New Evidence for Black Hole Event Horizons from Chandra

Abstract

Previously we claimed that Black Hole X-ray Novae (BHXN) in quiescence are much less luminous than equivalent Neutron Star X-ray Novae (NSXN). This claim was based on the quiescent detection of a single short period BHXN (A0620-00, P(orb)=7.8 hrs) and two longer period BHXN (GRO J1655-40, P(orb)=62.9 hrs; V404 Cyg, P(orb)=155.3 hrs), along with sensitive upper limits. We announce the detection of two more short period BHXN (GRO J0422+32, P(orb)=5.1 hrs; GS 2000+25, P(orb)=8.3 hrs), an upper limit for a third which is improved by two orders of magnitude (4U 1543-47, P(orb)=27.0 hrs) and a new, much lower quiescent measurement of GRO J1655-40. Taken together, these new Chandra measurements confirm that the quiescent X-ray luminosities of BHXN are significantly lower than those of NSXN. We argue that this provides strong evidence for the existence of event horizons in BHXN.

arXiv commentSubmitted to ApJ Letters, 4 pages, 2 figures

References in corpus (23)

• Advection-Dominated Accretion: A Self-Similar Solution
• On the Fate of Gas Accreting at a Low Rate onto a Black Hole
• Advection-Dominated Accretion: Self-Similarity and Bipolar Outflows
• Advection-Dominated Accretion Model of Sagittarius A*: Evidence for a Black Hole at the Galactic Center
• A Catalog of 200 Galaxy Clusters Serendipitously Detected in the ROSAT PSPC Pointed Observations
• Crustal Heating and Quiescent Emission from Transiently Accreting Neutron Stars
• The two-hour orbit of a binary millisecond X-ray pulsar
• A New Model for Black Hole Soft X-ray Transients in Quiescence
• Advection-Dominated Accretion and Black Hole Event Horizons
• Spectral Models of Advection-Dominated Accretion Flows with Winds
• Black Hole and Neutron Star Transients in Quiescence
• Advection-Dominated Accretion Model of the Black Hole V404 Cyg in Quiescence
• On the bolometric quiescent luminosity and luminosity swing of black hole candidate and neutron star low mass X-ray transients
• What is the Accretion Rate in Sgr A*?
• A First Look at the Nuclear Region of M31 with Chandra
• Accretion onto nearby supermassive black holes: Chandra constraints on the dominant cluster galaxy NGC 6166
• Limits on the accretion rates onto massive black holes in nearby galaxies
• Coronal X-Ray Emission from the Stellar Companions to Transiently Accreting Black Holes
• HST/STIS UV Spectroscopy of Two Quiescent X-ray Novae: A0620-00 and Centaurus X-4
• The Population of Faint Transients in the Galactic Centre
• The discovery of quiescent X-ray emission from SAX J1808.4-3658, the transient 2.5ms pulsar
• X-Ray Flux Decrease of the Accretion-Powered Millisecond Pulsar SAX J1808.4-3658 in Quiescence Detected by ASCA
• The Chandra X-Ray Observatory's Radiation Environment and the AP-8/AE-8 Model

Cited by in corpus (174)

