PAMELA Anomaly
• Nuclear Effects on Hadron Production in d+Au and p+p Collisions at sqrt(s_NN)=200 GeV
• Energy dependence of Ti/Fe ratio in the Galactic cosmic rays measured by the ATIC-2 experiment
• Anti-Matter in Cosmic Rays : Backgrounds and Signals
• On the Positron Fraction and the Spectrum of the Electronic Component in Cosmic Rays
• The Cosmic-Ray Positron and Electron Excess: An Experimentalist's Point of View
• Inhomogeneity in the Supernova Remnants as a Natural Explanation of the PAMELA/ATIC Observations
• Analysis of the Spectral Intensities and Ratios of Electrons and Positrons in Cosmic Rays

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Dark Matter Candidates from Particle Physics and Methods of Detection
• New limits on dark matter annihilation from AMS cosmic ray positron data
• The origin of Galactic cosmic rays: challenges to the standard paradigm
• Cosmic Ray Transport in the Galaxy: a Review
• A Precision Search for WIMPs with Charged Cosmic Rays
• Astrophysical models for the origin of the positron "excess"
• Reverse Direct Detection: Cosmic Ray Scattering With Light Dark Matter
• AMS-02 beryllium data and its implication for cosmic ray transport
• Nonabelian dark matter: models and constraints
• AMS02 results support the secondary origin of cosmic ray positrons
• Cosmic rays, anti-helium, and an old navy spotlight
• The origin of the spectral intensities of cosmic-ray positrons
• Interpretation of the cosmic ray positron and antiproton fluxes
• A Gamma-Ray Burst/Pulsar for Cosmic-Ray Positrons with a Dark Matter-like Spectrum
• Explaining cosmic ray antimatter with secondaries from old supernova remnants
• Cosmic Ray Studies with the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope Large Area Telescope
• Effects of reacceleration and source grammage on secondary cosmic rays spectra
• Interpretation of the excess of antiparticles within a modified paradigm of galactic cosmic rays
• Cosmic ray propagation time scales: lessons from radioactive nuclei and positron data
• What could we learn from a sharply falling positron fraction?
• Selected Topics in Cosmic Ray Physics
• Deep Correlation Between Cosmic-Ray Anomaly and Neutrino Masses
• $e^{+}$ and $\bar{p}$ production in $pp$ collisions and the cosmic-ray $e^{+}/\bar{p}$ flux ratio
• Extracting the size of the cosmic electron-positron anomaly
• Cosmic ray backgrounds for dark matter indirect detection
• Production of light antinuclei in $pp$ collisions by dynamical coalescence and their fluxes in cosmic rays near earth
• Cosmic Rays in the Milky Way and Beyond
• Examining the secondary product origin of cosmic ray positrons with the latest AMS-02 data
• Fundamental physics in space with the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope