New Evidence for Black Hole Event Horizons from Chandra

Abstract

Previously we claimed that Black Hole X-ray Novae (BHXN) in quiescence are much less luminous than equivalent Neutron Star X-ray Novae (NSXN). This claim was based on the quiescent detection of a single short period BHXN (A0620-00, P(orb)=7.8 hrs) and two longer period BHXN (GRO J1655-40, P(orb)=62.9 hrs; V404 Cyg, P(orb)=155.3 hrs), along with sensitive upper limits. We announce the detection of two more short period BHXN (GRO J0422+32, P(orb)=5.1 hrs; GS 2000+25, P(orb)=8.3 hrs), an upper limit for a third which is improved by two orders of magnitude (4U 1543-47, P(orb)=27.0 hrs) and a new, much lower quiescent measurement of GRO J1655-40. Taken together, these new Chandra measurements confirm that the quiescent X-ray luminosities of BHXN are significantly lower than those of NSXN. We argue that this provides strong evidence for the existence of event horizons in BHXN.

Submitted to ApJ Letters, 4 pages, 2 figures

References in corpus (23)

• Advection-Dominated Accretion: A Self-Similar Solution
• On the Fate of Gas Accreting at a Low Rate onto a Black Hole
• Advection-Dominated Accretion: Self-Similarity and Bipolar Outflows
• Advection-Dominated Accretion Model of Sagittarius A*: Evidence for a Black Hole at the Galactic Center
• A Catalog of 200 Galaxy Clusters Serendipitously Detected in the ROSAT PSPC Pointed Observations
• Crustal Heating and Quiescent Emission from Transiently Accreting Neutron Stars
• The two-hour orbit of a binary millisecond X-ray pulsar
• A New Model for Black Hole Soft X-ray Transients in Quiescence
• Advection-Dominated Accretion and Black Hole Event Horizons
• Spectral Models of Advection-Dominated Accretion Flows with Winds
• Black Hole and Neutron Star Transients in Quiescence
• Advection-Dominated Accretion Model of the Black Hole V404 Cyg in Quiescence
• On the bolometric quiescent luminosity and luminosity swing of black hole candidate and neutron star low mass X-ray transients
• What is the Accretion Rate in Sgr A*?
• A First Look at the Nuclear Region of M31 with Chandra
• Accretion onto nearby supermassive black holes: Chandra constraints on the dominant cluster galaxy NGC 6166
• Limits on the accretion rates onto massive black holes in nearby galaxies
• Coronal X-Ray Emission from the Stellar Companions to Transiently Accreting Black Holes
• HST/STIS UV Spectroscopy of Two Quiescent X-ray Novae: A0620-00 and Centaurus X-4
• The Population of Faint Transients in the Galactic Centre
• The discovery of quiescent X-ray emission from SAX J1808.4-3658, the transient 2.5ms pulsar
• X-Ray Flux Decrease of the Accretion-Powered Millisecond Pulsar SAX J1808.4-3658 in Quiescence Detected by ASCA
• The Chandra X-Ray Observatory's Radiation Environment and the AP-8/AE-8 Model

Cited by in corpus (174)

