Comments on ``The first detections of the Extragalactic Background Light at 3000, 5500, and 8000 A'' by Bernstein, Freedman and Madore

Abstract

A critical discussion is presented of the data analysis applied by Bernstein, Freedman and Madore (2002 ApJ, 571, 56; and ApJ 571, 85) in their measurement of the Extragalactic Background Light. There are questionable assumptions in the analysis of the ground-based observations of the Zodiacal Light. The modeling of the Diffuse Galactic Light is based on an underestimated value of the dust column density along the line of sight. Comparison with the previously presented results from the same observations reveals a puzzling situation: in spite of a large difference in the atmospheric scattered light corrections the derived Extragalactic Background Light values are exactly the same. The claim of the paper of a ``detection of the Extragalactic Background Light'' appears premature.

6 pages, accepted for ApJ

References in corpus (3)

• The First Detections of the Extragalactic Background Light at 3000, 5500, and 8000A (I): Results
• New constraints on the cosmic mid-infrared background using TeV gamma-ray astronomy
• The First Detections of the Extragalactic Background Light at 3000, 5500, and 8000A (II): Measurement of Foreground Zodiacal Light

Cited by in corpus (39)

• The extragalactic optical-infrared background radiations, their time evolution and the cosmic photon-photon opacity
• Modeling the Extragalactic Background Light from Stars and Dust
• A low level of extragalactic background light as revealed by gamma-rays from blazars
• The Cosmic Infrared Background Resolved by Spitzer. Contributions of Mid-Infrared Galaxies to the Far-Infrared Background
• An atmospheric radiation model for Cerro Paranal. I. The optical spectral range
• Dusty Infrared Galaxies: Sources of the Cosmic Infrared Background
• Radiation Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of Protostellar Collapse: Protostellar Core Formation
• Dark Matter and Background Light
• Simultaneous Constraints on the Spectrum of the Extragalactic Background Light and the Intrinsic Tev Spectra of Mrk 421, Mrk 501, and H1426+428
• Cosmic Infrared Background and Early Galaxy Evolution
• Constraints on the Intergalactic Magnetic Field with Gamma-Ray Observations of Blazars
• The History of Cosmological Star Formation: Three Independent Approaches and a Critical Test Using the Extragalactic Background Light
• Cosmic Optical Background: the View from Pioneer 10/11
• The stellar contribution to the extra-galactic background light and absorption of high-energy gamma-rays
• Measurement of the Cosmic Optical Background using the Long Range Reconnaissance Imager on New Horizons
• Modeling the Extragalactic Background Light and the Cosmic Star Formation History
• Diffuse Galactic Light in the Field of the Translucent High Galactic Latitude Cloud MBM32
• Constraints on the Extragalactic Background Light from Very High Energy Gamma-Ray Observations of Blazars
• The 1 um discontinuity in the Extragalactic Background Light spectrum: an artefact of foreground subtraction
• A Measurement of the Cosmic Optical Background and Diffuse Galactic Light Scaling from the R < 50 AU New Horizons-LORRI Data
• The Cosmic Infrared Background Experiment
• Extragalactic Background Light: Inventory of light throughout the cosmic history
• The Cosmic Infrared Background Experiment (CIBER): The Low Resolution Spectrometer
• The Cosmic Infrared Background Experiment (CIBER): the Narrow Band Spectrometer
• Wide and deep near-UV (360nm) galaxy counts and the extragalactic background light with the Large Binocular Camera
• Measurements of the Zodiacal Light Absolute Intensity through Fraunhofer Absorption Line Spectroscopy with CIBER
• Corrections of Errors in `The First Detections of the Extragalactic Background Light at 3000, 5500, and 8000 Å. I, II, and III'
• Intrinsic VHE Gamma-ray spectra of Blazars as a probe for Extragalactic Background Light
• A kinematic study of the compact jet in quasar B3 1633+382
• Extragalactic Background Light: a measurement at 400 nm using dark cloud shadow I. Low surface brightness spectrophotometry in the area of Lynds 1642
• Observations of the High Redshift Universe
• A low density of the Extragalactic Background Light revealed by the H.E.S.S. spectra of the BLLac objects 1ES 1101-232 and H 2356-309
• Astrophysics with New Horizons: Making the Most of a Generational Opportunity
• An original constraint on the Hubble constant: h>0.74
• Spectrophotometric measurement of the Extragalacic Background Light
• Gamma-ray constraints on the infrared background excess
• Measurement of the extragalactic background light at 8600Å using dark cloud shadow and the CaII-triplet lines
• Extragalactic Background Light: Measurements and Applications
• What fraction of stars formed in infrared galaxies at high redshift?