On the reliability of mass-loss-rate estimates for AGB stars
arXiv:0806.0517 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361:20078876
Abstract
In the recent literature there has been some doubt as to the reliability of CO multi-transitional line observations as a mass-loss-rate estimator for AGB stars. Mass-loss rates for 10 intermediate- to high-mass-loss-rate AGB stars are derived using a detailed non-LTE, non-local radiative transfer code based on the Monte-Carlo method to model the CO radio line intensities. The circumstellar envelopes are assumed to be spherically symmetric and formed by constant mass-loss rates. The energy balance is solved self-consistently and the effects of dust on the radiation field and thermal balance are included. An independent estimate of the mass-loss rate is also obtained from the combination of dust radiative transfer modelling with a dynamical model of the gas and dust particles. We find that the CO radio line intensities and shapes are successfully reproduced for the majority of our objects assuming a constant mass-loss rate. Moreover, the CO line intensities are only weakly dependent on the adopted micro-turbulent velocity, in contrast to recent claims in the literature. The two methods used in the present work to derive mass-loss-rates are consistent within a factor of ~3 for intermediate- to high-mass-loss-rate objects, indicating that this is a lower limit to the uncertainty in present mass-loss-rate estimates. We find a tentative trend with chemistry. Mass-loss rates from the dust/dynamical model are systematically higher than those from the CO model for the carbon stars and vice versa for the M-type stars. This could be ascribed to a discrepancy in the adopted CO/H_2-abundance ratio, but we caution that the sample is small and systematic errors cannot be excluded.
arXiv comment18 pages, 17 figures, accepted for publication in A&A
References in corpus (27)
- An atomic and molecular database for analysis of submillimetre line observations
- Self-similarity and scaling behavior of IR emission from radiatively heated dust: I. Theory
- Evolution of asymptotic giant branch stars I. Updated synthetic TP-AGB models and their basic calibration
- Too little radiation pressure on dust in the winds of oxygen-rich AGB stars
- Models of circumstellar molecular radio line emission: Mass loss rates for a sample of bright carbon stars
- Nucleosynthesis of light elements inside thermally pulsing AGB stars I: the case of intermediate-mass stars
- Multiple Molecular Winds in Evolved Stars I. A Survey of CO(2-1) and CO(3-2) Emission from 45 Nearby AGB Stars
- Mass loss rates of a sample of irregular and semiregular M-type AGB-variables
- `Thermal' SiO radio line emission towards M-type AGB stars: a probe of circumstellar dust formation and dynamics
- Imaging the circumstellar envelopes of AGB stars
- Circumstellar water vapour in M-type AGB stars: Radiative transfer models, abundances and predictions for HIFI
- Dust-enshrouded Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars in the Solar Neighbourhood
- Origin of quasi-periodic shells in dust forming AGB winds
- Molecular abundances in carbon-rich circumstellar envelopes
- The circumstellar envelope of IRC+10216 from milli-arcsecond to arcmin scales
- Mass loss and rotational CO emission from Asymptotic Giant Branch stars
- Winds of M- and S-type AGB stars: an unorthodox suggestion for the driving mechanism
- Temporal Variations of Mid-IR Spectra in Late-Type Stars
- Properties of detached shells around carbon stars: Evidence of interacting winds
- Probing the mass loss history of carbon stars using CO line and dust continuum emission
- Sub-au imaging of water vapour clouds around four Asymptotic Giant Branch stars
- Mass-loss properties of S-stars on the AGB
- Carbon-Rich Mira Variables: Kinematics and Absolute Magnitudes
- Three-component modeling of C-rich AGB star winds. II. The effects of drift in long-period variables
- Maps of the Molecular Emission Around 18 Evolved Stars
- Continuum emission around AGB stars at 1.2 mm
- Three-component modeling of C-rich AGB star winds I. Method and first results
Cited by in corpus (101)
- Probing the mass-loss history of AGB and red supergiant stars from CO rotational line profiles - II. CO line survey of evolved stars: derivation of mass-loss rate formulae
- The mass-loss rates of red supergiants and the de Jager prescription
- Production of dust by massive stars at high redshift
- Unexpectedly large mass loss during the thermal pulse cycle of the red giant R Sculptoris!
