On the Perils of Curve-of-Growth Analysis: Systematic Abundance Underestimates for the Gas in Gamma-Ray Burst Host Galaxies
arXiv:astro-ph/0606500 · doi:10.1086/507126
Abstract
We examine the practice of deriving interstellar medium (ISM) abundances from low-resolution spectroscopy of GRB afterglows. We argue that the multi-ion single-component curve-of-growth analysis technique systematically underestimates the column densities of the metal-line profiles commonly observed for GRB. This systematic underestimate is accentuated by the fact that many GRB line-profiles (e.g. GRB 050730, GRB 050820, GRB 051111) are comprised of `clouds' with a bi-modal distribution of column density. Such line-profiles may be characteristic of a sightline which penetrates both a high density star-forming region and more distant, ambient ISM material. Our analysis suggests that the majority of abundances reported in the literature are systematically underestimates and that the reported errors are frequently over-optimistic. Further, we demonstrate that one cannot even report precise relative abundances with confidence. The implications are profound for our current understanding on the metallicity, dust-to-gas ratio, and chemical abundances of the ISM in GRB host galaxies. For example, we argue that all but a few sightlines allow for the gas to have at least solar metallicity. Finally, we suggests new approaches for constraining the abundances.
arXiv comment9 pages, 9 figures. Accepted to ApJ
References in corpus (18)
- The afterglow, the redshift, and the extreme energetics of the gamma-ray burst 990123
- The SDSS Damped Lya Survey: Data Release 3
- The host of GRB 030323 at z=3.372: a very high column density DLA system with a low metallicity
- Probing Cosmic Chemical Evolution with Gamma-Ray Bursts: GRB060206 at z=4.048
- Heavy Element Abundances and Dust Depletions in the Host Galaxies of Three Gamma-Ray Bursts
- Echelle Spectroscopy of a GRB Afterglow at z=3.969: A New Probe of the Interstellar and Intergalactic Media in the Young Universe
- The UCSD HIRES/KeckI Damped Lya Abundance Database: I. The Data
- A Homogeneous Sample of Sub-DLAs I: Construction of the Sample and Chemical Abundance Measurements
- Dust Depletion and Extinction in a Gamma-Ray Burst Afterglow
- Optical Spectropolarimetry of the GRB 020813 Afterglow
- Spectroscopy of GRB 050505 at z=4.275: A logN(HI)=22.1 DLA Host Galaxy and the Nature of the Progenitor
- A Keck HIRES Investigation of the Metal Abundances and Kinematics of the z=2.46 Damped Lya System Toward Q0201+365
- Abundances and Physical Conditions in the Warm Neutral Medium Towards mu Columbae
- A flash in the dark: UVES/VLT high resolution spectroscopy of GRB afterglows
- Keck Spectroscopy and HST Imaging of GRB 000926: Probing a Host Galaxy at z = 2. 038
- Time-Dependent Optical Spectroscopy of GRB 010222: Clues to the GRB Environment
- The Gemini Deep Deep Survey: II. Metals in Star-Forming Galaxies at Redshift 1.3<z<2
- GRB 050408: An Atypical Gamma-Ray Burst as a Probe of an Atypical Galactic Environment
Cited by in corpus (47)
- Lyman Alpha Emitting Galaxies as a Probe of Reionization
- Probing Galactic Halos with Fast Radio Bursts
- A Highly Complete Spectroscopic Survey of the GOODS-N Field
- Probing the ISM Near Star Forming Regions with GRB Afterglow Spectroscopy: Gas, Metals, and Dust
- The most metal-poor damped Lyman-alpha systems: Insights into chemical evolution in the very metal-poor regime
- Reconciling the Metallicity Distributions of Gamma-ray Burst, Damped Lyman-alpha, and Lyman-break Galaxies at z=3
- Constraints on Type Ib/c and GRB Progenitors
