Tombaugh 2: The First Open Cluster with a Significant Abundance Spread or Embedded in a Cold Stellar Stream?

Abstract

We present new abundances and radial velocities for stars in the field of the open cluster Tombaugh 2, which has been suggested to be associated with the Galactic Anticenter Stellar Structure (also known as the Monoceros stream). Using VLT/FLAMES with the UVES and GIRAFFE spectrographs, we find a radial velocity (RV) of <V_{r}> = 121 \pm 0.4 km/s using eighteen Tombaugh 2 cluster stars. Our abundance analysis of RV-selected members finds that Tombaugh 2 is more metal-rich than previous studies have found; moreover, unlike the previous work, our larger sample also reveals that stars with the velocity of the cluster show a relatively large spread in chemical properties (e.g., Delta[Fe/H] > 0.2). This is the first time a possible abundance spread has been observed in an open cluster, though this is one of several possible explanations for our observations. While there is an apparent trend of [alpha/Fe] with [Fe/H], the distribution of abundances of these "RV cluster members" also may hint at a possible division into two primary groups with different mean chemical characteristics -- namely (<[Fe/H]>,<[Ti/Fe]>) ~ (-0.06, +0.02) and (-0.28, +0.36). Based on position and kinematics Tombaugh 2 is a likely member of the GASS/Monoceros stream, which makes Tombaugh 2 the second star cluster within the originally proposed GASS/Monoceros family. However, we explore other possible explanations for the observed spread in abundances and two possible sub-populations, with the most likely explanation being that the metal-poor ([Fe/H] = -0.28), more centrally-concentrated population being the true Tombaugh 2 clusters stars and the metal-rich ([Fe/H] = -0.06) population being an overlapping, and kinematically associated, but "cold" (sigma_V < 2 km/s) stellar stream at R_{gc} >= 15 kpc.

15 pages, 7 figure, MNRAS in press

References in corpus (52)

• Evolutionary tracks and isochrones for low- and intermediate-mass stars: from 0.15 to 7 M_sun, and from Z=0.0004 to 0.03
• The Ghost of Sagittarius and Lumps in the Halo of the Milky Way
• A Triple Main Sequence in the Globular Cluster NGC 2808
• Simulations of Galaxy Formation in a Lambda CDM Universe II: The Fine Structure of Simulated Galactic Disks
• The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. I. Overview and Clusters Without Previous HST Photometry
• A Low Latitude Halo Stream around the Milky Way
• The Emergence of the Thick Disk in a CDM Universe
• Two distinct ancient components in the Sculptor Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy: First Results from DART
• A dwarf galaxy remnant in Canis Major: the fossil of an in-plane accretion onto the Milky Way
• Abundances for metal-poor stars with accurate parallaxes I. Basic data
• Outer structure of the Galactic warp and flare: explaining the Canis Major over-density
• The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. III. The Double Subgiant Branch of NGC 1851
• Improved Color-Temperature Relations and Bolometric Corrections for Cool Stars
• One Ring to Encompass them All: A giant stellar structure that surrounds the Galaxy
• A Complete N-body Model of the Old Open Cluster M67
• The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters: M54 and Young Populations in the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy
• Elemental Abundance Ratios in Stars of the Outer Galactic Disk. I. Open Clusters
• The multiplicity of the subgiant branch of Omega Centauri: Evidence for prolonged star formation
• New evidence for the complex struscture of the RGB of Omega Cen
• A comprehensive model for the Monoceros tidal stream
• A Hipparcos study of the Hyades open cluster: Improved colour-absolute magnitude and Hertzsprung-Russell diagrams
• A 2MASS All-Sky View of the Sagittarius Dwarf Galaxy: Variation of the Metallicity Distribution Function Along the Sagittarius Stream
• Exploring Halo Substructure with Giant Stars: Spectroscopy of Stars in the Galactic Anticenter Stellar Structure
• Exploring Halo Substructure with Giant Stars: I. Survey Description and Calibration of the Photometric Search Technique
• Substructure in Tidal Streams; Tributaries in the Anticenter Ring
• Element abundances of unevolved stars in the open cluster M 67
• NGC 6441: another indication for a very high helium content in Globular Cluster stars
• Old open clusters in the outer Galactic disk
• Elemental Abundance Ratios in Stars of the Outer Galactic Disk. III. Cepheids
• Spiral structure of the Third Galactic Quadrant and the solution to the Canis Major debate
• Probing the Canis Major stellar over-density as due to the Galactic warp
• Open Clusters as Galactic Disk Tracers: I. Project Motivation, Cluster Membership and Bulk Three-Dimensional Kinematics
• Metal abundances in extremely distant Galactic old open clusters. I. Berkeley 29 and Saurer 1
• Space Velocities of Southern Globular Clusters. V. A Low Galactic Latitude Sample
• Star Clusters in the Galactic Anticenter Stellar Structure and the Origin of Outer Old Open Clusters
• Detection of the Canis Major galaxy at (l;b)=(244;-8) and in the background of Galactic open clusters
• The central density cusp of the Sagittarius dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• The Closest View of a Dwarf Galaxy: New Evidence on the Nature of the Canis Major over-density
• Detection of a young stellar population in the background of open clusters in the Third Galactic Quadrant
• Why the Canis Major overdensity is not due to the Warp: analysis of its radial profile and velocities
• Elemental Abundance Ratios in Stars of the Outer Galactic Disk. II. Field Red Giants
• Absolute Proper Motion of the Canis Major Dwarf Galaxy Candidate
• The Dog on the Ship: The "Canis Major Dwarf Galaxy" as an Outlying Part of the Argo Star System
• Modeling the Stellar Populations in the Canis Major Over-Density: the Relation Between the Old and Young Populations
• A Canis Major over-density imaging survey. I. Stellar content and star-count maps : A distinctly elongated body of main sequence stars
• The Ultra Luminous X-ray sources in the High Velocity System of NGC 1275
• A radial velocity survey of low Galactic latitude structures: III. The Monoceros Ring in front of the Carina and Andromeda galaxies
• The Open Cluster NGC 7789: I. Radial Velocities for Giant Stars
• UVES observations of the Canis Major overdensity
• The metallicity of Palomar 1
• The old open clusters Saurer A, B and C revisited
• The Complex Chemical Abundances and Evolution of the Sagittarius Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy

