How Gaussian competition leads to lumpy or uniform species distributions

Abstract

A central model in theoretical ecology considers the competition of a range of species for a broad spectrum of resources. Recent studies have shown that essentially two different outcomes are possible. Either the species surviving competition are more or less uniformly distributed over the resource spectrum, or their distribution is 'lumped' (or 'clumped'), consisting of clusters of species with similar resource use that are separated by gaps in resource space. Which of these outcomes will occur crucially depends on the competition kernel, which reflects the shape of the resource utilization pattern of the competing species. Most models considered in the literature assume a Gaussian competition kernel. This is unfortunate, since predictions based on such a Gaussian assumption are not robust. In fact, Gaussian kernels are a border case scenario, and slight deviations from this function can lead to either uniform or lumped species distributions. Here we illustrate the non-robustness of the Gaussian assumption by simulating different implementations of the standard competition model with constant carrying capacity. In this scenario, lumped species distributions can come about by secondary ecological or evolutionary mechanisms or by details of the numerical implementation of the model. We analyze the origin of this sensitivity and discuss it in the context of recent applications of the model.

11 pages, 3 figures, revised version

References in corpus (4)

• Species clustering in competitive Lotka-Volterra models
• Multimodal pattern formation in phenotype distributions of sexual populations
• Species competition: coexistence, exclusion and clustering
• Neutral Evolution as Diffusion in phenotype space: reproduction with mutation but without selection

Cited by in corpus (15)

• Fairy circle landscapes under the sea
• Species competition: coexistence, exclusion and clustering
• Demographic noise can lead to the spontaneous formation of species
• Formation of localized structures in bistable systems through nonlocal spatial coupling II: The nonlocal Ginzburg Landau Equation
• How self-regulation, the storage effect and their interaction contribute to coexistence in stochastic and seasonal environments
• A model for the evolutionary diversification of religions
• Spontaneous genetic clustering in populations of competing organisms
• Translucent windows: How uncertainty in competitive interactions impacts detection of community pattern
• Continuously stable strategies as evolutionary branching points
• Spatial patterns of competing random walkers
• A framework for analyzing ecological trait-based models in multi-dimensional niche spaces
• Self-localized states in species competition
• Ginzburg-Landau amplitude equation for nonlinear nonlocal models
• The role of demographic stochasticity in a speciation model with sexual reproduction
• Vegetation pattern formation induced by local growth outpacing susceptibility to non-local competition