- Super-solar Metal Abundances in Two Galaxies at z ~ 3.57 revealed by the GRB 090323 Afterglow Spectrum
- GRB 090426: The Environment of a Rest-Frame 0.35-second Gamma-Ray Burst at Redshift z=2.609
- Evolution of the dust-to-metals ratio in high-redshift galaxies probed by GRB-DLAs
- High-Redshift Starbursting Dwarf Galaxies Revealed by GRB Afterglows
- GRB 130606A as a Probe of the Intergalactic Medium and the Interstellar Medium in a Star-forming Galaxy in the First Gyr After the Big Bang
- Molecular Hydrogen in the Damped Lyman-alpha System towards GRB 120815A at z=2.36
- Gamma-Ray Burst afterglows as probes of environment and blastwave physics I: absorption by host galaxy gas and dust
- Unveiling the Secrets of Metallicity and Massive Star Formation Using DLAs along Gamma-ray Bursts
- The ERO Host Galaxy of GRB 020127: Implications for the Metallicity of GRB Progenitors
- GRB 071003: Broadband Follow-up Observations of a Very Bright Gamma-Ray Burst in a Galactic Halo
- The Interstellar Medium of GRB Host Galaxies I. Echelle Spectra of Swift GRB Afterglows
- Discovery of Multi-Phase Cold Accretion in a Massive Galaxy at z=0.7
- A very metal poor Damped Lyman-alpha system revealed through the most energetic GRB 090926A
- The missing gas problem in GRB host galaxies: evidence for a highly ionised component
- Evidence for diffuse molecular gas and dust in the hearts of gamma-ray burst host galaxies
- Metallicities, dust and molecular content of a QSO-Damped Lyman-α system reaching log N (H i) = 22: An analog to GRB-DLAs
- A High Signal-to-Noise Ratio Composite Spectrum of Gamma-ray Burst Afterglows
- Photometry and spectroscopy of GRB 060526: A detailed study of the afterglow and host galaxy of a z=3.2 gamma-ray burst
- Direct Evidence of Cold Gas in DLA 0812+32B
- Constraining the energy budget of GRB 080721
- Properties of a Gamma Ray Burst Host Galaxy at z ~ 5
- Discovery of a Fast Iron Low-ionization Outflow in the Early Evolution of the Nearby Tidal Disruption Event AT2019qiz
- MMT Extremely Metal Poor Galaxy Survey I. An Efficient Technique to Identify Metal Poor Galaxies
- When Do Internal Shocks End and External Shocks Begin? Early-Time Broadband Modelling of GRB 051111
- A Metal-Strong and Dust-Rich Damped \lya Absorption System toward the Quasar SDSS J115705.52+615521.7
- The host-galaxy response to the afterglow of GRB 100901A
- GRB 050826: A Subluminous Event at z = 0.296 Finds its Place in the Luminosity Distribution of Gamma-Ray Burst Afterglows
- Testing the Possible Intrinsic Origin of the Excess of Very Strong MgII Absorbers Along GRB Lines-of-Sight
- The circumburst environment of a FRED GRB: study of the prompt emission and X-ray/optical afterglow of GRB 051111
- A quasar hiding behind two dusty absorbers. Quantifying the selection bias of metal-rich, damped Lyman-alpha absorption systems
- Metal-Enriched Neutral Gas Reservoir around a Strongly-lensed, Low-mass Galaxy at Identified by JWST/NIRISS and VLT/MUSE
- Strong Ly alpha Emission in the Proximate Damped Ly alpha Absorption Trough toward the Quasar SDSS J095253.83+011422.0
- The high A_V Quasar Survey: A z=2.027 metal-rich damped Lyman-alpha absorber towards a red quasar at z=3.21
- Models for Gamma-Ray Bursts and Diverse Transients
- New constraints on the physical conditions in H-bearing GRB-host damped Lyman- absorbers
- The ultra-long GRB 220627A at z=3.08
- Gamma Ray Bursts as Probes of the Distant Universe
- The luminous, massive and solar metallicity galaxy hosting the Swift gamma-ray burst, GRB 160804A at z = 0.737
- Ghostly Damped Ly Systems: Tracers of Gas Flows in the Close Vicinity of Quasars ?
- GRB 241105A: A test case for GRB classification and rapid r-process nucleosynthesis channels