Cited by in corpus (83)

• A strong redshift dependence of the broad absorption line quasar fraction
• Accreted versus In Situ Milky Way Globular Clusters
• Chemical abundance analysis of the Open Clusters Cr110, NGC2099 (M37), NGC2420, NGC7789 and M67 (NGC2682)
• A global view of the inner accretion and ejection flow around super massive black holes: radiation driven accretion disk winds in a physical context
• Feedback from central black holes in elliptical galaxies. I: models with either radiative or mechanical feedback but not both
• Broad Absorption Line Disappearance on Multi-Year Timescales in a Large Quasar Sample
• Active Galactic Nuclei Feedback in an Elliptical Galaxy with the Most Updated AGN Physics (I): Low-angular Momentum Case
• A High-Velocity Narrow Absorption Line Outflow in the Quasar J212329.46-005052.9
• Variability in Quasar Broad Absorption Line Outflows I. Trends in the Short-Term versus Long-Term Data
• Chemical abundance analysis of the Open Clusters Berkeley 32, NGC 752, Hyades and Praesepe
• On the metallicity of open clusters II. Spectroscopy
• Variability in quasar broad absorption line outflows II. Multi-epoch monitoring of SiIV and CIV BAL variability
• Variability in Quasar Broad Absorption Line Outflows III. What Happens on the Shortest Time-scales?
• Implications of Dramatic Broad Absorption Line Variability in the Quasar FBQS J1408+3054
• Extreme-Velocity Quasar Outflows and the Role of X-ray Shielding
• Emergence of a Broad-Absorption-Line Outflow in the Narrow-line Seyfert 1 Galaxy WPVS 007
• The rise of an ionized wind in the Narrow Line Seyfert 1 Galaxy Mrk 335 observed by XMM-Newton and HST
• The Evolution of Quasar CIV and SiIV Broad Absorption Lines Over Multi-Year Time Scales
• Evidence for Photoionization Driven Broad Absorption Line Variability
• The Extreme High-Velocity Outflow in Quasar PG0935+417
• On the large-scale outflows in active galactic nuclei: consequences of coupling the mass-supply rate and accretion luminosity
• Chemical signatures of the first star clusters
• Broad absorption line disappearance and emergence using multiple-epoch spectroscopy from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• AGN feedback in an isolated elliptical galaxy: the effect of strong radiative feedback in the kinetic mode
• A study of the X-rayed outflow of APM 08279+5255 through photoionization codes
• Variability in Low Ionization Broad Absorption Line Outflows
• The Transition from "Normal" to "Broad Absorption Line Quasar" of Ton 34
• Dynamically evolving Mg II broad absorption line flow in SDSS J133356.02+001229.1
• A Variable PV Broad Absorption Line and Quasar Outflow Energetics
• Synchrotron Emission from Elliptical Galaxies Consequent to AGN outbursts
• Monitoring the Variability of Intrinsic Absorption Lines in Quasar Spectra
• Probing the time variability of five Fe low broad absorption line quasars
• AGN feedback in elliptical galaxies: numerical simulations
• On the diversity and complexity of absorption line profiles produced by outflows in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Correlation between the variation of the ionizing continuum and broad absorption lines
• Kinematic parameters and membership probabilities of open clusters in the Bordeaux PM2000 catalogue
• Abundances and kinematics for ten anticentre open clusters
• Some Stars are Totally Metal: A New Mechanism Driving Dust Across Star-Forming Clouds, and Consequences for Planets, Stars, and Galaxies
• Discovery of the Transition of a Mini-Broad Absorption Line into Broad Absorption in the SDSS Quasar J115122.14+020426.3
• Emergence and Variability of Broad Absorption Line Quasar Outflows
• Narrow absorption lines complex I: one form of broad absorption line
