Discrepant Mass Estimates in the Cluster of Galaxies Abell 1689
arXiv:0906.4153 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/701/2/1283
Abstract
We present a new mass estimate of a well-studied gravitational lensing cluster, Abell 1689, from deep Chandra observations with a total exposure of 200 ks. Within r=200 h-1 kpc, the X-ray mass estimate is systematically lower than that of lensing by 30-50%. At r>200 h-1 kpc, the mass density profiles from X-ray and weak lensing methods give consistent results. The most recent weak lensing work suggest a steeper profile than what is found from the X-ray analysis, while still in agreement with the mass at large radii. Previous studies have suggested that cooler small-scale structures can bias X-ray temperature measurements or that the northern part of the cluster is disturbed. We find these scenarios unlikely to resolve the central mass discrepancy since the former requires 70-90% of the space to be occupied by these cool structures and excluding the northern substructure does not significantly affect the total mass profiles. A more plausible explanation is a projection effect. We also find that the previously reported high hard-band to broad-band temperature ratio in A1689, and many other clusters observed with Chandra, may be resulting from the instrumental absorption that decreases 10-15% of the effective area at ~1.75 keV.
arXiv comment18 pages, 15 figures. ApJ accepted
References in corpus (60)
- A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
- Collisional Plasma Models with APEC/APED: Emission Line Diagnostics of Hydrogen-like and Helium-like Ions
- Chandra sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters: mass, gas fraction, and mass-temperature relation
- Nucleosynthesis in Chandrasekhar Mass Models for Type Ia Supernovae and Constraints on Progenitor Systems and Burning-Front Propagation
- Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project II: Samples and X-ray Data Reduction
- Statistics: Handle with Care, Detecting Multiple Model Components with the Likelihood Ratio Test
- Improved constraints on dark energy from Chandra X-ray observations of the largest relaxed galaxy clusters
- Chandra temperature profiles for a sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters
- Testing X-ray Measurements of Galaxy Clusters with Cosmological Simulations
- A New Robust Low-Scatter X-ray Mass Indicator for Clusters of Galaxies
- Comparing the temperatures of galaxy clusters from hydro-N-body simulations to Chandra and XMM-Newton observations
- Comparing the temperatures of galaxy clusters from hydro-N-body simulations to Chandra and XMM-Newton observations
- The 2-8 keV cosmic X-ray background spectrum as observed with XMM-Newton
- A Catalog of Galaxy Clusters Observed by XMM-Newton
- Strong Lensing Analysis of A1689 from Deep Advanced Camera Images
- Filaments, Bubbles, and Weak Shocks in the Gaseous Atmosphere of M87
- Systematics in the X-ray Cluster Mass Estimators
- Combining Strong and Weak Gravitational Lensing in Abell 1689
- The X-ray virial relations for relaxed lensing clusters observed with Chandra
- The Surprisingly Steep Mass Profile of Abell 1689, from a Lensing Analysis of Subaru Images
- A deeper X-ray study of the core of the Perseus galaxy cluster: the power of sound waves and the distribution of metals and cosmic rays
- Spatially resolved X-ray spectroscopy of cooling clusters of galaxies
- Radial temperature profiles for a large sample of galaxy clusters observed with XMM-Newton
- The mass profile of A1413 observed with XMM-Newton: implications for the M-T relation
- Characterizing the Cluster Lens Population
- Four Measures of the Intracluster Medium Temperature and Their Relation to a Cluster's Dynamical State
- Outer Regions of the Cluster Gaseous Atmospheres
- Chandra Spectra of the Soft X-ray Diffuse Background
- Can the Steep Mass Profile of A1689 Be Explained by a Triaxial Dark Halo?
- The Observed Concentration-Mass Relation for Galaxy Clusters
- XMM-Newton observation of M87 I. Single-phase temperature structure of intracluster medium
- Gravitational Lensing in Clusters of Galaxies: New Clues Regarding the Dynamics of Intracluster Gas
- Spatially-resolved X-ray spectroscopy of the core of the Centaurus cluster
- Projection effects in cluster mass estimates : the case of MS2137
- Predicting Single-Temperature Fit to Multi-Component Thermal Plasma Spectra
- Parametric Strong Gravitational Lensing Analysis of Abell 1689
- Constraining supernova models using the hot gas in clusters of galaxies
- Combining Lens Distortion and Depletion to Map the Mass Distribution of A1689
- What is the largest Einstein radius in the universe?
