Reopening the TNOs Color Controversy: Centaurs Bimodality and TNOs Unimodality

Abstract

We revisit the Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) color controversy allegedly solved by Tegler and Romanishin 2003. We debate the statistical approach of the quoted work and discuss why it can not draw the claimed conclusions, and reanalyze their data sample with a more adequate statistical test. We find evidence for the existence of two color groups among the Centaurs. Therefore, mixing both centaurs and TNOs populations lead to the erroneous conclusion of a global bimodality, while there is no evidence for two color groups in the TNOs population alone. We use quasi-simultaneous visible color measurements published for 20 centaurs (corresponding to about half of the identified objects of this class), and conclude on the existence of two groups. With the surface evolution model of Delsanti et al. (2003) we discuss how the existence of two groups of Centaurs may be compatible with a continuous TNOs color distribution.

arXiv comment4 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics Letters

References in corpus (4)

• Colors and Spectra of Kuiper Belt Objects
• On the Size-Dependence of the Inclination Distribution of the Main Kuiper Belt
• The Color Distribution in the Edgeworth-Kuiper Belt
• The dynamics of Plutinos

Cited by in corpus (47)

• The Active Centaurs
• "TNOs are Cool": A survey of the trans-Neptunian region X. Analysis of classical Kuiper belt objects from Herschel and Spitzer observations
• Color Systematics of Comets and Related Bodies
• Possible ring material around centaur (2060) Chiron
• WISE/NEOWISE Observations of the Jovian Trojan Population: Taxonomy
• The albedo-color diversity of transneptunian objects
• Visible spectroscopic and photometric survey of Jupiter Trojans: final results on dynamical families
• Colors and taxonomy of Centaurs and Trans-Neptunian Objects
• Colours of minor bodies in the outer solar system - II: A statistical analysis revisited
• The Bimodal Colors of Centaurs and Small Kuiper Belt Objects
• A hypothesis for the color bimodality of Jupiter Trojans
• Reanalyzing the visible colors of Centaurs and KBOs: what is there and what we might be missing
• Diverse Albedos of Small Trans-Neptunian Objects
• Unbiased Inclination Distributions for Objects in the Kuiper Belt
• The orbit, mass, size, albedo, and density of (65489) Ceto/Phorcys: A tidally-evolved binary Centaur
• The Colors of Extreme Outer Solar System Objects
• The bimodal color distribution of small Kuiper Belt objects
• (42355) Typhon-Echidna: Scheduling Observations for Binary Orbit Determination
• Col-OSSOS: z Band Photometry Reveals Three Distinct TNO Surface Types
• The Neptune Trojans - a new source for the Centaurs?
• Col-OSSOS: The Colours of the Outer Solar System Origins Survey
• OSSOS XX: The Meaning of Kuiper Belt Colors
• Is the Missing Ultra-Red Material Colorless Ice?
• Dynamical evolution and end states of active and inactive Centaurs
• Optical and Infrared Colors of Transneptunian Objects Observed with HST
• Col-OSSOS: Color and Inclination are Correlated Throughout the Kuiper Belt
• A deeper look at the colors of the Saturnian irregular satellites
• Characterization of material around the centaur (2060) Chiron from a visible and near-infrared stellar occultation in 2011
• A model for the common origin of Jupiter family and Halley type comets
• The Diverse Solar Phase Curves of Distant Icy Bodies. II. The Cause of the Opposition Surges and Their Correlations
• Colors of Inner Disk Classical Kuiper Belt Objects
• Physical Characterization of the December 2017 Outburst of the Centaur 174P/Echeclus
• Photometry of active Centaurs: Colors of dormant active Centaur nuclei
• 174P/Echeclus and its Blue Coma Observed Post-outburst
• Surface composition and dynamical evolution of two retrograde objects in the outer solar system: 2008 YB3 and 2005 VD
• OSSOS: XV. No active Centaurs in the Outer Solar System Origins Survey
• Absolute colours and phase coefficients of trans-Neptunian objects: Correlations and Populations
• Searching for Moving Objects in HSC-SSP: Pipeline and Preliminary Results
• The Kuiper Belt and Other Debris Disks
• Comet P/2010 TO20 LINEAR-Grauer as a Mini-29P/SW1
• OSSOS XII: Variability studies of 65 Trans-Neptunian Objects using the Hyper Suprime-Cam
• The rarity of very red TNOs in the scattered disk
• Cryogenic-specific reddish coloration by cryoplasma: New explanation to color diversity of outer solar system objects
• From Centaurs to comets - 40 years
• The active centaur 2020 MK4
• Apse-alignment in narrow-eccentric ringlets and its implications for the EPSILON-ring of Uranus and the ring system of (10199) Chariklo
• Colors of Centaurs observed by the Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam and implications for their origin