Note on isolated horizon
arXiv:1809.03483 · doi:10.1088/1361-6382/ab7dd7
Abstract
We point out that the symplectic structure, written in terms of the Sen-Ashtekar-Immirzi-Barbero variables, of a spacetime admitting an isolated horizon as the inner boundary, involves a positive constant parameter, say , if , where is the Barbero-Immirzi parameter. The parameter represents the rescaling freedom that characterizes the equivalence class of null generators of the isolated horizon. We reiterate the fact that the laws of mechanics associated with the isolated horizon does not depend on the choice of and, in particular, while one uses the value of standard surface gravity as input, that does not fix to a particular value. This fact contradicts the claims made in certain parts of the concerned literature that we duly refer to. We do the calculations by taking Schwarzschild metric as an example so that the contradiction with the referred literature, where similar approaches were adopted, becomes apparent. The contribution to the symplectic structure that comes from the isolated horizon, diverges for , implying that the rescaling symmetry of the isolated horizon is violated for any real . Since the quantum theory of isolated horizon in the LQG framework exists only for real values of , it is founded on this flawed classical setup. Nevertheless, if the flaw is ignored, then two different viewpoints persist in the literature for entropy calculation. We highlight the main features of those approaches and point out why one is logically viable and the other is not.
arXiv comment12 pages, version accepted for publication
References in corpus (20)
- Background Independent Quantum Gravity: A Status Report
- Quantum Geometry and Black Hole Entropy
- Logarithmic correction to the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy
- Isolated Horizons: Hamiltonian Evolution and the First Law
- Mechanics of Isolated Horizons
- Isolated Horizons: A Generalization of Black Hole Mechanics
- Black Holes in Loop Quantum Gravity
- Black hole entropy and SU(2) Chern-Simons theory
- Black hole entropy from an SU(2)-invariant formulation of Type I isolated horizons
- Quantum Black Hole Entropy
- Is Barbero's Hamiltonian formulation a Gauge Theory of Lorentzian Gravity?
- The SU(2) Black Hole entropy revisited
- Black Hole Entropy from complex Ashtekar variables
- A Real Polynomial Formulation of General Relativity in terms of Connections
- Static isolated horizons: SU(2) invariant phase space, quantization, and black hole entropy
- Schwarzschild horizon dynamics and SU(2) Chern-Simons theory
- The reality conditions for the new canonical variables of General Relativity
- Regge calculus and Ashtekar variables
- Black Hole Entropy from indistinguishable quantum geometric excitations
- Quantum Geometry and Black Holes