Unbiased cut selection for optimal upper limits in neutrino detectors: the model rejection potential technique

Abstract

We present a method for optimising experimental cuts in order to place the strongest constraints (upper limits) on theoretical signal models. The method relies only on signal and background expectations derived from Monte-Carlo simulations, so no bias is introduced by looking at actual data, for instance by setting a limit based on expected signal above the ``last remaining data event.'' After discussing the concept of the ``average upper limit,'' based on the expectation from an ensemble of repeated experiments with no true signal, we show how the best model rejection potential is achieved by optimising the cuts to minimise the ratio of this ``average upper limit'' to the expected signal from the model. As an example, we use this technique to determine the limit sensitivity of kilometre scale neutrino detectors to extra-terrestrial neutrino fluxes from a variety of models, e.g. active galaxies and gamma-ray bursts. We suggest that these model rejection potential optimised limits be used as a standard method of comparing the sensitivity of proposed neutrino detectors.

arXiv comment18 pages, 7 figures, submitted to Astroparticle Physics

References in corpus (12)

• A Unified Approach to the Classical Statistical Analysis of Small Signals
• High Energy Neutrinos from Astrophysical Sources: An Upper Bound
• Ultrahigh-Energy Neutrino Interactions
• Neutrino Interactions at Ultrahigh Energies
• Particle Physics with High Energy Neutrinos
• On the cosmic ray bound for models of extragalactic neutrino production
• Flux of Atmospheric Neutrinos
• Pinning down the Glue in the Proton
• On Radio Detection of Ultra-High Energy Neutrinos in Antarctic Ice
• The prompt lepton cookbook
• Detecting Neutrinos from AGN: New Fluxes and Cross Sections
• Astrophysical Neutrino Event Rates and Sensitivity for Neutrino Telescopes

Cited by in corpus (65)

• First observation of PeV-energy neutrinos with IceCube
• Sensitivity of the IceCube Detector to Astrophysical Sources of High Energy Muon Neutrinos
• Search for dark matter annihilations in the Sun with the 79-string IceCube detector
• The contribution of Fermi-2LAC blazars to the diffuse TeV-PeV neutrino flux
• Differential limit on the extremely-high-energy cosmic neutrino flux in the presence of astrophysical background from nine years of IceCube data
• Search for annihilating dark matter in the Sun with 3 years of IceCube data
• Constraints on Cosmic Neutrino Fluxes from the ANITA Experiment
• Search for Cosmic Neutrino Point Sources with Four Years of Data from the ANTARES Telescope
• A Search for a Diffuse Flux of Astrophysical Muon Neutrinos with the IceCube 40-String Detector
• Multi-year search for a diffuse flux of muon neutrinos with AMANDA-II
• Search for a diffuse flux of astrophysical muon neutrinos with the IceCube 59-string configuration
• First Search for Dark Matter Annihilation in the Sun Using the ANTARES Neutrino Telescope
• Search for extraterrestrial point sources of neutrinos with AMANDA-II
• Limits on diffuse fluxes of high energy extraterrestrial neutrinos with the AMANDA-B10 detector
• Results from the search for dark matter in the Milky Way with 9 years of data of the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Probing the origin of cosmic-rays with extremely high energy neutrinos using the IceCube Observatory
• Time-Dependent Point Source Search Methods in High Energy Neutrino Astronomy
• Search for Neutrino-Induced Cascades with AMANDA
• Five years of searches for point sources of astrophysical neutrinos with the AMANDA-II neutrino telescope
• Search for a diffuse flux of high-energy ${\nu }_{\mu }$ with the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Search for non-relativistic Magnetic Monopoles with IceCube
• Search of Dark Matter Annihilation in the Galactic Centre using the ANTARES Neutrino Telescope
• All-flavor search for a diffuse flux of cosmic neutrinos with 9 years of ANTARES data
• Search for Point Sources of High Energy Neutrinos with Final Data from AMANDA-II
• First search for atmospheric and extraterrestrial neutrino-induced cascades with the IceCube detector
• Constraints on the neutrino emission from the Galactic Ridge with the ANTARES telescope
• A search for Secluded Dark Matter in the Sun with the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Multipole analysis of IceCube data to search for dark matter accumulated in the Galactic halo
• Search for neutrino emission from relic dark matter in the Sun with the Baikal NT200 detector
• Search for extraterrestrial point sources of high energy neutrinos with AMANDA-II using data collected in 2000-2002
• Search for Relativistic Magnetic Monopoles with IceCube
• Search for Extremely-High-Energy Neutrinos and First Constraints on the Ultrahigh-Energy Cosmic-Ray Proton Fraction with IceCube
• Search for high-energy muon neutrinos from the "naked-eye" GRB 080319B with the IceCube neutrino telescope
• Search for neutrino-induced cascades from gamma-ray bursts with AMANDA
• A Search for Neutrino Emission from the Fermi Bubbles with the ANTARES Telescope
• Search for neutrino-induced particle showers with IceCube-40
• A Search for UHE Tau Neutrinos with IceCube
• Enhanced Sensitivity to Dark Matter Self-annihilations in the Sun using Neutrino Spectral Information
• Search for Relativistic Magnetic Monopoles with Eight Years of IceCube Data
• Constraining Secluded Dark Matter models with the public data from the 79-string IceCube search for dark matter in the Sun
• Limits on the high-energy gamma and neutrino fluxes from the SGR 1806-20 giant flare of December 27th, 2004 with the AMANDA-II detector
• An algorithm for the reconstruction of high-energy neutrino-induced particle showers and its application to the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Search for relativistic magnetic monopoles with five years of the ANTARES detector data
• Neutrino Astronomy with IceCube
• Search for Magnetic Monopoles with ten years of the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Search for a correlation between ANTARES neutrinos and Pierre Auger Observatory UHECRs arrival directions
• A search for neutrino signal from dark matter annihilation in the center of the Milky Way with Baikal NT200
• Probing light exotics from a hidden sector at $c$-$\tau$ factories with polarized electron beams
• Probing the connection between IceCube neutrinos and MOJAVE AGN
• Simulation of the cosmic ray tau neutrino telescope (CRTNT) experiment
• From AMANDA to IceCube
• New results from the Antarctic Muon And Neutrino Detector Array
• Upper Limit on the Diffuse Flux of Cosmic ${\nu }_{\mu }$ with the ANTARES Neutrino Telescope
• Constraints and prospects on GW and neutrino emissions using GW150914
• Limits on the nuclearite flux using the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Constraints and prospects on gravitational wave and neutrino emission using GW150914
• Searches for neutrino counterparts of gravitational waves from the LIGO/Virgo third observing run with KM3NeT
• Nuclearite search with ANTARES
• Search for Dark Matter in the Sun with the ANTARES Neutrino Telescope in the CMSSM and mUED frameworks
• Search for relativistic Magnetic Monopoles with ten years of the ANTARES detector data
• The Search for Muon Neutrinos from Northern Hemisphere Gamma-Ray Bursts with AMANDA
• Upper Limit on the Diffuse ${\nu }_{\mu }$ Flux with the ANTARES Telescope
• Dark matter search with the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Indirect dark matter search with the ANTARES neutrino telescope
• Search for Ultra High-Energy Neutrinos with AMANDA-II