• X-ray Properties of Black-Hole Binaries
• Hot Accretion Flows Around Black Holes
• Compact Object Modeling with the StarTrack Population Synthesis Code
• A universal radio/X-ray correlation in low/hard state black hole binaries
• First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. VI: Testing the Black Hole Metric
• Foundations of Black Hole Accretion Disk Theory
• Advection-Dominated Accretion and the Black Hole Event Horizon
• Radio / X-ray correlation in the low/hard state of GX 339--4
• Probes and Tests of Strong-Field Gravity with Observations in the Electromagnetic Spectrum
• Jets in neutron star X-ray binaries: a comparison with black holes
• A Hydrogen Atmosphere Spectral Model Applied to the Neutron Star X7 in the Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae
• Jet-dominated states: an alternative to advection across black hole event horizons in `quiescent' X-ray binaries
• Global optical/infrared - X-ray correlations in X-ray binaries: quantifying disc and jet contributions
• Dynamical Evidence for a Black Hole in the Microquasar XTE J1550-564
• High Resolution X-ray Imaging of a Globular Cluster Core: Compact Binaries in 47Tuc
• No observational proof of the black-hole event-horizon
• Black Holes in Astrophysics
• A radio-emitting outflow in the quiescent state of A0620-00: implications for modelling low-luminosity black hole binaries
• A Be-type star with a black hole companion
• A wide star-black-hole binary system from radial-velocity measurements
• The first accurate parallax distance to a black hole
• Crustal Emission and the Quiescent Spectrum of the Neutron Star in KS 1731-260
• Radio--X-ray Correlation and the "Quiescent State" of Black Hole Sources
• The Distance and Interstellar Sight Line to GX339-4
• The Inclination of the Soft X-ray Transient A0620--00 and the Mass of its Black Hole
• Observing the effects of the event horizon in black holes
• The X-ray Spectral Evolution of Galactic Black Hole X-ray Binaries Toward Quiescence
• The radio/X-ray domain of black hole X-ray binaries at the lowest radio luminosities
• Chandra observation of the fast X-ray transient IGR J17544-2619: evidence for a neutron star?
• Disc-jet coupling in the 2009 outburst of the black hole candidate H1743-322
• A Radio-Selected Black Hole X-ray Binary Candidate in the Milky Way Globular Cluster M62
• The X-ray Spectra of Black Hole X-ray Novae in Quiescence as Measured by Chandra
• Discovery of X-ray Jets in the Microquasar H 1743-322
• Deep radio imaging of 47 Tuc identifies the peculiar X-ray source X9 as a new black hole candidate
• X-Rays from Isolated Black Holes in the Milky Way
• Variability in the Thermal Emission from Accreting Neutron Star Transients
• A Chandra X-ray Observation of the Binary Millisecond Pulsar PSR J1023+0038
• Surface Emission from Neutron Stars and Implications for the Physics of their Interiors
• An XMM-Newton study of the 401 Hz accreting pulsar SAX J1808.4-3658 in quiescence
• Spectral and Timing Evolution of the Black Hole X-ray Nova 4U 1543-47 During its 2002 Outburst
• Multiwavelength Spectrum of the Black Hole XTE J1118+480 in Quiescence
• Neutron Star Mass-Radius Constraints of the Quiescent Low-mass X-ray Binaries X7 and X5 in the Globular Cluster 47 Tuc
• Constraining Alternate Models of Black Holes: Type I X-ray Bursts on Accreting Fermion-Fermion and Boson-Fermion Stars
• Intermediate Mass Black Holes in Accreting Binaries: Formation, Evolution and Observational Appearance
• The spectral energy distribution of quiescent black hole X-ray binaries: new constraints from Spitzer
• The Event Horizon of M87
• The Inclination Angle of and Mass of the Black Hole in XTE J1118+480
• On the origin of black hole X-ray emission in quiescence: Chandra observations of XTE J1550-564 and H 1743-322
• On the Lack of Thermal Emission from the Quiescent Black Hole XTE J1118+480: Evidence for the Event Horizon
• An X-ray Variable Millisecond Pulsar in the Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae: Closing the Link to Low Mass X-ray Binaries
• The behavior of subluminous X-ray transients near the Galactic center as observed using the X-ray telescope aboard Swift
• The runaway black hole GRO J1655-40
• The black hole candidate XTE J1752-223 towards and in quiescence: optical and simultaneous X-ray - radio observations
• Analysing the atolls: X-ray spectral transitions of accreting neutron stars
