Do we really know the dust? Systematics and uncertainties of the mid-infrared spectral analysis methods

Abstract

The spectral region around 10 micrometer, showing prominent dust emission bands, is commonly used to derive the chemical composition of protoplanetary dust. Different analysis methods have been proposed for this purpose, but so far, no comparative test has been performed to test their validity. We calculated model spectra of disk models with different geometries and central sources, using a 2D radiative transfer code. These spectra were then fitted in a blind test using four different spectral decomposition methods. We studied the effect of disk structure (flared vs. flat), inclination angle, size of the inner disk hole and stellar luminosity on the fitted chemical composition. Our results show that the derived dust compositions by all methods deviate systematically from the real chemical composition. Out of the four tested spectral decomposition methods, our new two-layer temperature distribution method, differs the least from the input dust composition and the results show the weakest systematic effects. The reason for the deviations of the results given by other methods lies in their simplifying assumptions (e.g. single average grain temperature or one component continuum). We also tested the influence of different noise levels on the results of the spectral decomposition methods. We find that, for ground-based observations (8-13 micrometer) the expected uncertainty in the value of the crystallinity is about 11% for a signal-to-noise ratio of 100, while for space-based observations (7-17 micrometer) the uncertainty is about 5%. On the basis of our results, we propose a recipe for the analysis and interpretation of dust spectroscopy data in the mid-infrared which should be especially valuable for analysing Spitzer data and ground-based infrared spectroscopy data in the 10 micrometer window.

Accepted for publication in ApJ, 47 pages, 13 figures, 3 tables

References in corpus (7)

• The shape and composition of interstellar silicate grains
• The formation and evolution of planetary systems: Grain growth and chemical processing of dust in T Tauri systems
• Crystalline silicates and dust processing in the protoplanetary disks of the Taurus young cluster
• Dust Processing in Disks around T Tauri Stars
• Silicate Dust in Evolved Protoplanetary Disks: Growth, Sedimentation, and Accretion
• Probing Protoplanetary Disks with Silicate Emission: Where is the silicate emission zone?
• Analysis of the dust evolution in the circumstellar disks of TTauri stars

Cited by in corpus (23)

• Observing transiting planets with JWST -- Prime targets and their synthetic spectral observations
• Dust evolution in protoplanetary disks around Herbig Ae/Be stars - The Spitzer view
• The Atomic and Molecular Content of Disks Around Very Low-mass Stars and Brown Dwarfs
• Water in the terrestrial planet-forming zone of the PDS 70 disk
• The Long-Lived Disks in the Eta Chamaeleontis Cluster
• The Impact of Recent Advances in Laboratory Astrophysics on our Understanding of the Cosmos
• The VLTI/MIDI survey of massive young stellar objects - Sounding the inner regions around intermediate- and high-mass young stars using mid-infrared interferometry
• On the Evolution of Dust Mineralogy, From Protoplanetary Disks to Planetary Systems
• C2D Spitzer-IRS spectra of disks around T Tauri stars V. Spectral decomposition
• Young stars in Epsilon Cha and their disks: disk evolution in sparse associations
• Dust properties and disk structure of evolved protoplanetary disks in Cep OB2: Grain growth, settling, gas and dust mass, and inside-out evolution
• Dust mineralogy and variability of the inner PDS 70 disk
• Bayesian Analysis of Molecular Emission and Dust Continuum of Protoplanetary Disks
• The radial distribution of dust species in young brown dwarf disks
• Silicate Evolution in Brown Dwarf Disks
• Dust Grain Evolution in Spatially Resolved T Tauri Binaries
• Mid-infrared evidence for iron-rich dust in the multi-ringed inner disk of HD 144432
• Disentangling the dust and gas contributions of the JWST/MIRI spectrum of Sz28
• The young B-star quintuple system HD 155448
• MINDS. Cha Hα 1, a brown dwarf with a hydrocarbon-rich disk
• MINDS survey of silicates in T Tauri disks: Correlation between dust and gas
• MINDS: The very low-mass star and brown dwarf sample II. Probing disk settling, dust properties, and dust-gas interplay with JWST/MIRI
• Probing the temporal and spatial variations of dust emission in the protoplanetary disk of DG Tau with VLTI/MIDI - Preliminary results