• X-ray Properties of Black-Hole Binaries
• Hot Accretion Flows Around Black Holes
• Compact Object Modeling with the StarTrack Population Synthesis Code
• A universal radio/X-ray correlation in low/hard state black hole binaries
• First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. VI: Testing the Black Hole Metric
• Foundations of Black Hole Accretion Disk Theory
• Advection-Dominated Accretion and the Black Hole Event Horizon
• Radio / X-ray correlation in the low/hard state of GX 339--4
• Probes and Tests of Strong-Field Gravity with Observations in the Electromagnetic Spectrum
• Jets in neutron star X-ray binaries: a comparison with black holes
• A Hydrogen Atmosphere Spectral Model Applied to the Neutron Star X7 in the Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae
• Jet-dominated states: an alternative to advection across black hole event horizons in `quiescent' X-ray binaries
• Global optical/infrared - X-ray correlations in X-ray binaries: quantifying disc and jet contributions
• Dynamical Evidence for a Black Hole in the Microquasar XTE J1550-564
• High Resolution X-ray Imaging of a Globular Cluster Core: Compact Binaries in 47Tuc
• No observational proof of the black-hole event-horizon
• Black Holes in Astrophysics
• A radio-emitting outflow in the quiescent state of A0620-00: implications for modelling low-luminosity black hole binaries
• A Be-type star with a black hole companion
• A wide star-black-hole binary system from radial-velocity measurements
• The first accurate parallax distance to a black hole
• Crustal Emission and the Quiescent Spectrum of the Neutron Star in KS 1731-260
• Radio--X-ray Correlation and the "Quiescent State" of Black Hole Sources
• The Distance and Interstellar Sight Line to GX339-4
• The Inclination of the Soft X-ray Transient A0620--00 and the Mass of its Black Hole
• Observing the effects of the event horizon in black holes
• The X-ray Spectral Evolution of Galactic Black Hole X-ray Binaries Toward Quiescence
• The radio/X-ray domain of black hole X-ray binaries at the lowest radio luminosities
• Chandra observation of the fast X-ray transient IGR J17544-2619: evidence for a neutron star?
• Disc-jet coupling in the 2009 outburst of the black hole candidate H1743-322
• A Radio-Selected Black Hole X-ray Binary Candidate in the Milky Way Globular Cluster M62
• The X-ray Spectra of Black Hole X-ray Novae in Quiescence as Measured by Chandra
• Discovery of X-ray Jets in the Microquasar H 1743-322
• Deep radio imaging of 47 Tuc identifies the peculiar X-ray source X9 as a new black hole candidate
• X-Rays from Isolated Black Holes in the Milky Way
• Variability in the Thermal Emission from Accreting Neutron Star Transients
• A Chandra X-ray Observation of the Binary Millisecond Pulsar PSR J1023+0038
• Surface Emission from Neutron Stars and Implications for the Physics of their Interiors
• An XMM-Newton study of the 401 Hz accreting pulsar SAX J1808.4-3658 in quiescence
• Spectral and Timing Evolution of the Black Hole X-ray Nova 4U 1543-47 During its 2002 Outburst
• Multiwavelength Spectrum of the Black Hole XTE J1118+480 in Quiescence
• Neutron Star Mass-Radius Constraints of the Quiescent Low-mass X-ray Binaries X7 and X5 in the Globular Cluster 47 Tuc
• Constraining Alternate Models of Black Holes: Type I X-ray Bursts on Accreting Fermion-Fermion and Boson-Fermion Stars
• Intermediate Mass Black Holes in Accreting Binaries: Formation, Evolution and Observational Appearance
• The spectral energy distribution of quiescent black hole X-ray binaries: new constraints from Spitzer
• The Event Horizon of M87
• The Inclination Angle of and Mass of the Black Hole in XTE J1118+480
• On the origin of black hole X-ray emission in quiescence: Chandra observations of XTE J1550-564 and H 1743-322
• On the Lack of Thermal Emission from the Quiescent Black Hole XTE J1118+480: Evidence for the Event Horizon
• An X-ray Variable Millisecond Pulsar in the Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae: Closing the Link to Low Mass X-ray Binaries
• The behavior of subluminous X-ray transients near the Galactic center as observed using the X-ray telescope aboard Swift
• The runaway black hole GRO J1655-40
• The black hole candidate XTE J1752-223 towards and in quiescence: optical and simultaneous X-ray - radio observations
• Analysing the atolls: X-ray spectral transitions of accreting neutron stars
• Black Holes at Future Colliders and Beyond: a Topical Review
• Spectral Fits to the 1999 Aql X-1 Outburst Data
• Identification of black hole power spectral components across all canonical states
• Orbital Period and Outburst Luminosity of Transient Low Mass X-ray Binaries
• Following the 2008 outburst decay of the black hole candidate H1743-322 in X-ray and radio