• HST and Ground-Based Spectroscopy of Quasar Outflows: From Mini-BALs to BALs
• Narrow absorption line variability in repeat quasar observations from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Radiation driven outflow in active galactic nuclei: the feedback effects of scattered and reprocessed photons
• Narrow absorption lines with two observations of Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Evidence of Early Enrichment of the Galactic Disk by Large-Scale Winds
• Strong UV and X-ray variability of the Narrow Line Seyfert 1 Galaxy WPVS 007 -- on the nature of the X-ray low state
• Quasar broad absorption line variability measurements using reconstructions of un-absorbed spectra
• The Metallicity of the Open Cluster Tombaugh 2
• Distance, Energy, and Variability of Quasar Outflows: Two HST/COS epochs of LBQS 1206+1052
• Evidence for photoionization-driven variability in narrow absorption lines
• Emergences of C IV narrow absorption troughs in the quasar SDSS J095254.10+021932.8
• Broad absorption line disappearance/emergence in multiple ions in a weak emission-line quasar
• Resolving the Clumpy Structure of the Outflow Winds in the Gravitationally Lensed Quasar SDSS J1029+2623
• Deceleration of CIV and SiIV broad absorption lines in X-ray bright quasar SDSS-J092345+512710
• Rapidly varying Mg II broad absorption line in SDSS J133356.02+001229.1
• Spectroscopy along Multiple, Lensed Sightlines through Outflowing Winds in the Quasar SDSS J1029+2623
• Vanishing Absorption and Blueshifted Emission in FeLoBAL Quasars
• Galactic Winds across the Gas-Rich Merger Sequence: I. Highly Ionized N V and O VI Outflows in the QUEST Quasars
• Disappearance of a narrow Mg II absorption system with a measured velocity up to $166,000km{\mathrm{s}}^{-1}$
• Time variations of narrow absorption lines in high resolution quasar spectra
• An analysis of the most distant catalogued open clusters -- Re-assessing fundamental parameters with Gaia EDR3 and $\text{ASteCA}$
• Narrow Absorption Lines Complex. III. Gradual Transition from Type S to Type N Broad Absorption Line
• X-ray and multi-epoch optical/UV investigations of BAL to non-BAL quasar transformations
• Old open clusters and the Galactic metallicity gradient: Berkeley 20, Berkeley 66, and Tombaugh 2
• SDSS J1138+3517: A quasar showing remarkably variable broad absorption lines
• Multi-Sightline Observation of Narrow Absorption Lines in Lensed Quasar SDSS J1029+2623
• Correlations between the Variation of the Ionizing Continuum and Broad Absorption Lines in Individual Quasars
• A Catalog of High-Velocity CIV Mini-BALs in the VLT-UVES and Keck-HIRES Archives
• Physical properties and the variability mechanism of the He I outflow in NGC 4151
• Is there a connection between Broad Absorption Line Quasars and Narrow Line Seyfert 1 galaxies?
• The Gaia-ESO Survey DR5.1 and Gaia DR3 GSP-Spec: a comparative analysis
• The physical constraints on a new LoBAL QSO at z=4.82
• Direct Measurement of Quasar Outflow Wind Acceleration
• On the Origin of the Dramatic Spectral Variability of WPVS 007
• Spectroscopic Observations of the Outflowing Wind in the Lensed Quasar SDSS J1001+5027
• Signature of a chemical spread in the open cluster M37
• Triggering star formation by both radiative and mechanical active galactic nucleus feedback
• MCMC-based Voigt Profile fitting to a Mini-BAL System in the Quasar UM675
• Unveiling the X-ray/UV properties of disk winds in active galactic nuclei using broad and mini-broad absorption line quasars
• Hubble Space Telescope Observations of BALQSO Ton 34 Reveal a Connection between the Broad Line Region and the BAL Outflow
• Ultra-dense Broad-line Region Scale Outflow in Highly Reddened Quasar SDSS J145057.28+530007.6
• Report of IAU Commission 30 on Radial Velocities (2009-2012)