Magnetic Field Diagnostics Based on Far-Infrared Polarimetry: Tests Using Numerical Simulations
arXiv:astro-ph/0103286 · doi:10.1086/323489
Abstract
The dynamical state of star-forming molecular clouds cannot be understood without determining the structure and strength of their magnetic fields. Measurements of polarized far-infrared radiation from thermally aligned dust grains are used to map the orientation of the field and estimate its strength, but the accuracy of the results has remained in doubt. In order to assess the reliability of this method, we apply it to simulated far-infrared polarization maps derived from three-dimensional simulations of supersonic magnetohydrodynamical turbulence, and compare the estimated values to the known magnetic field strengths in the simulations. We investigate the effects of limited telescope resolution and self-gravity on the structure of the maps. Limited observational resolution affects the field structure such that small scale variations can be completely suppressed, thus giving the impression of a very homogeneous field. The Chandrasekhar-Fermi method of estimating the mean magnetic field in a turbulent medium is tested, and we suggest an extension to measure the rms field. Both methods yield results within a factor of 2 for field strengths typical of molecular clouds, with the modified version returning more reliable estimates for slightly weaker fields. However, neither method alone works well for very weak fields, missing them by a factor of up to 150. Taking the geometric mean of both methods estimates even the weakest fields accurately within a factor of 2.5. Limited telescope resolution leads to a systematic overestimation of the field strengths for all methods. We discuss the effects responsible for this overestimation and show how to extract information on the underlying (turbulent) power spectrum.
30 pages, 15 figures (figs 1, 4, 5 reduced quality), submitted to ApJ Hires version of figs 1, 4, 5 see ftp://ftp.mpia-hd.mpg.de/pub/heitsch/HZM00/hiresfigs.tar.gz
References in corpus (1)
Cited by in corpus (116)
- Control of star formation by supersonic turbulence
- Planck intermediate results. XXXV. Probing the role of the magnetic field in the formation of structure in molecular clouds
- Dispersion of Magnetic Fields in Molecular Clouds. I
- An Imprint of Molecular Cloud Magnetization in the Morphology of the Dust Polarized Emission
- SCUBA Polarization Measurements of the Magnetic Field Strengths in the L183, L1544, and L43 Prestellar Cores
- Dispersion of Magnetic Fields in Molecular Clouds. II
- Magnetically Aligned HI Fibers and the Rolling Hough Transform
- Magnetic Fields in High-Mass Infrared Dark Clouds
- Studies of regular and random magnetic fields in the ISM: statistics of polarization vectors and the Chandrasekhar-Fermi technique
- The James Clerk Maxwell Telescope Legacy Survey of Nearby Star-forming Regions in the Gould Belt
- Theoretical Models of Polarized Dust Emission from Protostellar Cores
- Radiation-magnetohydrodynamic simulations of HII regions and their associated PDRs in turbulent molecular clouds
- Statistical Properties of Galactic Starlight Polarization
- The JCMT BISTRO Survey: The magnetic field strength in the Orion A filament
- First results from BISTRO -- a SCUBA-2 polarimeter survey of the Gould Belt
- IRAS 16293: A "Magnetic" Tale of Two Cores
- Interferometric observations of magnetic fields in forming stars
- Magnetic Fields in Diffuse H I and Molecular Clouds
- Star Formation in Isolated Disk Galaxies. I. Models and Characteristics of Nonlinear Gravitational Collapse
- Magnetically Dominated Strands of Cold Hydrogen in the Riegel-Crutcher Cloud
- A Radio and Optical Polarization Study of the Magnetic Field in the Small Magellanic Cloud
- Evolution of Magnetic Fields in High Mass Star Formation: Linking field geometry and collapse for the W51 e2/e8 cores
- The Average Magnetic Field Strength in Molecular Clouds: New Evidence of Super-Alfvenic Turbulence
- Effects of Magnetic Field Strength and Orientation on Molecular Cloud Formation
- High-accuracy estimation of magnetic field strength in the interstellar medium from dust polarization
