Fundamental Discreteness Limitations of Cosmological N-Body Clustering Simulations

Abstract

We explore some of the effects that discreteness and two-body scattering may have on N-body simulations with ``realistic'' cosmological initial conditions. We use an identical subset of particles from the initial conditions for a $128^3$ Particle-Mesh (PM) calculation as the initial conditions for a variety P${}^3$M and Tree code runs. We investigate the effect of mass resolution (the mean interparticle separation) since most ``high resolution'' codes only have high resolution in gravitational force. The phase-insensitive two--point statistics, such as the power spectrum (autocorrelation) are somewhat affected by these variations, but phase-sensitive statistics show greater differences. Results converge at the mean interparticle separation scale of the lowest mass-resolution code. As more particles are added, but the force resolution is held constant, the P${}^3$M and the Tree runs agree more and more strongly with each other and with the PM run which had the same initial conditions. This shows high particle density is necessary for correct time evolution, since many different results cannot all be correct. However, they do not so converge to a PM run which continued the fluctuations to small scales. Our results show that ignoring them is a major source of error on comoving scales of the missing wavelengths. This can be resolved by putting in a high particle density. Since the codes never agree well on scales below the mean comoving interparticle separation, we find little justification for quantitative predictions on this scale. Some measures vary by 50%, but others can be off by a factor of three or more. Our results suggest possible problems with the density of galaxy halos, formation of early generation objects such as QSO absorber clouds, etc.

Revised version to be published in Astrophysical Journal. One figure changed; expanded discussion, more information on code parameters. Latex, 44 pages, including 19 figures. Higher resolution versions of Figures 10-15 available at: ftp://kusmos.phsx.ukans.edu/preprints/nbody

Cited by in corpus (81)

• GADGET: A code for collisionless and gasdynamical cosmological simulations
• Resolving the Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
• Transients from Initial Conditions in Cosmological Simulations
• Disruption of Dark Matter Substructure: Fact or Fiction?
• An accurate physical model for halo concentrations
• Generation of Vorticity and Velocity Dispersion by Orbit Crossing
• Large-scale dark matter simulations
• The Warm DM halo mass function below the cut-off scale
• A New Algorithm for Computing Statistics of Weak Lensing by Large-Scale Structure
• Modeling Nonlinear Evolution of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations: Convergence Regime of N-body Simulations and Analytic Models
• Gas density and X-ray surface brightness profiles of clusters of galaxies from dark matter halo potentials: beyond the isothermal beta model
• Scaling Laws in the Distribution of Galaxies
• A model for the postcollapse equilibrium of cosmological structure: truncated isothermal spheres from top-hat density perturbations
• A new approach to simulating collisionless dark matter fluids
• Numerical convergence of simulations of galaxy formation: the abundance and internal structure of cold dark matter haloes
• An adaptively refined phase-space element method for cosmological simulations and collisionless dynamics
• Adhesive Gravitational Clustering
• Dark Sky Simulations: Early Data Release
• The Tree-Particle-Mesh N-body Gravity Solver
• Density profiles of ultracompact minihalos: Implications for constraining the primordial power spectrum
• Discreteness Effects in Lambda Cold Dark Matter Simulations: A Wavelet-Statistical View
• Discreteness effects in cosmological N-body simulations
• Toward an accurate mass function for precision cosmology
• ColDICE: a parallel Vlasov-Poisson solver using moving adaptive simplicial tessellation
• Linear perturbative theory of the discrete cosmological N-body problem
• Generation of Primordial Cosmological Perturbations from Statistical Mechanical Models
• Towards quantitative control on discreteness error in the non-linear regime of cosmological N body simulations
• Quantification of discreteness effects in cosmological N-body simulations: I. Initial Conditions
• What sets the central structure of dark matter haloes?
• The Evolution of Baryon Density Fluctuations in Multi-Component Cosmological Simulations
• Reliability of the dark matter clustering in cosmological N-body simulation on scales below the mean separation length of particles
• Gravitational cooling and density profile near caustics in collisionless dark matter haloes
• Gravitational evolution of a perturbed lattice and its fluid limit
• Quantification of discreteness effects in cosmological N-body simulations: II. Evolution up to shell crossing
• Phase-space structure of protohalos: Vlasov versus Particle-Mesh
• The Size and Shape of Voids in Three-Dimensional Galaxy Surveys
• N-body simulations with two-orders-of-magnitude higher performance using wavelets
• The optimal gravitational softening length for cosmological N-body simulations
• Power-law correlation and discreteness in cosmological N-body simulations
• Spurious Small-Scale Structure & Discreteness-Driven Relaxation in Cosmological Simulations
• On the starting redshift for cosmological simulations: Focusing on halo properties
• Quantifying resolution in cosmological N-body simulations using self-similarity
• The Fractal Geometry of the Cosmic Web and its Formation
• A wavelet add-on code for new-generation N-body simulations and data de-noising (JOFILUREN)
• Vlasov versus N-body: the Hénon sphere
• On the problem of initial conditions in cosmological N-body simulations
• Novel Adaptive softening for collisionless N-body simulations: Eliminating spurious halos
• Evolution of isolated overdensities as a control on cosmological N body simulations
• Gravitational Dynamics of an Infinite Shuffled Lattice: Particle Coarse-grainings, Non-linear Clustering and the Continuum Limit
• The Adaptive TreePM: An Adaptive Resolution Code for Cosmological N-body Simulations
• Shedding light on low-mass subhalo survival and annihilation luminosity with numerical simulations
• Exponents of non-linear clustering in scale-free one dimensional cosmological simulations
• Optimal Softening for N-Body Halo Simulations
• The mass function of the Las Campanas loose groups of galaxies
• Shadowing-based reliability decay in softened n-body simulations
• Fractal distributions of dark matter and gas in the MareNostrum Universe
• Growth of correlations in gravitational N-body simulations
• Particle linear theory on a self-gravitating perturbed cubic Bravais lattice
• Accuracy of power spectra in dissipationless cosmological simulations
• Gravitational collapse in an expanding background and the role of substructure II: Excess power at small scales and its effect of collapse of structures at larger scales
• Cluster mass function in mixed models
• Gravitational collapse in an expanding background and the role of substructure I: Planar collapse
• Hydrodynamic Approach to the Evolution of Cosmic Structures II: Study of N-body Simulations at z=0
• Stable clustering and the resolution of dissipationless cosmological N-body simulations
• Numerical Discreteness Errors in Multi-Species Cosmological N-body Simulations
• Smooth halos in the cosmic web
• A toy model to test the accuracy of cosmological N-body simulations
• Statistical characteristics of simulated walls
• Collapsed and Extended Cold Dark Matter Haloes in Softened N-Body Gravity
• Universality of power law correlations in gravitational clustering
• Cosmological simulations of structure formation and the Vlasov equation
• Numerical Simulations of the Dark Universe: State of the Art and the Next Decade
• Vlasov limit and discreteness effects in cosmological N-body simulations
• Halo Models of Large Scale Structure and Reliability of Cosmological N-Body Simulations
• The Hidden Role of Anisotropies in Shaping Structure Formation in Cosmological N-Body Simulations
• Self-similarity and stable clustering in a family of scale-free cosmologies
• On the origin of transient features in cosmological N-Body Simulations
• Properties of observed Ly-$\alpha$ forest
• Super-resolution simulation of the Fuzzy Dark Matter cosmological model
• Comment on 'Discreteness Effects in Lambda Cold Dark Matter Simulations: A Wavelet-Statistical View' by Romeo et al
• A dynamics-based density profile for dark haloes. I. Algorithm and basic results