- A New Look at Massive Clusters: weak lensing constraints on the triaxial dark matter halos of Abell 1689, Abell 1835, & Abell 2204
- Observations of metals in the intra-cluster medium
- Complex Structure of Galaxy Cluster Abell 1689: Evidence for a Merger from X-ray data?
- XMM-Newton EPIC background modeling for extended sources
- Non-parametric mass reconstruction of A1689 from strong lensing data with SLAP
- Cluster Structure in Cosmological Simulations I: Correlation to Observables, Mass Estimates, and Evolution
- XMM-Newton observation of the relaxed cluster A478: gas and dark matter distribution from 0.01 R_200 to 0.5 R_200
- XMM-Newton Observations of Evolution of Cluster X-Ray Scaling Relations at z=0.4-0.7
- Mass and Gas Profiles in A1689: Joint X-ray and Lensing Analysis
- Aspherical galaxy clusters: effects on cluster masses and gas mass fractions
- Bandpass Dependence of X-ray Temperatures in Galaxy Clusters
- Tracing the X-ray emitting intra-cluster medium of clusters of galaxies beyond r_200
- The complex velocity distribution of galaxies in Abell 1689: implications for mass modelling
- Robust quantitative measures of cluster X-ray morphology, and comparisons between cluster characteristics
- Radial profile and log-normal fluctuations of intra-cluster medium as an origin of systematic bias of spectroscopic temperature
- Chandra observation of Abell 1689: New determination of mass distribution and comparison to lensing measurements
- Meso-structure in three strong-lensing systems
- Resolving the discrepancy between lensing and X-ray mass estimates of the complex galaxy cluster Abell 1689
- Characterizing the Properties of Clusters of Galaxies as a Function of Luminosity and Redshift
- The Sextet Arcs: a Strongly Lensed Lyman Break Galaxy in the ACS Spectroscopic Galaxy Survey towards Abell 1689
- Extracting the Dark Matter Profile of a Relaxed Galaxy Cluster
Cited by in corpus (32)
- Cluster Lenses
- CLASH: The Concentration-Mass Relation of Galaxy Clusters
- Mass profiles of Galaxy Clusters from X-ray analysis
- Suzaku Observation of Abell 1689: Anisotropic Temperature and Entropy Distributions Associated with the Large-Scale Structure
- The Three-Dimensional Shapes of Galaxy Clusters
- The Highest Resolution Mass Map of Galaxy Cluster Substructure To Date Without Assuming Light Traces Mass: LensPerfect Analysis of Abell 1689
- Three-dimensional Multi-probe Analysis of the Galaxy Cluster A1689
- Unveiling the three-dimensional structure of galaxy clusters: resolving the discrepancy between X-ray and lensing masses
- Mass, shape and thermal properties of A1689 by a multi-wavelength X-ray, lensing and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich analysis
- Weak and strong lensing analysis of the triaxial matter distribution of A1689
- A Free-Form Lensing Grid Solution for A1689 with New Mutiple Images
- Triaxiality and non-thermal gas pressure in Abell 1689
- Discovery of diffuse emission in the galaxy cluster A1689
- Abell 611. II. X-ray and strong lensing analyses
- Reconstructing the triaxiality of the galaxy cluster Abell 1689: solving the X-ray and strong lensing mass discrepancy
- Shape and orientation of the gas distribution in A1689
- Testing Strict Hydrostatic Equilibrium in Simulated Clusters of Galaxies: Implications to Abell 1689
- Gravitational Lensing Corrections in Flat LambdaCDM Cosmology
- Galaxy cluster's rotation
- LoCuSS: The splashback radius of massive galaxy clusters and its dependence on cluster merger history
- Data and 2D scaling relations for galaxies in Abell 1689: a hint of size evolution at z~0.2
- A new tool to determine masses and mass profiles using gravitational flexion
- New Constraints on the Complex Mass Substructure in Abell 1689 from Gravitational Flexion
- Testing hydrostatic equilibrium in galaxy cluster MS 2137
- Reconstructing the projected gravitational potential of Abell 1689 from X-ray measurements
- An excursion into the core of the cluster lens Abell 1689
- The Cosmic Background Imager 2
- The KALEIDOSCOPE survey : A new strong and weak gravitational lensing view of the massive galaxy cluster MACS J1423.8+2404
- CHEX-MATE: Multi-probe analysis of Abell 1689
- Quantifying the collisionless nature of dark matter and galaxies in A1689
- CHEX-MATE: New detections and properties of the radio diffuse emission in massive clusters with MeerKAT
- AMiBA: Cluster Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Observations with the Expanded 13-Element Array