- The wind speeds, dust content, and mass-loss rates of evolved AGB and RSG stars at varying metallicity
- (Sub)stellar companions shape the winds of evolved stars
- Extended rotating disks around post-AGB stars
- Chemical equilibrium in AGB atmospheres: Successes, failures, and prospects for small molecules, clusters, and condensates
- Circumstellar molecular line emission from S-type AGB stars: Mass-loss rates and SiO abundances
- The abundance of HCN in circumstellar envelopes of AGB stars of different chemical types
- Dynamic atmospheres and winds of cool luminous giants, I. AlO and silicate dust in the close vicinity of M-type AGB stars
- New observations and models of circumstellar CO line emission of AGB stars in the Herschel SUCCESS programme
- Distance estimates for AGB stars from parallax measurements
- Herschel/HIFI observations of O-rich AGB stars : molecular inventory
- Synthetic photometry for carbon-rich giants. IV. An extensive grid of dynamic atmosphere and wind models
- The Red Rectangle: Its Shaping Mechanism and its Source of Ultraviolet Photons
- Circumstellar molecular composition of the oxygen-rich AGB star IK~Tau: II. In-depth non-LTE chemical abundance analysis
- Evolution and Mass Loss of Cool Ageing Stars: a Daedalean Story
- A HIFI view on circumstellar H2O in M-type AGB stars: radiative transfer, velocity profiles, and H2O line cooling
- The 12CO/13CO ratio in AGB stars of different chemical type-Connection to the 12C/13C ratio and the evolution along the AGB
- The evolution of DARWIN: current status of wind models for AGB stars
- An extensive grid of DARWIN models for M-type AGB stars I. Mass-loss rates and other properties of dust-driven winds
- Gas phase atomic metals in the circumstellar envelope of IRC+10216
- High-resolution HST/ACS images of detached shells around carbon stars
- IRC +10 216 in 3-D: morphology of a TP-AGB star envelope
- Detailed modelling of the circumstellar molecular line emission of the S-type AGB star W Aquilae
- On the physical structure of IRC+10216. Ground-based and Herschel observations of CO and CCH
- Reduction of the maximum mass-loss rate of OH/IR stars due to unnoticed binary interaction
- Carbon star wind models at solar and sub-solar metallicities: a comparative study. I. Mass loss and the properties of dust-driven winds
- ATOMIUM: ALMA tracing the origins of molecules in dust forming oxygen rich M-type stars: Motivation, sample, calibration, and initial results
- Sulphur-bearing molecules in AGB stars I: The occurrence of hydrogen sulfide
- A New Method of Determining the Characteristics of Evolved Binary Systems Revealed in the Observed Circumstellar Patterns: Application to AFGL 3068
- ALMA detection of CO rotational line emission in red supergiant stars of the massive young star cluster RSGC1 -- Determination of a new mass-loss rate prescription for red supergiants
- The detached dust and gas shells around the carbon star U Ant
- Photodissociation of CO in the outflow of evolved stars
- Sulphur-bearing molecules in AGB stars II: Abundances and distributions of CS and SiS
- 870 um observations of evolved stars with LABOCA
- The wind of the M-type AGB star RT Virginis probed by VLTI/MIDI
- Atomium: A high-resolution view on the highly asymmetric wind of the AGB star Pi1 Gruis. I. First detection of a new companion and its effect on the inner wind
- Polarization of thermal molecular lines in the envelope of IK Tau
- The ALMA detection of CO rotational line emission in AGB stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- Searching for X-ray emission from AGB stars
- The abundance of S- and Si-bearing molecules in O-rich circumstellar envelopes of AGB stars
- The photodissociation of CO in circumstellar envelopes
- Interplay between pulsation, mass loss, and third dredge-up: More about Miras with and without technetium
- The Illumination and Growth of CRL 2688: An Analysis of New & Archival HST Observations
- SPH modelling of wind-companion interactions in eccentric AGB binary systems
- SHAPEMOL: a 3-D code for calculating CO line emission in planetary and protoplanetary nebulae. Detailed model fitting of the complex nebula NGC 6302
- Modeling the physical and excitation conditions of the molecular envelope of NGC 7027
- Constraints on the H2O formation mechanism in the wind of carbon-rich AGB stars
- Deep optical imaging of AGB circumstellar envelopes
- ALMA reveals sunburn: CO dissociation around AGB stars in the globular cluster 47 Tucanae
