The O VII X-ray forest toward Markarian 421: Consistency between XMM-Newton and Chandra

Abstract

Recently the first detections of highly ionised gas associated with two Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM) filaments have been reported. The evidence is based on X-ray absorption lines due to O VII and other ions observed by Chandra towards the bright blazar Mrk 421. We investigate the robustness of this detection by a re-analysis of the original Chandra LETGS spectra, the analysis of a large set of XMM-Newton RGS spectra of Mrk 421, and additional Chandra observations. We address the reliability of individual spectral features belonging to the absorption components, and assess the significance of the detection of these components. We also use Monte Carlo simulations of spectra. We confirm the apparent strength of several features in the Chandra spectra, but demonstrate that they are statistically not significant. This decreased significance is due to the number of redshift trials that are made and that are not taken into account in the original discovery paper. Therefore these features must be attributed to statistical fluctuations. This is confirmed by the RGS spectra, which have a higher signal to noise ratio than the Chandra spectra, but do not show features at the same wavelengths. Finally, we show that the possible association with a Ly-alpha absorption system also lacks sufficient statistical evidence. We conclude that there is insufficient observational proof for the existence of the two proposed WHIM filaments towards Mrk 421, the brightest X-ray blazar on the sky. Therefore, the highly ionised component of the WHIM still remains to be discovered.

13 pages, 4 figures, submitted to the Astrophysical Journal

References in corpus (1)

• XMM-Newton View of the z>0 Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium Toward Markarian 421

Cited by in corpus (83)

