Non-Linear Approximations to Gravitational Instability: A Comparison in the Quasi-Linear Regime

Abstract

We compare different nonlinear approximations to gravitational clustering in the weakly nonlinear regime, using as a comparative statistic the evolution of non-Gaussianity which can be characterised by a set of numbers $S_p$ describing connected moments of the density field at the lowest order in $<{\delta }^2>$: $<{\delta }^n{>}_c\simeq S_n<{\delta }^2{>}^{n-1}$. Generalizing earlier work by Bernardeau (1992) we develop an ansatz to evaluate all $S_p$ in a given approximation by means of a generating function which can be shown to satisfy the equations of motion of a homogeneous spherical density enhancement in that approximation. On the basis of the values of we show that approximations formulated in Lagrangian space (such as the Zeldovich approximation and its extensions) are considerably more accurate than those formulated in Eulerian space such as the Frozen Flow and Linear Potential approximations. In particular we find that the $n$th order Lagrangian perturbation approximation correctly reproduces the first $n+1$ parameters $S_n$. We also evaluate the density probability distribution function for the different approximations in the quasi-linear regime and compare our results with an exact analytic treatment in the case of the Zeldovich approximation.

21 pages, 1 figure, Latex

Cited by in corpus (56)

• Large-Scale Structure of the Universe and Cosmological Perturbation Theory
• Multi-scale initial conditions for cosmological simulations
• The Effective Field Theorist's Approach to Gravitational Dynamics
• Approximation Methods for Non-linear Gravitational Clustering
• Large-scale dark matter simulations
• Reconstruction of the early Universe as a convex optimization problem
• A reconstruction of the initial conditions of the Universe by optimal mass transportation
• Newtonian Cosmology in Lagrangian Formulation: Foundations and Perturbation Theory
• The Zeldovich approximation
• Accurate initial conditions for cosmological N-body simulations: Minimizing truncation and discreteness errors
• Lagrangian perturbations and the matter bispectrum I: fourth-order model for non-linear clustering
• The Statistics of Weak Lensing at Small Angular Scales: Probability Distribution Function
• Higher-order initial conditions for mixed baryon-CDM simulations
• The recursion relation in Lagrangian perturbation theory
• Accuracy of Nonlinear Approximations in Spheroidal Collapse --- Why are Zel'dovich-type approximations so good? ---
• Predictions for the clustering properties of the Lyman-alpha Forest - I. One-point statistics
• Reconstruction of the primordial Universe by a Monge--Ampere--Kantorovich optimisation scheme
• Probing The Gravity Induced Bias with Weak Lensing: Test of Analytical results Against Simulations
• A question of separation: disentangling tracer bias and gravitational nonlinearity with counts-in-cells statistics
• Extending Lagrangian perturbation theory to a fluid with velocity dispersion
• The Integrated Bispectrum and Beyond
• Why is the Zel'dovich Approximation so Accurate?
• Cosmological Vlasov-Poisson equations for dark matter: Recent developments and connections to selected plasma problems
• Perturbation theory in Lagrangian hydrodynamics for a cosmological fluid with velocity dispersion
• Primordial fractal density perturbations and structure formation in the Universe: 1-Dimensional collisionless sheet model
• Multiple-streaming and the Probability Distribution of Density in Redshift Space
• Modelling non-linear evolution using Lagrangian Perturbation Theory (LPT) re-expansions
• Evolution of the Cosmological Density Distribution Function: A New Analytical Model
• Transients from initial conditions based on Lagrangian perturbation theory in N-body simulations
• Gravitational instability on the brane: the role of boundary conditions
• The Integrated Bispectrum in Modified Gravity Theories
• Extending the domain of validity of the Lagrangian approximation
• Relativistic Zel'dovich approximation in spherically symmetric model
• Consistency Relations in Effective Field Theory
• Quasi-spherical collapse of matter in $\Lambda$CDM
• Statistical Properties of Thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Maps
• Estimating the Integrated Bispectrum from Weak Lensing Maps
• Third-order perturbative solutions in the Lagrangian perturbation theory with pressure
• Cross-correlating Sunyaev-Zel'dovich and Weak Lensing Maps
• An Eulerian Perturbation Approach to Large Scale Structures: Extending the Adhesion Approximation
• Improving the Lagrangian perturbative solution for cosmic fluid: Applying Shanks transformation
• Density field in extended Lagrangian perturbation theory
• Correspondence between the adhesion model and the velocity dispersion for the cosmological fluid
• Renormalization group and UV completion of cosmological perturbations: Gravitational collapse as a critical phenomenon
• Beyond Zel'dovich-Type Approximations in Gravitational Instability Theory --- Padé Prescription in Spheroidal Collapse ---
• Non-Gaussianity of the density distribution in accelerating universes
• Third-order perturbative solutions in the Lagrangian perturbation theory with pressure II: Effect of the transverse modes
• Higher-Order Spectra of Weak Lensing Convergence Maps in Parameterized Theories of Modified Gravity
• Fast and accurate collapse-time predictions for collisionless matter
• Fourth-order perturbative equations in Lagrangian perturbation theory for a cosmological dust fluid
• Symmetries, Invariants and Generating Functions: Higher-order Statistics of Biased Tracers
• Non-Gaussianity of one-point distribution functions in extended Lagrangian perturbation theory
• The comparison of velocity distribution between Adhesion approximation and the Euler-Jeans-Newton model
• Non-Gaussianity of the density distribution in accelerating universes II:N-body simulations
• Transients from Initial Conditions Based on Lagrangian Perturbation Theory in $N$-body Simulations III: The Case of GADGET-2 Code
• Probing the Dark Side of Gravitational Clustering: Weak Lensing Statistics at Large Smoothing Angle