Can Neutrinos be Degenerate in Mass?

Abstract

We reconsider the possibility that the masses of the three light neutrinos of the Standard Model might be almost degenerate and close to the present upper limits from Tritium beta decay and cosmology. In such a scenario, the cancellations required by the latest upper limit on neutrinoless double-beta decay enforce near-maximal mixing that may be compatible only with the vacuum-oscillation scenario for solar neutrinos. We argue that the mixing angles yielded by degenerate neutrino mass-matrix textures are not in general stable under small perturbations. We evaluate within the MSSM the generation-dependent one-loop renormalization of neutrino mass-matrix textures that yielded degenerate masses and large mixing at the tree level. We find that m_{nu_e} > m_{nu_mu} > m_{nu_tau} after renormalization, excluding MSW effects on solar neutrinos. We verify that bimaximal mixing is not stable, and show that the renormalized masses and mixing angles are not compatible with all the experimental constraints, even for tanbeta as low as unity. These results hold whether the neutrino masses are generated by a see-saw mechanism with heavy neutrinos weighing approx. 10^{13} GeV or by non-renormalizable interactions at a scale approx. 10^5 GeV. We also comment on the corresponding renormalization effects in the minimal Standard Model, in which m_{nu_e} < m_{nu_mu} < m_{nu_tau}. Although a solar MSW effect is now possible, the perturbed neutrino masses and mixings are still not compatible with atmospheric- and solar-neutrino data.

17 pages, 4 figures. Corrections to typos and notation: rephrased and clarified statements on impact of induced deviations from bimaximal mixing

Cited by in corpus (161)

