The Evolutionary Status of M3 RR Lyrae Variables: Breakdown of the Canonical Framework?

Abstract

In order to test the prevailing paradigm of horizontal-branch (HB) stellar evolution, we use the large databases of measured RR Lyrae parameters for the globular cluster M3 (NGC 5272) recently provided by Bakos et al. and Corwin & Carney. We compare the observed distribution of fundamentalized periods against the predictions of synthetic HBs. The observed distribution shows a sharp peak at P_f ~ 0.55 d, which is primarily due to the RRab variables, whereas the model predictions instead indicate that the distribution should be more uniform in P_f, with a buildup of variables with shorter periods (P_f < 0.5 d). Detailed statistical tests show, for the first time, that the observed and predicted distributions are incompatible with one another at a high significance level. We show that the sharp peak in the M3 period distribution receives a significant contribution from the Blazhko variables in the cluster. We also show that M15 (NGC 7078) and M68 (NGC 4590) show similar peaks in their P_f distributions, which in spite of being located at a similar P_f value as M3's, can be primarily ascribed to the RRc variables. Again similar to M3, a demise of RRc variables towards the blue edge of the instability strip is present in these two globulars. This is again in sharp contrast with the evolutionary scenario, which also foresees a strong buildup of RRc variables with short periods in OoII globulars. We speculate that, in OoI systems, RRab variables may get "trapped" close to the transition line between RRab and RRc pulsators as they evolve to the blue, whereas in OoII systems it is the RRc variables that may get "trapped" instead, as they evolve to the red, before changing their pulsation mode to RRab. Such a scenario is supported by the available CMDs and Bailey diagrams for M3, M15, and M68.

8 figures, 11 pages. Uses latest emulateapj.cls style file (included, 05/14/03) and apjfonts.sty (also included). The full-resolution preprint can be downloaded from http://www.astro.puc.cl/~mcatelan/. ApJ, in press

References in corpus (6)

• Variable Stars in Galactic Globular Clusters
• Variable Stars in the Unusual, Metal-Rich Globular Cluster NGC 6388
• RR Lyrae stars in Galactic globular clusters. II. A theoretical approach to variables in M3
• Horizontal-Branch Models and the Second-Parameter Effect. IV. The Case of M3 and Palomar 3
• M75, a Globular Cluster with a Trimodal Horizontal Branch. I. Color-Magnitude Diagram
• The metallicity range of variables in M3

Cited by in corpus (49)

• VISTA Variables in the Via Lactea (VVV): The public ESO near-IR variability survey of the Milky Way
• Horizontal Branch Stars: The Interplay between Observations and Theory, and Insights into the Formation of the Galaxy
• The RR Lyrae Period-Luminosity Relation. I. Theoretical Calibration
• A multi-color and Fourier study of RR Lyrae variables in the globular cluster NGC 5272 (M3)
• Deciphering the 3D structure of the old Galactic bulge from the OGLE RR Lyrae stars
• The fraction of second generation stars in Globular Clusters from the analysis of the Horizontal Branch
• Fourier analysis of non-Blazhko ab-type RR Lyrae stars observed with the Kepler space telescope
• Evidence for an Overluminosity of the Variable Star RR Lyr, and a Revised Distance to the LMC
• RR Lyrae variables in Galactic globular clusters: IV. Synthetic HB and RR Lyrae predictions
• On the RR Lyrae stars in globulars: IV. $\omega$ Centauri Optical UBVRI Photometry
• Automated Nonlinear Stellar Pulsation Calculations: Applications to RR Lyrae stars. The Slope of the Fundamental Blue Edge and the First RRd Model Survey
• The Chemical Compositions of Non-Variable Red and Blue Field Horizontal Branch Stars
• The Globular Cluster NGC 5286. II. Variable Stars
• Constraints on Helium Enhancement in the Globular Cluster M3 (NGC 5272): The Horizontal Branch Test
• The Period-Luminosity Relation of RR Lyrae Stars in the SDSS Photometric System
• Constraints on the Distance Moduli, Helium and Metal Abundances, and Ages of Globular Clusters from their RR Lyrae and Non-Variable Horizontal-Branch Stars. I. M3, M15, and M92
• Is mass loss along the red giant branch of globular clusters sharply peaked? The case of M3
• The ACS LCID Project. VIII. The short-period Cepheids of Leo A
• Constraints on the distance moduli, helium and metal abundances, and ages of globular clusters from their RR Lyrae and non-variable horizontal-branch stars. II. Multiple stellar populations in 47Tuc, M3, and M13
• Image-Subtraction Photometry of Variable Stars in the Globular Clusters NGC 6388 and NGC 6441
• In search of massive single-population Globular Clusters
• Multicolour CCD photometry of the variable stars in globular cluster M3
• The Globular Cluster M15. I. Identification, Discovery, and Period Determination of Variable Stars
• Multiple Populations in Globular Clusters and the Origin of the Oosterhoff Period Groups
• Variable stars in the Fornax dSph Galaxy. I. The Globular Cluster Fornax 4
• Homogeneous Photometry V: The Globular Cluster NGC 4147
• Photometric and radial-velocity time-series of RR Lyrae stars in M3: analysis of single-mode variables
• RR Lyrae variables in Galactic globular clusters V. The case of M3 pulsators
• Discovery of > 200 RR Lyrae Variables in M62: An Oosterhoff I Globular Cluster with a Predominantly Blue HB
• Stellar Evolution and Variability in the Pre-ZAHB Phase
• Is helium the key parameter in the extended color spread of the first generation stars in M3?
• A Semi-Empirical Study of the Mass Distribution of Horizontal Branch Stars in M3 (NGC 5272)
• Variable Stars in the Fornax dSph Galaxy. III. The Globular Cluster Fornax 5
• Variable Stars in Large Magellanic Cloud Globular Clusters I: NGC 1466
• The Horizontal Branch of NGC 1851: Constraints from its RR Lyrae Variables
• Near-infrared Census of RR Lyrae variables in the Messier 3 globular cluster and the Period--Luminosity Relations
• BVI Photometric Variability Survey of M3
• The Globular Cluster NGC 6402 (M14). II. Variable Stars
• Impact of distance determinations on Galactic structure. II. Old tracers
• On period distribution of RR Lyr type variables in the globular cluster M3
• Multi-wavelength Photometric Study of RR Lyrae Variables in the Globular Cluster NGC 5272 (Messier 3)
• Variable Stars in Large Magellanic Cloud Globular Clusters II: NGC 1786
• Evolutionary status of W Vir pulsating variables
• Detailed analysis of the variable star population in the globular cluster NGC 7006
• A search for photometric variability towards the globular cluster M3 with the TWenty Inch Survey Telescope
• High-cadence stellar variability studies of RR Lyrae stars with DECam: New multi-band templates
• RR Lyrae stars with variable mean magnitudes
• Physical Parameters for RR Lyrae Stars in the SDSS Filter System
• A Multiband Photometric Study of RR Lyrae Stars in M53 (NGC 5024)