Horizontal-Branch Models and the Second-Parameter Effect. III. The Impact of Mass Loss on the Red Giant Branch, and the Case of M5 and Palomar 4/Eridanus

Abstract

Deep HST photometry has recently been presented for the outer-halo globular clusters Palomar 4 and Eridanus. The new high-precision color-magnitude diagrams obtained for these globulars have allowed a measurement of their ages relative to M5 (NGC 5904), which is a well-observed, much closer cluster. Assuming that the globular clusters share the same chemical composition, Pal 4/Eridanus have been reported to be younger than M5 by ~1-2 Gyr, based on both the magnitude difference between the horizontal branch (HB) and the turnoff and the difference in color between the turnoff and the lower subgiant branch. In the present article, we address the following question: What age difference would be required to account for the difference in HB types between M5 and Pal 4/Eridanus, assuming age to be the "second parameter"? We find that, unless all these clusters (including M5) are younger than 10 Gyr, such an age difference is substantially larger than that based on an analysis of the cluster turnoffs. To reach such a conclusion, six different analytical mass loss rate formulae (reported in an Appendix), all implying a dependence of mass loss on the red giant branch on age, were employed. Our results appear to be in conflict with claims that age can be the only second parameter in the Galactic globular cluster system.

13 pages, including 11 postscript figures. The Astrophysical Journal, in press

Cited by in corpus (61)

• Evolution of asymptotic giant branch stars II. Optical to far-infrared isochrones with improved TP-AGB models
• The Dawes Review 2: Nucleosynthesis and stellar yields of low and intermediate-mass single stars
• The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. IX. Horizontal Branch Morphology and the Second Parameter Phenomenon
• An empirical formula for the mass-loss rates of dust-enshrouded red supergiants and oxygen-rich Asymptotic Giant Branch stars
• Asteroseismology of old open clusters with Kepler: direct estimate of the integrated RGB mass loss in NGC6791 and NGC6819
• Horizontal Branch Stars: The Interplay between Observations and Theory, and Insights into the Formation of the Galaxy
• Testing a Predictive Theoretical Model for the Mass Loss Rates of Cool Stars
• The early evolution of Globular Clusters: the case of NGC 2808
• Red Giant Branch stars: the theoretical framework
• Global and non-global parameters of horizontal branch morphology of globular clusters
• The Identification of Blue Horizontal Branch Stars in the Integrated Spectra of Globular Clusters
• Uncertainties of Synthetic Integrated Colors as Age Indicators
• The First Empirical Mass Loss Law for Population II Giants
• A model of spectral galaxy evolution including the effects of nebular emission
• Effects of Helium Enrichment in Globular Clusters I.Theoretical Plane with PGPUC stellar evolution code
• ISOCAM observations of Galactic Globular Clusters: mass loss along the Red Giant Branch
• The Evolutionary Status of M3 RR Lyrae Variables: Breakdown of the Canonical Framework?
• The age of the Milky Way inner stellar spheroid from RR Lyrae population synthesis
• The Binary Fraction of Low Mass White Dwarfs
• Age as the Second Parameter in NGC 288 / NGC 362? I. Turnoff Ages: a Purely Differential Comparison
• Rotation, Planets, and the "Second Parameter" of the Horizontal Branch
• Age as the Second Parameter in NGC 288/NGC 362? II. The Horizontal Branch Revisited
• Mass Outflow from Red Giant Stars in M13, M15, and M92
• On the Origin of Bimodal Horizontal-Branches in Massive Globular Clusters: The Case of NGC 6388 and NGC 6441
• Is Dust Forming on the Red Giant Branch in 47 Tuc?
• Horizontal-Branch Models and the Second-Parameter Effect. IV. The Case of M3 and Palomar 3
• The Chemical Abundances of the Stellar Populations in the Leo I and Leo II dSph Galaxies
• On constructing horizontal branch models
• The velocity dispersion and mass function of the outer halo globular cluster Palomar 4
• Modelling Chromospheric Line Profiles in NGC2808: Evidence of Mass Loss from RGB Stars
• An empirical mass-loss law for Population II giants from the Spitzer-IRAC survey of Galactic globular clusters
• The Very Slow Wind From the Pulsating Semiregular Red Giant L2 Pup
• Globular clusters in modified Newtonian dynamics: velocity-dispersion profiles from self-consistent models
• Mass Outflow and Chromospheric Activity of Red Giant Stars in Globular Clusters I: M15
• Surface convection and red giants radii measurements
• Mass Outflow and Chromospheric Activity of Red Giant Stars in Globular Clusters II. M13 and M92
• Chemical Abundances for the Outer Halo Cluster Pal 4 from Co-added High-Resolution Spectroscopy
• A Spitzer search for cold dust within globular clusters
• Exploring the Upper Red Giant and Asymptotic Giant Branches: the Globular Cluster M5
• M75, a Globular Cluster with a Trimodal Horizontal Branch. I. Color-Magnitude Diagram
• Spinning-Up the Envelope Before Entering a Common Envelope Phase
• Mass loss law for red giant stars in simple population globular clusters
• A differential chemical abundance scale for the globular cluster M5
• Discovery of a Variable Star Population in NGC 2808
• A Search for Pulsations in Helium White Dwarfs
• CCD Photometry of the globular cluster NGC 5466. RR Lyrae light curve decomposition and the distance scale
• Clusters AgeS Experiment. Hot subdwarfs and luminous white dwarf candidates in the field of the globular cluster M4
• Modelling chromospheric line profiles as diagnostics of velocity fields in ω Centauri red giant stars
• Alfvén wave-driven wind from RGB and AGB stars
• Observational consequences of the hypothesized helium rich stellar population in Omega Centauri
• The `Second Parameter': A Memory from the Globular Cluster Formation Epoch
• Various Modes of Helium Mixing in Globular Cluster Giants and Their Possible Effects on the Horizontal Branch Morphology
• Evidence that Mass Loss on the Red Giant Branch Decreases with Metallicity
• Measuring Polarization in microlensing events
• A Superwind from Early Post-Red Giant Stars?
• Fabry-Perot Absorption Line Spectroscopy of the Galactic Bar. II. Stellar Metallicities
• The temperature distribution of horizontal branch stars: methods and first results
• The Ages of Stars: The Horizontal Branch
• Planetary magnetosphere evolution around post-main-sequence stars
• Horizontal Branch Stars and the Ultraviolet Universe
• XMM-Newton follow-up of two eROSITA X-ray binary candidates