• Non-Baryonic Dark Matter - Observational Evidence and Detection Methods
• Mass and Flavor Mixing Schemes of Quarks and Leptons
• Theory of Neutrinos: A White Paper
• Flavour physics of leptons and dipole moments
• Running Neutrino Masses, Mixings and CP Phases: Analytical Results and Phenomenological Consequences
• Flavor structures of charged fermions and massive neutrinos
• Large Mixing Angle MSW and Atmospheric Neutrinos from Single Right-Handed Neutrino Dominance and U(1) Family Symmetry
• Neutrino Mass Models
• Neutrino Mass Operator Renormalization Revisited
• A 2-3 Symmetry in Neutrino Oscillations
• Enhanced lepton flavour violation in the supersymmetric inverse seesaw model
• Models of Neutrino Masses and Mixings
• General RG Equations for Physical Neutrino Parameters and their Phenomenological Implications
• Neutrino masses and the number of neutrino species from WMAP and 2dFGRS
• Constructing the large mixing angle MNS matrix in see-saw models with right-handed neutrino dominance
• Neutrino oscillations and signals in beta and 0nu2beta experiments
• A review of mu-tau flavor symmetry in neutrino physics
• Quantum corrections to neutrino masses and mixing angles
• Progress in the physics of massive neutrinos
• Neutrino mass spectrum and neutrinoless double beta decay
• tau -> mu gamma and mu -> e gamma as probes of neutrino mass models
• Non-vanishing $U_{e3}$ and $\cos 2{\theta }_{23}$ from a broken $Z_2$ symmetry
• Seesaw and Lepton Flavour Violation in SUSY SO(10)
• Massive Neutrinos and Flavour Violation
• Fixed points in the evolution of neutrino mixings
• Quasi-Degenerate Neutrino Mass Spectrum, μ-> e + γDecay and Leptogenesis
• Supersymmetric Seesaw without Singlet Neutrinos: Neutrino Masses and Lepton-Flavour Violation
• Running Neutrino Masses, Leptonic Mixing Angles and CP-Violating Phases: From $M_{\mathrm{Z}}$ to ${\Lambda }_{\mathrm{GUT}}$
• Pieces of the Flavour Puzzle
• Renormalisation Group Analysis of Single Right-handed Neutrino Dominance
• Neutrino Mass Spectrum and Future Beta Decay Experiments
• One-loop Corrected Neutrino Masses and Mixing in the Supersymmetric Standard Model without R-parity
• Generation of large flavor mixing from radiative corrections
• Large Solar Angle and Seesaw Mechanism: a Bottom-up Perspective
• Predictive Grand Unified Textures for Quark and Neutrino Masses and Mixings
• Fermion Masses and Mixing and CP-Violation in SO(10) Models with Family Symmetries
• The LMA Solution from Bimaximal Lepton Mixing at the GUT Scale by Renormalization Group Running
• Structure of neutrino mass matrix and CP violation
• Quark lepton complementarity and renormalization group effects
• Predictions for the neutrino parameters in the minimal gauged U(1)${}_{L_{\mu }-L_{\tau }}$ model
• Majorana CP-Violating Phases, RG Running of Neutrino Mixing Parameters and Charged Lepton Flavour Violating Decays
• QLC relation and neutrino mass hierarchy
• Limits on Neutrino Mass from Cosmic Structure Formation
• Neutrino Unification
• Radiative Corrections to Neutrino Mixing and CP Violation in the Minimal Seesaw Model with Leptogenesis
• Importance of Threshold Corrections in Quark-Lepton Complementarity
• Can cosmology detect hierarchical neutrino masses?
• Inverted Hierarchy Models of Neutrino Masses
• Large U_{e3} and Tri-bimaximal Mixing
• Status of Evidence for Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay
• Radiative magnification of neutrino mixings and a natural explanation of the neutrino anomalies
• The minimal seesaw and leptogenesis models
• Implications of observed neutrinoless double beta decay
• Quark-lepton complementarity with quasidegenerate Majorana neutrinos
• Corrections to Tri-bimaximal Neutrino Mixing: Renormalization and Planck Scale Effects
• Supergraph Techniques and Two-Loop Beta-Functions for Renormalizable and Non-Renormalizable Operators
• Neutrino masses and mixing with seesaw mechanism and universal breaking of extended democracy
• Gauge and Scheme Dependence of Mixing Matrix Renormalization
• Cosmological neutrinos
• U(e3) from physics above the GUT scale
• Radiatively broken symmetries of nonhierarchical neutrinos
• Lepton Flavor Violating Process in Degenerate and Inverse-Hierarchical Neutrino Models
• Renormalization group evolution of neutrino masses and mixing in the Type-III seesaw mechanism
• Bi-maximal Neutrino Mixings And Proton Decay In SO(10) With Anomalous Flavor $\mathcal{U}(1)$
• Lepton Flavor Violating Process in Bi-maximal texture of Neutrino Mixings
• Quark-lepton complementarity, neutrino and standard model data predict $({\theta }_{13}^{PMNS}=9_{-2}^{+1}{)}^{\circ }$
• Cosmological limit on the neutrino mass
• Neutrino Mass Matrix with Two Zeros and Leptogenesis
• Neutrino Mass from Laboratory: Contribution of Double Beta Decay to the Neutrino Mass Matrix
• Large Neutrino Mixing from Renormalization Group Evolution
• The $\mu$-$\tau$ reflection symmetry of Majorana neutrinos
• Reconstructing the two right-handed neutrino model
• Implications of a Massless Neutralino for Neutrino Physics
• Permutation Symmetry for Neutrino and Charged-Lepton Mass Matrices
• Breakings of the neutrino mu-tau reflection symmetry
• Neutrino Mixings and Leptonic CP Violation from CKM Matrix and Majorana Phases
• Stability of Neutrino Mass Degeneracy
• Radiative Generation of the LMA Solution from Small Solar Neutrino Mixing at the GUT Scale
• Slepton Flavour Mixing and Neutrino Masses
• Neutrino mu-tau reflection symmetry and its breaking in the minimal seesaw
• Radiative corrections to neutrino mass matrix in the Standard Model and beyond
• The renormalization group effect to the bi-maximal mixing
• See-saw Mechanisms for Dirac and Majorana Neutrino Masses
