On the Putative Detection of z>0 X-ray Absorption Features in the Spectrum of Markarian 421
arXiv:astro-ph/0604515 · doi:10.1086/509865
Abstract
In a series of papers, Nicastro et al. have reported the detection of z>0 OVII absorption features in the spectrum of Mrk421 obtained with the Chandra Low Energy Transmission Grating Spectrometer (LETGS). We evaluate this result in the context of a high quality spectrum of the same source obtained with the Reflection Grating Spectrometer (RGS) on XMM-Newton. The data comprise over 955ks of usable exposure time and more than 26000 counts per 50 milliAngstrom at 21.6 Angstroms. We concentrate on the spectrally clean region (21.3 < lambda < 22.5 Angstroms) where sharp features due to the astrophysically abundant OVII may reveal an intervening, warm--hot intergalactic medium (WHIM). We do not confirm detection of any of the intervening systems claimed to date. Rather, we detect only three unsurprising, astrophysically expected features down to the Log(N_i)~14.6 (3 sigma) sensitivity level. Each of the two purported WHIM features is rejected with a statistical confidence that exceeds that reported for its initial detection. While we can not rule out the existence of fainter, WHIM related features in these spectra, we suggest that previous discovery claims were premature. A more recent paper by Williams et al. claims to have demonstrated that the RGS data we analyze here do not have the resolution or statistical quality required to confirm or deny the LETGS detections. We show that our careful analysis resolves the issues encountered by Williams et al. and recovers the full resolution and statistical quality of the RGS data. We highlight the differences between our analysis and those published by Williams et al. as this may explain our disparate conclusions.
arXiv comment19 pages/7 figures/4 tables. 060424 submitted to ApJ 060522 re-submitted following ApJ request
References in corpus (21)
- Where are the Baryons?
- The Deuterium Abundance Towards Q1009+2956
- Chandra Discovery of a Tree in the X-ray Forest towards PKS 2155-304: the Local Filament?
- High Resolution X-Ray Spectra of Capella: Initial Results from the Chandra High Energy Transmission Grating Spectrometer
- Chandra Detection of the First X-ray Forest along the Line of Sight To Mkn 421
- Chandra Detection of OVIII Ly-alpha Absorption from an Overdense Region in the Intergalactic Medium
- Tracing the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium at Low Redshift: X-ray Forest Observations Towards H1821+643
- X-Ray IGM in the Local Group
- The O VII X-ray forest toward Markarian 421: Consistency between XMM-Newton and Chandra
- Hydrodynamic Simulation of the Cosmological X-ray Background
- Probing the Local Group Medium Toward Mkn 421 with Chandra and FUSE
- X-ray Absorption by the Low-redshift Intergalactic Medium: A Numerical Study of the Lambda CDM model
- Simulating the X-ray Forest
- The Neutral Hydrogen Column Density towards Q1937--1009 from the Unabsorbed Intrinsic Continuum in the Lyman- Forest
- Probing Cosmology with the X-ray Forest
- FUSE Observations of Interstellar and Intergalactic Absorption Toward the X-ray Bright BL Lac Object Mrk 421
- Chandra Observations of Two High-Redshift Quasars
- XMM-Newton View of the z>0 Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium Toward Markarian 421
- A view of PKS 2155-304 with XMM-Newton Reflection Grating Spectrometers
- A search for Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium features in the X-ray spectra of Mkn 421 with the XMM-Newton RGS
- Tentative detection of warm intervening gas towards PKS 0548-322 with XMM-Newton
Cited by in corpus (63)
- The Baryon Census in a Multiphase Intergalactic Medium: 30% of the Baryons May Still Be Missing
- Time-Dependent Ionization in Radiatively Cooling Gas
- The Physics of the Intergalactic Medium
- The Search for the Missing Baryons at Low Redshift
- Observations of the MIssing Baryons in the warm-hot intergalactic medium
- A High-Resolution Survey of Low-Redshift QSO Absorption Lines: Statistics and Physical Conditions of O VI Absorbers
- The Low-z Intergalactic Medium. III. HI and Metal Absorbers at z<0.4
- Baryons in the CosmicWeb of IllustrisTNG - I: Gas in Knots, Filaments, Sheets and Voids
- Detection of hot gas in the filament connecting the clusters of galaxies Abell 222 and Abell 223
- Massive Warm/Hot Galaxy Coronae as Probed by UV/X-ray Oxygen Absorption and Emission: I - Basic Model
- X-Ray Absorption from the Milky Way Halo and the Local Group