• The Quiescent Spectral Energy Distribution of V404 Cyg
• The black hole candidate MAXIJ1659-152 in and towards quiescence in X-ray and radio
• Detection of Low-Hard State Spectral and Timing Signatures from the Black Hole X-Ray Transient XTE J1650-500 at Low X-Ray Luminosities
• The radio spectrum of a quiescent stellar mass black hole
• Correlated X-ray and Optical Variability in V404 Cyg in Quiescence
• X-Ray Observations of the Black Hole Transient 4U 1630-47 During Two Years of X-Ray Activity
• X-Ray Observations of XTE J1550-564 During the Decay of the 2000 Outburst - I. Chandra and RXTE Energy Spectra
• Is there a Supermassive Black Hole at the Center of the Milky Way?
• X-Ray Jet Emission from the Black Hole X-Ray Binary XTE J1550-564 with Chandra in 2000
• Inclination Effects and Beaming in Black Hole X-ray Binaries
• Multiwavelength Observations of A0620-00 in Quiescence
• Chandra Localizations and Spectra of INTEGRAL Sources in the Galactic Plane
• XMM-Newton observations of the black hole X-ray transient XTE J1650-500 in quiescence
• An Ultra-deep Chandra Catalog of X-ray Point Sources in the Galactic Center Star Cluster
• A Chandra observation of the neutron star X-ray transient and eclipsing binary MXB 1659-29 in quiescence
• The Maveric Survey: a Red Straggler Binary with an Invisible Companion in the Galactic Globular Cluster M10
• XMM-Newton observations of two black hole X-ray transients in quiescence
• The cold neutron star in the soft X-ray transient 1H 1905+000
• Low-Mass X-ray Binaries
• The Quiescent X-ray Spectrum of Accreting Black Holes
• New Gamma Cas-like objects: X-ray and optical observations of SAO49725 and HD161103
• A deep radio survey of hard state and quiescent black hole X-ray binaries
• The Spectrum of the Black Hole X-ray Nova V404 Cygni in Quiescence as Measured by XMM-Newton
• An XMM-Newton Observation of 4U1755-33 in Quiescence: Evidence for a Fossil X-Ray Jet
• Characterizing X-ray and Radio emission in the Black Hole X-Ray Binary V404 Cygni during Quiescence
• A Chandra observation of the old open cluster M67
• The X-ray properties of the black hole transient MAXI J1659-152 in quiescence
• The faint neutron star soft X-ray transient SAX J1810.8-2609 in quiescence
• Understanding X-ray Irradiation in Low-Mass X-ray Binaries directly from their Light-Curves
• The neutron star soft X-ray transient 1H1905+000 in quiescence
• Evidence For Intrinsic Magnetic Moments in Black Hole Candidates
• Halpha Flares from V404 Cyg in Quiescence
• Chandra Detections of Two Quiescent Black Hole X-Ray Transients
• Swift J1357.2-0933: the faintest black hole?
• Zooming in on a sleeping giant: milliarcsecond HSA imaging of the black hole binary V404 Cyg in quiescence
• The observed mass distribution of Galactic black hole LMXBs is biased against massive black holes
• Radio and X-ray observations during the outburst decay of the Black Hole Candidate XTE J1908+094
• Very High Angular Resolution Science with the Square Kilometre Array
• Spectral and Temporal Behavior of the Black Hole Candidate XTE J1118+480 as Observed with BeppoSAX
• Multiwavelength observations of the black hole X-ray binary A0620-00 in quiescence
• The Chandra Small Magellanic Cloud Wing Survey - the search for X-ray Binaries
• A Delayed Transition to the Hard State for 4U 1630-47 at the End of Its 2010 Outburst
• The Rates of type I X-ray Bursts from Transients Observed with RXTE: Evidence for Black Hole Event Horizons
• The X-ray binary population in the Galactic Center revealed through multi-decade observations
• The Galactic Center as a laboratory for theories of gravity and dark matter
• An Anomalous Quiescent Stellar Mass Black Hole
• Evolution of the spin parameter of accreting compact objects with non-Kerr quadrupole moment
• Discovery of a bright X-ray transient in the Galactic Center with XMM-Newton
• Discovery of X-ray eclipses from the transient source CXOGC J174540.0-290031 with XMM-Newton
• Astrometric observations of X-ray binaries using very long baseline interferometry
• An anti-correlation between X-ray luminosity and H-alpha equivalent width in X-ray binaries
• Up and Down the Black Hole Radio/X-ray Correlation: the 2017 mini-outbursts from Swift J1753.5-0127
• X-ray binaries in Sculptor
• The discovery of X-ray binaries in the Sculptor Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy
• Identification of 5 Interacting Binaries in the Galactic Bulge Survey
• An X-ray-UV correlation in Cen X-4 during quiescence
• An accreting millisecond pulsar with black hole-like X-ray variability: IGR J00291+5934
• The Low Quiescent X-Ray Luminosity of the Transient X-Ray Burster EXO 1747-214
• Formation of Black Hole Low-Mass X-ray Binaries