• Running of Low-Energy Neutrino Masses, Mixing Angles and CP Violation
• Large mixing angles for neutrinos from infrared fixed points
• Baryogenesis and Degenerate Neutrinos
• Small entries of neutrino mass matrices
• Predictive Framework with a Pair of Degenerate Neutrinos at a high scale
• Understanding neutrino properties from decoupling right-handed neutrinos and extra Higgs doublets
• In Quest of Neutrino Masses at $\mathcal{O}$(eV) Scale
• Renormalization group evolution of neutrino masses and mixing in seesaw models: A review
• New supersymmetric source of neutrino masses and mixings
• Deviation from tri-bimaximal mixings in two types of inverted hierarchical neutrino mass models
• Radiative origin of solar scale and U_{e3}
• Flavour Symmetries and Kahler Operators
• Neutrino oscillations and neutrinoless double beta decay
• One diagonal texture or cofactor zero of the neutrino mass matrix
• Constraints on Neutrino Mixing Parameters By Observation of Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay
• Neutrino CP violating parameters from nontrivial quark-lepton correlation: a S3xGUT model
• Bi-maximal neutrino mixing and small U_{e3} from Abelian flavor symmetry
• Large Lepton Mixings Induced by Sterile Neutrino
• Leptogenesis in Neutrino Textures with Two Zeros
• Implications of the Renormalization Group Equations in Three-Neutrino Models with Two-fold Degeneracy
• Neutrino Mass Models
• Lower Bound on |U_{e3}|^2 from Single and Double Beta Decay Experiments
• Renormalization of the neutrino mass matrix
• Lepton Flavor Violation and Radiative Neutrino Masses
• Radiative Generation of Quark Masses and Mixing Angles in the Two Higgs Doublet Model
• Radiative and Seesaw Threshold Corrections to the $S_3$ Symmetric Neutrino Mass Matrix
• Correlation of normal neutrino mass ordering with upper octant of ${\theta }_{23}^{}$ and third quadrant of $\delta$ via RGE-induced $\mu$-$\tau$ symmetry breaking
• Neutrino textures and charged lepton flavour violation in light of theta13, MEG and LHC data
• Large Mixing Angle MSW Solution in U(1) Flavor Symmetry
• Large Neutrino Mixing with Universal Strength of Yukawa Couplings
• Renormalization group evolution of neutrino mixing parameters near ${\theta }_{13}=0$ and models with vanishing ${\theta }_{13}$ at the high scale
• Majorana neutrinos with split fermions in extra dimensions
• A short survey of matter-antimatter evolution in the primordial universe
• Quasi-degenerate neutrinos and tri-bi-maximal mixing
• Littlest mu-tau seesaw
• Power law enhancement of neutrino mixing angles in extra dimensions
• Renormalization Group Evolution of Neutrino Parameters in Presence of Seesaw Threshold Effects and Majorana Phases
• Double Beta Decay Constraints on Neutrino Masses and Mixing; Reanalysis with KamLAND Data
• Predictions from non trivial Quark-Lepton complementarity
• Grand Unification of Flavor Mixings
• Impact of RGE-induced $\mu -\tau$ Reflection Symmetry Breaking on the Effective Majorana Neutrino Mass in $0\nu \beta \beta$ Decay
• Quasi-degenerate neutrinos and tri-bi-maximal mixing
• Origin of neutrino masses and mixings
• Stability of Leptonic Self-complementarity
• Renormalization Invariants of the Neutrino Mass Matrix
• Summary of Neutrino 2000
• Numerical consistency check between two approaches to radiative corrections for neutrino masses and mixings
• Neutrino seesaw mechanism with texture zeros
• Renormalization-Group Effects in the SO(3) Gauge Model With Nearly Degenerate Neutrino Masses and Bi-maximal Mixing
• Renormalization Group Equation of Quark-Lepton Mass Matrices in the SO(10) Model with Two Higgs Scalars
• Renormalization group evolution induced leptogenesis in the minimal seesaw model with the trimaximal mixing and mu-tau reflection symmetry
• Leptonic unitarity triangles: RGE running effects and $\mu$-$\tau$ reflection symmetry breaking
• Lower Bounds on U_{e3}
• Lowering solar mixing angle in inverted hierarchy without charged lepton corrections
• SUSY Seesaw and FCNC
• Gauge Origin of Baryon Number Conservation and Suppressed Neutrino Masses From Five Dimensions
• Neutrino Oscillations: Status, Prospects and Opportunities at a Neutrino Factory
• Possible Flavor Mixing Structures of Lepton Mass Matrices
• Simiplified textures of the seesaw model for the trimaximal neutrino mixings
• Radiative generation of neutrino mixing: degenerate masses and threshold corrections
• Quark-Lepton Complementarity Predictions for ${\theta }_{23}^{pmns}$ and CP Violation
• Theta_{13}, Rare Decays and Leptonic CP Violation
• Accurate renormalization group analyses in neutrino sector
• Supersymmetric threshold corrections to Δm^2_{\odot}
• The translational $\mu$-$\tau$ reflection symmetry of Majorana neutrinos
• Renormalization Group Evolution of the Non-Unitary operator
• Maximal Neutrino Mixing from an Attractive Infrared Fixed Point
• Threshold effects and renormalization group evolution of neutrino parameters in TeV scale seesaw models
• Particular textures of the minimal seesaw model
• Renormalization effects on neutrino masses and mixing in a string-inspired SU(4) X SU(2)_L X SU(2)_R X U(1)_X model
• Renormalization group invariants in neutrino sector
• Neutrino Oscillations Due to Nonuniversal Gauge Interactions in the Weak Sector
• Predictions of effective Majorana neutrino mass under radiative corrections to $\mu -\tau$ reflection symmetry
• Running of neutrino mass parameters in the Zee model
• RGE-induced $\mu$-$\tau$ symmetry breaking: an analysis of the latest T2K results
• Neutrino physics from cosmological observations
• $\nu -K^0$ Analogy, Dirac-Majorana Neutrino Duality and the Neutrino Oscillations
• Running neutrino masses and mixing in a SU(4) x SU(2)^2 x U(1)_X model