- Physical Properties, Baryon Content, and Evolution of the LyαForest: New Insights from High Resolution Observations at z < 0.4
- Outskirts of Galaxy Clusters
- The Relationship Between Intergalactic HI/OVI and Nearby (z<0.017) Galaxies
- X-Ray Absorption By WHIM in the Sculptor Wall
- Confirmation of X-Ray Absorption by WHIM in the Sculptor Wall
- The Rotation of the Hot Gas Around the Milky Way
- Missing Baryons and the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- The Abell 3391/95 galaxy cluster system: A 15 Mpc intergalactic medium emission filament, a warm gas bridge, infalling matter clumps, and (re-) accelerated plasma discovered by combining SRG/eROSITA data with ASKAP/EMU and DECam data
- XMM-Newton Survey of Local O VII Absorption Lines in the Spectra of Active Galactic Nuclei
- Broad HI Absorbers as Metallicity-Independent Tracers of the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- The impact of feedback on the low redshift Intergalactic Medium
- FUV and X-ray absorption in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- Studying the WHIM Content of the Galaxy Large-Scale Structures along the Line of Sight to H 2356-309
- Metal-line emission from the warm-hot intergalactic medium: I. Soft X-rays
- Confirming the Detection of an Intergalactic X-ray Absorber Toward PKS 2155-304
- Studying the WHIM with Gamma Ray Bursts
- Metal-Absorption Column Densities in Fast Radiative Shocks
- Resonant scattering of X-ray emission lines in the hot intergalactic medium
- Chandra View of the Warm-Hot IGM toward 1ES 1553+113: Absorption Line Detections and Identifications (Paper I)
- A possible Chandra and Hubble Space Telescope detection of extragalactic WHIM towards PG 1116+215
- Calibration and in orbit performance of the reflection grating spectrometer onboard XMM-Newton
- Detecting the warm-hot intergalactic medium through X-ray absorption lines
- Narrow absorption features in the co-added XMM-Newton RGS spectra of isolated Neutron Stars
- Evidence for the Missing Baryons in the Angular Correlation of the Diffuse X-ray Background
- The effect of feedback on the emission properties of the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy of the Local Hot Gas along the 3C 273 Sightline
- XMM-{\em Newton} and FUSE Tentative Evidence for a WHIM filament along the Line of Sight to PKS~0558-504
- Hot WHIM counterparts of FUV OVI absorbers: Evidence in the line-of-sight towards quasar 3C 273
- Baryons: What, When and Where?
- Studying the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium in Emission
- X-raying the Intergalactic OVI Absorbers
- X-ray Intraday Variability of the TeV Blazar Mrk 421 with {\it Chandra}
- Future instrumentation for the study of the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- X-Ray Absorption by the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium in the Hercules Supercluster
- The diffuse soft excess emission in the Coma cluster from the ROSAT All-Sky Survey
- Effect of the Metallicity on the X-ray Emission from the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- Discovery of Galactic OIV and OV X-ray absorption due to transition temperature gas in the PKS 2155-304 spectrum
- On the lack of strong O-line excess in the Coma cluster outskirts from Suzaku
- Study of the Intracluster and Intergalactic Medium in the Sculptor Supercluster with Suzaku
- Discovery of a large-scale galaxy filament near a candidate intergalactic X-ray absorption system
- Expected properties of the Two-Point Autocorrelation Function of the IGM
- Detection capabilities of the Athena X-IFU for the warm-hot intergalactic medium using gamma-ray burst X-ray afterglows
- Searching for the warm-hot intergalactic medium using XMM-Newton high-resolution X-ray spectra
- Merger Signatures in the Galaxy Cluster Abell 98
- An X-ray spectroscopic search for dark matter and unidentified line signatures in the Perseus cluster with Hitomi
- Cosmic metal invaders: Intergalactic OVII as a tracer of the warm-hot intergalactic medium within cosmic filaments in the EAGLE simulation
- X-ray and Sunyaev-Zeldovich properties of the WHIM
- The OVI mystery: mismatch between X-ray and UV column densities
- A search for the missing baryons with X--ray absorption lines towards the blazar 1ES 1553+113
- The Search for Million Degree Gas Through The NVII Hyperfine Line
- Searching for the Missing Baryons in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- Future Detections of the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium using Bright Power Law Sources with NewAthena