• The Ultraviolet Spectral Energy Distributions of Quiescent Black Holes and Neutron Stars
• 'Disc-jet' coupling in black hole X-ray binaries and active galactic nuclei
• Localization of the X-ray Source in the Globular Cluster G1 with Chandra
• Swift J174540.7-290015: a new accreting binary in the Galactic Center
• A broadband look at the old and new ULXs of NGC 6946
• An XMM-Newton observation of the neutron star X-ray transient 2S 1803-245 in quiescence
• Polarized synchrotron emission in quiescent black hole X-ray transients
• Response to Comment on "A Non-Interacting Low-Mass Black Hole -- Giant Star Binary System"
• XMM-Newton detection of Nova Muscae 1991 in Quiescence
• Long-term optical/infrared variability in the quiescent X-ray transient V404 Cyg
• Testing General Relativity with High-Resolution Imaging of Sgr A*
• What is the closest black hole to the Sun?
• On the Final State of Spherical Gravitational Collapse
• Optical and J,K-photometry of black hole X-ray nova A0620-00 in passive and active stages of quiescence
• Chandra detection of XTE J1650-500 in quiescence and the minimum luminosity of black hole X-ray binaries
• Selection Effects on the Orbital Period Distribution of Low Mass Black Hole X-ray Binaries
• NuSTAR and Chandra observations of new X-ray transients in the central parsec of the Galaxy
• The X-ray quiescence of Swift J195509.6+261406 (GRB 070610): an optical bursting X-ray binary?
• XMM-Newton and INTEGRAL observations of the very faint X-ray transient IGRJ17285-2922/XTEJ1728-295 during the 2010 outburst
• Possibility of a White Dwarf as the Accreting Compact Star in CI Cam (= XTE J0421+560)
• Variability of Optical Counterparts in the Chandra Galactic Bulge Survey
• Uncovering the Nature of the X-ray Transient 4U 1730-22: Discovery of X-ray Emission from a Neutron Star in Quiescence with Chandra
• Two new bursting neutron star low-mass X-ray binaries: Swift J185003.2-005627 and Swift J1922.7-1716
• Holonomy invariance, orbital resonances, and kilohertz QPOs
• The enigmatic black-hole candidate and X-ray transient IGR J17091-3624 in its quiescent state as seen with XMM-Newton
• Investigating CXOU J163802.6-471358: a new pulsar wind nebula in the Norma region?
• GS 2000+25: The Least Luminous Black Hole X-ray Binary
• Quiescent X-Ray/Optical Counterparts of the Black Hole Transient H 1705-250
• MAXI and NuSTAR observations of the faint X-ray transient MAXI J1848-015 in the GLIMPSE-C01 Cluster
• Very low luminosities from the accretion-driven millisecond X-ray pulsar SAX J1808.4-3658 during quiescence
• Galactic Sources Detected in the NuSTAR Serendipitous Survey
• Radio emission and jets from microquasars
• On the recurrence times of neutron star X-ray binary transients and the nature of the Galactic Centre quiescent X-ray binaries
• Energy Spectra and Normalized Power Spectral Densities of X-Ray Nova GS 2000+25
• Quiescent NIR and optical counterparts to candidate black hole X-ray binaries
• An X-ray Transient and Optical Counterpart in the M31 Bulge
• Spherical accretion: the influence of inner boundary and quasi-periodic oscillations
• Unsupervised spectral decomposition of X-ray binaries with application to GX 339-4
• Nonthermal processes and neutrino emission from the black hole GRO J0422+32 in a bursting state
• SWIFT J1749.4-2807: A neutron or quark star?
• Robust Models for Phase Shifts in Accreting Binary Stars
• Eclipses of jets and discs of X-ray binaries as a powerful tool for understanding jet physics and binary parameters
• Outliers: multicolour photometry guiding the search for evolved binary systems in the globular cluster 47 Tucanae
• The advection-dominated accretion flow for the origin of the thermal soft X-ray component in low-level accreting neutron stars
• XMM-Newton observation of 4U 1543-475: the X-ray spectrum of a stellar-mass black-hole at low luminosity
• An updated gamma-ray analysis of the Be-BH binary HD~215227
• Atomic X-ray Spectroscopy of Accreting Black Holes
• ROSAT/Chandra Observations of a Bright Transient in M81
• Hot accretion flow around neutron stars
• Lithium production on a low-mass secondary in a black hole soft X-ray transient
• I-band photometry of the quiescent black hole X-ray nova GROJ0422+32=V518 Per: modelling of the orbital light curve and estimation of the black hole mass
• How To Distinguish Neutron Star and Black Hole X-ray Binaries? Spectral index and Quasi-Periodic Oscillation Frequency Correlation
• High-resolution radio observations of X-ray binaries
• Two-temperature radiative hot accretion flow around neutron stars
• The black hole X-ray binary MAXI J1348$-$630 in quiescence
• Constraints on horizonless objects after the EHT observation of Sagittarius A*