- CO envelope of the symbiotic star R Aqr seen by ALMA
- Pulsation-induced atmospheric dynamics in M-type AGB stars. Effects on wind properties, photometric variations and near-IR CO line profiles
- The mass-loss rates of red supergiants at low metallicity: Detection of rotational CO emission from two red supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- Determining mass accretion and jet mass-loss rates in post-asymptotic giant branch binary systems
- The multi-scale environment of RS Cnc from CO and HI observations
- HI and CO in the circumstellar environment of the oxygen-rich AGB star RX Lep
- First detection of rotational CO line emission in an RGB star
- Extremely Strong ^{13}CO J=3-2 Line in the "Water Fountain" IRAS 16342-3814: Evidence for the Hot-Bottom Burning
- 3D simulations of AGB stellar winds -- II. Ray-tracer implementation and impact of radiation on the outflow morphology
- Dust in AGB wind-ISM interaction regions
- Chemical modelling of dust-gas chemistry within AGB outflows III. Photoprocessing of the ice and return to the ISM
- EU Del: exploring the onset of pulsation-driven winds in giant stars
- X-ray signature of antistars in the Galaxy
- DEATHSTAR: Nearby AGB stars with the Atacama Compact Array II. CO envelope sizes and asymmetries: The S-type stars
- First detection of AlF line emission towards M-type AGB stars
- Radiation-pressure-driven sub-Keplerian rotation of the disc around the AGB star L2 Pup
- Properties of dust in the detached shells around U Ant, DR Ser, and V644 Sco
- On the detection of CO and mass loss of Bulge OH/IR stars
- A HIFI preview of warm molecular gas around chi Cyg : first detection of H2O emission toward an S-type AGB star
- The dust and gas content of carbon stars toward the Galactic Halo
- A detailed view on the circumstellar environment of the M-type AGB star EP Aquarii I. High-resolution ALMA and SPHERE observations
- H12CN and H13CN excitation analysis in the circumstellar outflow of R Scl
- CO line observations of OH/IR stars in the inner Galactic Bulge: Characteristics of stars at the tip of the AGB
- Dissecting the central regions of OH 231.8 + 4.2 with ALMA: a salty rotating disk at the base of a young bipolar outflow
- Infrared photometry and evolution of mass-losing AGB stars. III. Mass loss rates of MS and S stars
- Resolving asymmetries along the pulsation cycle of the Mira star X Hya
- Deep into the Water Fountains: The case of IRAS 18043-2116
- Detection of the S(1) Rotational Line of H2 toward IRC+10216: A Simultaneous Measurement of Mass-Loss Rate and CO Abundance
- Dynamical Effects of Colliding Outflows in Binary Systems
- Characterising the AGB bump and its potential to constrain mixing processes in stellar interiors
- Circumstellar CO J = 3-2 detected around the evolving metal-poor ([Fe/H] ~ -1.15 dex) AGB star RU Vulpeculae
- Disentangling physics and chemistry in AGB outflows: revealing degeneracies when adding complexity
- Sensitivity study of chemistry in AGB outflows using chemical kinetics
- The impact of third dredge-up on the mass loss of Mira variables
- Warm CO in evolved stars from the THROES catalogue. II. Herschel/PACS spectroscopy of C-rich envelopes
- Multi-line study of the radial extent of SiO, CS, and SiS in AGB envelopes
- SPH modelling of AGB wind morphology in hierarchical triple systems \& comparison to observation of R Aql
- A 3 mm Molecular Line Survey toward The C-star Envelope CIT 6
- CO J = 2 - 1 Emission from Evolved Stars in the Galactic Bulge
- CO in OH/IR stars close to the Galactic centre
- On the Thermally Pulsing Asymptotic Giant Branch Contribution to the Light of Nearby Disk Galaxies
- Extended far-UV emission surrounding asymptotic giant branch stars as seen by GALEX
- CO observations of water-maser post-AGB stars and detection of a high-velocity outflow in IRAS 15452-5459
- Infrared interferometric imaging of the compact dust disk around the AGB star HR3126 with the bipolar Toby Jug Nebula
- Charting circumstellar chemistry of carbon-rich asymptotic giant branch stars. II. Abundances and spatial distributions of CS
- Exploring circumstellar chemistry in X-ray emitting AGB stars
- Impact of a binary companion in AGB outflows on CO spectral lines
- The Nearby Evolved Stars Survey III: First data release of JCMT CO-line observations
- The Nearby Evolved Stars Survey II: Constructing a volume-limited sample and first results from the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope