Is Barbero's Hamiltonian formulation a Gauge Theory of Lorentzian Gravity?

Abstract

This letter is a critique of Barbero's constrained Hamiltonian formulation of General Relativity on which current work in Loop Quantum Gravity is based. While we do not dispute the correctness of Barbero's formulation of general relativity, we offer some criticisms of an aesthetic nature. We point out that unlike Ashtekar's complex SU(2) connection, Barbero's real SO(3) connection does not admit an interpretation as a space-time gauge field. We show that if one tries to interpret Barbero's real SO(3) connection as a space-time gauge field, the theory is not diffeomorphism invariant. We conclude that Barbero's formulation is not a gauge theory of gravity in the sense that Ashtekar's Hamiltonian formulation is. The advantages of Barbero's real connection formulation have been bought at the price of giving up the description of gravity as a gauge field.

12 pages, no figures, revised in the light of referee's comments, accepted for publication in Classical and Quantum Gravity

References in corpus (1)

• Logarithmic correction to the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy

Cited by in corpus (61)

• Background Independent Quantum Gravity: A Status Report
• Fundamental Structure of Loop Quantum Gravity
• Loop quantum gravity: an outside view
• Non-extensive Statistical Mechanics and Black Hole Entropy From Quantum Geometry
• SU(2) Loop Quantum Gravity seen from Covariant Theory
• Fermions in Ashtekar-Barbero Connections Formalism for Arbitrary Values of the Immirzi Parameter
• Covariant Effective Action for Loop Quantum Cosmology a la Palatini
• The Superspace of Geometrodynamics
• Spin Foams and Canonical Quantization
• On choice of connection in loop quantum gravity
• Area spectrum in Lorentz covariant loop gravity
• Classical and Quantum Features of the Mixmaster Singularity
• Spin Networks for Non-Compact Groups
• Deformation Operators of Spin Networks and Coarse-Graining
• Critical Overview of Loops and Foams
• Hilbert space structure of covariant loop quantum gravity
• Spherically symmetric sector of self dual Ashtekar gravity coupled to matter: Anomaly-free algebra of constraints with holonomy corrections
• Geometric temperature and entropy of quantum isolated horizons
• CFT/Gravity Correspondence on the Isolated Horizon
• The Thiemann Complexifier and the CVH algebra for Classical and Quantum FLRW Cosmology
• Linking loop quantum gravity quantization ambiguities with phenomenology
• A new look at Lorentz-Covariant Loop Quantum Gravity
• The Fock Space of Loopy Spin Networks for Quantum Gravity
• A note on the Holst action, the time gauge, and the Barbero-Immirzi parameter
• Testing the role of the Barbero-Immirzi parameter and the choice of connection in Loop Quantum Gravity
• Horizon entropy with loop quantum gravity methods
• Loop Quantum Cosmology with Complex Ashtekar Variables
• Gravitational dynamics: A novel shift in the Hamiltonian paradigm
• A Lorentz-Covariant Connection for Canonical Gravity
• Reality conditions for Ashtekar gravity from Lorentz-covariant formulation
• Loop quantum cosmology with self-dual variables
• Quantization of diffeomorphism invariant theories of connections with a non-compact structure group - an example
• Spontaneously broken Lorentz symmetry for Hamiltonian gravity
• On a Covariant Formulation of the Barbero-Immirzi Connection
• Anisotropic loop quantum cosmology with self-dual variables
• A Note on Black Hole Entropy in Loop Quantum Gravity
• Extent of the Immirzi Ambiguity in Quantum General Relativity
• Deformed covariance in spherically symmetric vacuum models of loop quantum gravity: Consistency in Euclidean and self-dual gravity
• From Euclidean to Lorentzian Loop Quantum Gravity via a Positive Complexifier
• Ashtekar-Barbero holonomy on the hyperboloid: Immirzi parameter as a Cut-off for Quantum Gravity
• Loop Quantum Gravity and Quantum Information
• Area Propagator and Boosted Spin Networks in Loop Quantum Gravity
• Four-Dimensional Entropy from Three-Dimensional Gravity
• Canonical quantum gravity and consistent discretizations
• Quantization of static space-times
• Three-geometry and reformulation of the Wheeler-DeWitt equation
• Canonical Gravity, Diffeomorphisms and Objective Histories
• Shape Dynamical Loop Gravity from a Conformal Immirzi Parameter
• A Wick rotation for EPRL spin foam models
• Immirzi Ambiguity in the Kinematics of Quantum General Relativity
• Towards a general solution of the Hamiltonian constraints of General Relativity
• Inducing Barbero-Immirzi Connections along SU(2)-reductions of Bundles on Spacetime
• Simplicity constraints: a 3d toy-model for Loop Quantum Gravity
• Introduction to Loop Quantum Gravity. The Holst's action and the covariant formalism
• Barbero-Immirzi connections and how to build them
• Spacetime Quanta? : The Discrete Spectrum of a Quantum Spacetime Four-Volume Operator in Unimodular Loop Quantum Cosmology
• General structure of the solutions of the Hamiltonian constraints of gravity
• The Space of Connections as the Arena for (Quantum) Gravity
• Generalized BF state in quantum gravity
• Note on $SU(2)$ isolated horizon
• Holographic bound in covariant loop quantum gravity