- Polarization of Dust Emission in Clumpy Molecular Clouds and Cores
- Submillimeter and Far-Infrared Polarimetric Observations of Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Regions
- Dust polarized emission observations of NGC 6334; BISTRO reveals the details of the complex but organized magnetic field structure of the high-mass star-forming hub-filament network
- Magnetic fields in massive star forming regions
- Magnetic field evolution in Bok globules
- Change of Magnetic FieldGas Alignment at Gravity-Driven Alfvénic Transition in Molecular Clouds: Implications for Dust Polarization Observations
- A holistic perspective on the dynamics of G035.39-00.33: the interplay between gas and magnetic fields
- Magnetic Field Strength Maps for Molecular Clouds: A New Method Based on a Polarization - Intensity Gradient Relation
- Submillimeter Array Observations of Magnetic Fields in G240.31+0.07: an Hourglass in a Massive Cluster-forming Core
- From parallel to perpendicular -- On the orientation of magnetic fields in molecular clouds
- From diffuse gas to dense molecular cloud cores
- Magnetic fields towards Ophiuchus-B derived from SCUBA-2 polarization measurements
- Results of SPARO 2003: Mapping Magnetic Fields in Giant Molecular Clouds
- A First Look at BISTRO Observations of The Oph-A core
- Protostellar mass accretion rates from gravoturbulent fragmentation
- Does the magnetic field suppress fragmentation in massive dense cores?
- JCMT BISTRO survey: Magnetic Fields within the Hub-Filament Structure in IC 5146
- The magnetic field and dust filaments in the Polaris Flare
- Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Molecular Clouds III. Submillimeter Polarimetry of Intermediate Mass Cores and Filaments in Orion B
- A technique for constraining the driving scale of turbulence and a modified Chandrasekhar-Fermi method
- The JCMT BISTRO Survey: The Magnetic Field In The Starless Core Ophiuchus C
- Calibrating the Davis-Chandrasekhar-Fermi method with numerical simulations: uncertainties in estimating the magnetic field strength from statistics of field orientations
- Magnetic fields in the infrared dark cloud G34.43+0.24
- Magnetic fields in star formation: a complete compilation of all the DCF estimations
- JCMT POL-2 and BISTRO Survey observations of magnetic fields in the L1689 molecular cloud
- SILCC-Zoom: Polarisation and depolarisation in molecular clouds
- Diffusion in supersonic, turbulent, compressible flows
- Interferometric mapping of magnetic fields: The ALMA view of the massive star forming clump W43-MM1
- Near-Infrared Imaging Polarimetry of the Serpens Cloud Core: Magnetic Field Structure, Outflows, and Inflows in A Cluster Forming Clump
- Mapping the magnetic field in the Taurus/B211 filamentary cloud with SOFIA HAWC+ and comparing with simulation
- Star Formation in Molecular Clouds
- Magnetic field properties in star formation: a review of their analysis methods and interpretation
- Magnetic fields in the early stages of massive star formation as revealed by ALMA
- Magnetic field strength from turbulence theory (I): Using differential measure approach (DMA)
- Magnetic Fields in Massive Star-Forming Regions (MagMaR) II. Tomography Through Dust and Molecular Line Polarization in NGC 6334I(N)
- Evaluating the Magnetic Field Strength in Molecular Clouds
- Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability in a Weakly Ionized Medium
- CN Zeeman and dust polarization in a high-mass cold clump
- Canals beyond Mars: Beam depolarization in radio continuum maps of the warm ISM
- Estimating Column Density in Molecular Clouds with FIR and Sub-mm Emission Maps
- The role of the magnetic field in the fragmentation process: the case of G14.225-0.506
- Ambipolar Diffusion Heating in Turbulent Systems
- The JCMT BISTRO-2 Survey: Magnetic Fields of the Massive DR21 Filament
- The Davis-Chandrasekhar-Fermi Method Revisited
- ALMA reveals the magnetic field evolution in the high-mass star forming complex G9.62+0.19
- Dust heating by the interstellar radiation field in models of turbulent molecular clouds
- Rotating filament in Orion B: Do cores inherit their angular momentum from their parent filament?
