Protostellar collapse: A comparison between SPH and AMR calculations

Abstract

The development of parallel supercomputers allows today the detailed study of the collapse and the fragmentation of prestellar cores with increasingly accurate numerical simulations. Thanks to the advances in sub-millimeter observations, a wide range of observed initial conditions enable us to study the different modes of low-mass star formation. The challenge for the simulations is to reproduce the observational results. Two main numerical methods, namely AMR and SPH, are widely used to simulate the collapse and the fragmentation of prestellar cores. We compare thoroughly these two methods within their standard framework. We use the AMR code RAMSES and the SPH code DRAGON. Our physical model is as simple as possible and consists of an isothermal sphere rotating around the z-axis. We first study the conservation of angular momentum as a function of the resolution. Then, we explore a wide range of simulation parameters to study the fragmentation of prestellar cores. There seems to be a convergence between the two methods, provided resolution in each case is sufficient. Resolution criteria adapted to our physical cases, in terms of resolution per Jeans mass, for an accurate description of the formation of protostellar cores are deduced from the present study. This convergence is encouraging for future work in simulations of low-mass star formation, providing the aforementioned criteria are fulfilled. Higher resolution figures can be downloaded at http://www-dapnia.cea.fr/Projets/COAST/paper_amrvssph.pdf

16 pages, 16 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (14)

• Cosmological Hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: a new high resolution code called RAMSES
• Modelling Accretion in Protobinary Systems
• The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
• A High Order Godunov Scheme with Constrained Transport and Adaptive Mesh Refinement for Astrophysical MHD
• Simulating star formation in molecular cloud cores I. The influence of low levels of turbulence on fragmentation and multiplicity
• Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with particle splitting, applied to self-gravitating collapse
• Towards optimal softening in 3D N-body codes: I. Minimizing the force error
• Fragmentation of a Molecular Cloud Core versus Fragmentation of the Massive Protoplanetary Disk in the Main Accretion Phase
• Numerical requirements for simulations of self gravitating and non-self gravitating disks
• Tests of Spurious Transport in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
• Resolution requirements for simulating gravitational fragmentation using SPH
• Protostellar collapse induced by compression. II: rotation and fragmentation
• Adaptive smoothing lengths in SPH
• Particle Methods in Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics

Cited by in corpus (40)

• Modeling Collapse and Accretion in Turbulent Gas Clouds: Implementation and Comparison of Sink Particles in AMR and SPH
• Radiation Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of Protostellar Collapse: Protostellar Core Formation
• Disk formation during collapse of magnetized protostellar cores
• Collapse, outflows and fragmentation of massive, turbulent and magnetized prestellar barotropic cores
• Radiation Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of Protostellar Collapse: Non-Ideal Magnetohydrodynamic Effects and Early Formation of Circumstellar Disks
• Toward understanding the formation of multiple systems - A pilot IRAM-PdBI survey of Class 0 objects
• Protostellar collapse: radiative and magnetic feedbacks on small scale fragmentation
• Radiation hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement and application to prestellar core collapse. I Methods
• Towards a more realistic sink particle algorithm for the RAMSES code
• Moving Mesh Cosmology: Properties of Gas Disks
• Protostellar birth with ambipolar and ohmic diffusion
• Algorithmic comparisons of decaying, isothermal, supersonic turbulence
• Tidally induced brown dwarf and planet formation in circumstellar discs
• Synthetic observations of first hydrostatic cores in collapsing low-mass dense cores. I. Spectral energy distributions and evolutionary sequence
• A fast, robust, and simple implicit method for adaptive time-stepping on adaptive mesh-refinement grids
• Physical and radiative properties of the first core accretion shock
• Protostellar collapse: the conditions to form dust rich protoplanetary disks
• The fragmentation of expanding shells I: Limitations of the thin--shell approximation
• Formation and evolution of protostellar accretion discs. II. From 3D simulation to a simple semi-analytic model of Class 0/I discs
• Small dust grain dynamics on adaptive mesh-refinement grids. I. Methods
• Protostellar collapse and fragmentation using an MHD GADGET
• Convergence of AMR and SPH simulations - I. Hydrodynamical resolution and convergence tests
• Numerical heat conduction in hydrodynamical models of colliding hypersonic flows
• Simulating star formation in molecular cloud cores IV. The role of turbulence and thermodynamics
• Synthetic observations of first hydrostatic cores in collapsing low-mass dense cores II. Simulated ALMA dust emission maps
• Zooming in on supermassive black holes: how resolving their gas cloud host renders their accretion episodic
• The role of the H${}_2$ adiabatic index in the formation of the first stars
• Chemical evolution during the formation of a protoplanetary disk
• On the origin of magnetic fields in stars II: The effect of numerical resolution
• The role of magnetic fields in the formation of multiple massive stars
• Dynamics of dust grains in turbulent molecular clouds. Conditions for decoupling and limits of different numerical implementations
• Collapse and Fragmentation of Molecular Cloud Cores. X. Magnetic Braking of Prolate and Oblate Cores
• Consistent SPH Simulations of Protostellar Collapse and Fragmentation
• Disk fragmentation around a massive protostar: a comparison of two three-dimensional codes
• Impetus: Consistent SPH calculations of 3D spherical Bondi accretion onto a black hole
• Shell instability of a collapsing dense core
• Two-dimensional AMR simulations of colliding flows
• Protostellar disc structure and dynamics during star formation from cloud-scale initial conditions
• The early phase of multiple proto-stellar system emerged from collapse of molecular cloud under various initial thermal states
• On the interaction of a thin, supersonic shell with a molecular cloud