• The Baryon Census in a Multiphase Intergalactic Medium: 30% of the Baryons May Still Be Missing
• The Physics of the Intergalactic Medium
• The Search for the Missing Baryons at Low Redshift
• A High-Resolution Survey of Low-Redshift QSO Absorption Lines: Statistics and Physical Conditions of O VI Absorbers
• The Low-z Intergalactic Medium. III. HI and Metal Absorbers at z<0.4
• Do Hot Haloes Around Galaxies Contain the Missing Baryons?
• Baryons in the CosmicWeb of IllustrisTNG - I: Gas in Knots, Filaments, Sheets and Voids
• Detection of hot gas in the filament connecting the clusters of galaxies Abell 222 and Abell 223
• Physical Properties, Baryon Content, and Evolution of the LyαForest: New Insights from High Resolution Observations at z < 0.4
• Outskirts of Galaxy Clusters
• A Weak-Lensing Mass Reconstruction of the Large-Scale Filament Feeding the Massive Galaxy Cluster MACSJ0717.5+3745
• High Metallicity of the X-Ray Gas up to the Virial Radius of a Binary Cluster of Galaxies: Evidence of Galactic Superwinds at High-Redshift
• Evidence for a Variable Ultrafast Outflow in the Newly Discovered Ultraluminous Pulsar NGC 300 ULX-1
• The Relationship Between Intergalactic HI/OVI and Nearby (z<0.017) Galaxies
• Confirmation of X-Ray Absorption by WHIM in the Sculptor Wall
• X-Ray Absorption By WHIM in the Sculptor Wall
• The Enrichment History of Baryons in the Universe
• Resolving the unresolved cosmic X-ray background in the Chandra Deep Fields
• On the Putative Detection of z>0 X-ray Absorption Features in the Spectrum of Markarian 421
• Missing Baryons and the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
• The Abell 3391/95 galaxy cluster system: A 15 Mpc intergalactic medium emission filament, a warm gas bridge, infalling matter clumps, and (re-) accelerated plasma discovered by combining SRG/eROSITA data with ASKAP/EMU and DECam data
• XMM-Newton Survey of Local O VII Absorption Lines in the Spectra of Active Galactic Nuclei
• Broad HI Absorbers as Metallicity-Independent Tracers of the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
• Searching for Outflows in Ultraluminous X-ray Sources Through High-Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy
• The impact of feedback on the low redshift Intergalactic Medium
• Properties of the cosmological filament between two clusters: A possible detection of a large-scale accretion shock by $Suzaku$
• The nature of the unresolved extragalactic soft CXB
• FUV and X-ray absorption in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
• Tracing the Gas to the Virial Radius (R100) in a Fossil Group
• Detection of the Missing Baryons toward the Sightline of H1821+643
• Equilibration processes in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
• The Non-isothermality and Extent of Galactic Diffuse Hot Gas Toward Mrk~421
• Limits on Hot Galactic Halo Gas from X-ray Absorption Lines
• Metal-line emission from the warm-hot intergalactic medium: I. Soft X-rays
• Growing a `Cosmic Beast': Observations and Simulations of MACS J0717.5+3745
• Confirming the Detection of an Intergalactic X-ray Absorber Toward PKS 2155-304
• Studying the WHIM with Gamma Ray Bursts
• A Comprehensive X-ray Absorption Model for Atomic Oxygen
• Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium Associated with the Coma Cluster
• The abundance and physical properties of O VII and O VIII X-ray absorption systems in the EAGLE simulations
• Chandra View of the Warm-Hot IGM toward 1ES 1553+113: Absorption Line Detections and Identifications (Paper I)
• Calibration and in orbit performance of the reflection grating spectrometer onboard XMM-Newton
• Detection of Ne VIII in an Intervening Multi-Phase Absorption System Towards 3C 263
• Multiwavelength campaign on Mrk 509. II. Analysis of high-quality Reflection Grating Spectrometer spectra
• Probing the anisotropy of the Milky Way gaseous halo: Sight-lines toward Mrk 421 and PKS2155-304
• Detecting the warm-hot intergalactic medium through X-ray absorption lines
• Narrow absorption features in the co-added XMM-Newton RGS spectra of isolated Neutron Stars
• Evidence for the Missing Baryons in the Angular Correlation of the Diffuse X-ray Background
• The effect of feedback on the emission properties of the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
• A Pair of O VI and Broad Ly-alpha Absorbers Probing Warm Gas in a Galaxy Group Environment at z ~ 0.4
• XMM-{\em Newton} and FUSE Tentative Evidence for a WHIM filament along the Line of Sight to PKS~0558-504
• Wide-Field Optical Spectroscopy of Abell 133: A Search for Filaments Reported in X-ray Observations
• Baryons: What, When and Where?
• X-raying the Intergalactic OVI Absorbers
• Studying the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium in Emission
• X-ray Intraday Variability of the TeV Blazar Mrk 421 with {\it Chandra}
• X-Ray Absorption by the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium in the Hercules Supercluster
• How can star formation be sustained?
• On the lack of strong O-line excess in the Coma cluster outskirts from Suzaku
• Search for Oxygen Emission from Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium around A2218 with Suzaku
• Temperature and Entropy Profiles to the Virial Radius of Abell 1246 Cluster Observed with Suzaku
• Study of the Intracluster and Intergalactic Medium in the Sculptor Supercluster with Suzaku
• Discovery of a large-scale galaxy filament near a candidate intergalactic X-ray absorption system
• Expected properties of the Two-Point Autocorrelation Function of the IGM
• Hydrogen-like nitrogen radio line from hot interstellar and warm-hot intergalactic gas
• Clusters of galaxies: setting the stage
• An X-ray WHIM metal absorber from a Mpc-scale empty region of space
• Detection capabilities of the Athena X-IFU for the warm-hot intergalactic medium using gamma-ray burst X-ray afterglows
• Merger Signatures in the Galaxy Cluster Abell 98
• Searching for the warm-hot intergalactic medium using XMM-Newton high-resolution X-ray spectra
• Circumgalactic Medium on the Largest Scales: Detecting X-ray Absorption Lines with Large-Area Microcalorimeters
• Systematic errors in the maximum likelihood regression of Poisson count data: introducing the overdispersed chi-square distribution
• Constraints on the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich signal from the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium from WMAP and SPT data
• X-ray Absorption Lines in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium: Probing Chandra observations with the CAMEL simulations
• A search for the missing baryons with X--ray absorption lines towards the blazar 1ES 1553+113
• Soft X-ray absorption excess in gamma-ray burst afterglow spectra: Absorption by turbulent ISM
• Detection of pure warm-hot intergalactic medium emission from a $7.2$ Mpc long filament in the Shapley supercluster using X-ray spectroscopy
• X-ray spectroscopy of Abell S1101 with Chandra, XMM-Newton and ROSAT: band-pass dependence of he temperature profile and soft excess emission
• Soft X-ray excess of clusters: a thermal filament model, and the strong lensing of background galaxy groups
• Multiple Absorption-Line Spectroscopy of the Intergalactic Medium. I. Model
• Prospects for detecting the circum- and intergalactic medium in X-ray absorption using the extended intracluster medium as a backlight
• Searching for the Missing Baryons in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
• NICER Perspective on TeV Blazar Mrk~421: X-ray Variability and Particle Acceleration