- Comparison of Magnetic Field Structures on Different Scales in and around the Filamentary Dark Cloud GF 9
- First polarimetry results of two candidate high-mass protostellar objects
- The seven most massive clumps in W43-Main as seen by ALMA: Dynamical equilibrium and Magnetic Fields
- The magnetic field in the NGC 2024 FIR 5 dense core
- Nature of Striation in 21 cm Channel Maps: Velocity Caustics
- Magnetic field geometry of an unusual cometary cloud Gal 110-13
- Submillimeter Polarimetry with PolKa, a reflection-type modulator for the APEX telescope
- Distortion of Magnetic Fields in a Starless Core IV: Magnetic Field Scaling on Density and Mass-to-flux Ratio Distribution in FeSt 1-457
- Probing the magnetic fields in L1415 and L1389
- Sub-Alfvenic Non-Ideal MHD Turbulence Simulations with Ambipolar Diffusion: III. Implications for Observations and Turbulent Enhancement
- Irregular Magnetic Fields and the Far-Infrared Polarimetry of Dust Emission from Interstellar Clouds
- Understanding the links among magnetic fields, filament, the bipolar bubble, and star formation in RCW57A using NIR polarimetry
- Unravelling the structure of magnetised molecular clouds with SILCC-Zoom: sheets, filaments and fragmentation
- HI-H transition: exploring the role of the magnetic field
- Evolution of the Hub-filament Structures in IC 5146 in the Context of the Energy Balance of Gravity, Turbulence, and Magnetic Field
- Distortion of Magnetic Fields in Barnard 335
- Cloud Dispersal in Turbulent Flows
- The Magnetic Field Structure of the LMC 2 Supershell: NGC 2100
- Compressed magnetic field in the magnetically-regulated global collapsing clump of G9.62+0.19
- Structure Generation by Irradiation: What can GLIMPSE teach us about the ISM structure?
- Distortion of Magnetic Fields in a Starless Core VI: Application of Flux Freezing Model and Core Formation of FeSt 1-457
- Magnetic fields and Star Formation around HII regions: The S235 complex
- A Comparison of Multi-Phase Magnetic Field Tracers in a High-Galactic Latitude Region of the Filamentary Interstellar Medium
- Distortion of Magnetic Fields in BHR 71
- The JCMT BISTRO-2 Survey: The Magnetic Field in the Center of the Rosette Molecular Cloud
- The Role of Magnetic Fields in the Formation of the Filamentary Infrared Dark Cloud G11.11-0.12
- Aspect ratios of far-infrared and H i filaments in the diffuse interstellar medium at high Galactic latitudes
- CO enhancement by magnetohydrodynamic waves; Striations in the Polaris Flare
- Turbulent Fragmentation and Star Formation
- Magnetic field measurement from the Davis-Chandrasekhar-Fermi method employed with Atomic Alignment
- Distortion of Magnetic Fields in the Dense Core CB81 (L1774, Pipe 42) in the Pipe Nebula
- A study of 90 GHz dust emissivity on molecular cloud and filament scales
- Tracing the magnetic field morphology of the LDN 1172/1174 cloud complex
- Analytic characterization of sub-Alfvénic turbulence energetics
- Distortion of Magnetic Fields in the Dense Core SL42 (CrA-E) in the Corona Australis Molecular Cloud Complex
- Widespread subsonic turbulence in Ophiuchus North 1
- Diagnostics of magnetohydrodynamic modes in the ISM through synchrotron polarization statistics
- Why take the square root? An assessment of interstellar magnetic field strength estimation methods
- Turbulence in the Star-forming Interstellar Medium: Steps toward Constraining Theories with Observations
- Obtaining strength of magnetic field from E and B modes of dust polarization
- Optical polarimetry of HH 135/HH 136
- Multi-scale Dust Polarization and Spiral-like Stokes-I Residual in the Class I Protostellar System TMC-1A
- A Survey of Magnetic Field Properties in Bok Globules
- Magneto-Gravitational Regulated Streamer Accretion onto a Class 0 Protostellar System