• Black Holes at Future Colliders and Beyond: a Topical Review
• Spectral Fits to the 1999 Aql X-1 Outburst Data
• Identification of black hole power spectral components across all canonical states
• Orbital Period and Outburst Luminosity of Transient Low Mass X-ray Binaries
• Following the 2008 outburst decay of the black hole candidate H1743-322 in X-ray and radio
• The Quiescent Spectral Energy Distribution of V404 Cyg
• The black hole candidate MAXIJ1659-152 in and towards quiescence in X-ray and radio
• Detection of Low-Hard State Spectral and Timing Signatures from the Black Hole X-Ray Transient XTE J1650-500 at Low X-Ray Luminosities
• The radio spectrum of a quiescent stellar mass black hole
• Correlated X-ray and Optical Variability in V404 Cyg in Quiescence
• X-Ray Observations of the Black Hole Transient 4U 1630-47 During Two Years of X-Ray Activity
• X-Ray Observations of XTE J1550-564 During the Decay of the 2000 Outburst - I. Chandra and RXTE Energy Spectra
• Is there a Supermassive Black Hole at the Center of the Milky Way?
• X-Ray Jet Emission from the Black Hole X-Ray Binary XTE J1550-564 with Chandra in 2000
• Inclination Effects and Beaming in Black Hole X-ray Binaries
• Multiwavelength Observations of A0620-00 in Quiescence
• Chandra Localizations and Spectra of INTEGRAL Sources in the Galactic Plane
• XMM-Newton observations of the black hole X-ray transient XTE J1650-500 in quiescence
• An Ultra-deep Chandra Catalog of X-ray Point Sources in the Galactic Center Star Cluster
• A Chandra observation of the neutron star X-ray transient and eclipsing binary MXB 1659-29 in quiescence
• The Maveric Survey: a Red Straggler Binary with an Invisible Companion in the Galactic Globular Cluster M10
• XMM-Newton observations of two black hole X-ray transients in quiescence
• The cold neutron star in the soft X-ray transient 1H 1905+000
• Low-Mass X-ray Binaries
• The Quiescent X-ray Spectrum of Accreting Black Holes
• New Gamma Cas-like objects: X-ray and optical observations of SAO49725 and HD161103
• A deep radio survey of hard state and quiescent black hole X-ray binaries
• The Spectrum of the Black Hole X-ray Nova V404 Cygni in Quiescence as Measured by XMM-Newton
• An XMM-Newton Observation of 4U1755-33 in Quiescence: Evidence for a Fossil X-Ray Jet
• Characterizing X-ray and Radio emission in the Black Hole X-Ray Binary V404 Cygni during Quiescence
• A Chandra observation of the old open cluster M67
• The X-ray properties of the black hole transient MAXI J1659-152 in quiescence
• The faint neutron star soft X-ray transient SAX J1810.8-2609 in quiescence
• Understanding X-ray Irradiation in Low-Mass X-ray Binaries directly from their Light-Curves
• The neutron star soft X-ray transient 1H1905+000 in quiescence
• Evidence For Intrinsic Magnetic Moments in Black Hole Candidates
• Halpha Flares from V404 Cyg in Quiescence
• Chandra Detections of Two Quiescent Black Hole X-Ray Transients
• Swift J1357.2-0933: the faintest black hole?
• Zooming in on a sleeping giant: milliarcsecond HSA imaging of the black hole binary V404 Cyg in quiescence
• The observed mass distribution of Galactic black hole LMXBs is biased against massive black holes
• Radio and X-ray observations during the outburst decay of the Black Hole Candidate XTE J1908+094
• Very High Angular Resolution Science with the Square Kilometre Array
• Spectral and Temporal Behavior of the Black Hole Candidate XTE J1118+480 as Observed with BeppoSAX
• Multiwavelength observations of the black hole X-ray binary A0620-00 in quiescence
• The Chandra Small Magellanic Cloud Wing Survey - the search for X-ray Binaries
• A Delayed Transition to the Hard State for 4U 1630-47 at the End of Its 2010 Outburst
• The Rates of type I X-ray Bursts from Transients Observed with RXTE: Evidence for Black Hole Event Horizons
• The X-ray binary population in the Galactic Center revealed through multi-decade observations
• The Galactic Center as a laboratory for theories of gravity and dark matter
• An Anomalous Quiescent Stellar Mass Black Hole
• Evolution of the spin parameter of accreting compact objects with non-Kerr quadrupole moment
• Discovery of a bright X-ray transient in the Galactic Center with XMM-Newton
• Discovery of X-ray eclipses from the transient source CXOGC J174540.0-290031 with XMM-Newton
• Astrometric observations of X-ray binaries using very long baseline interferometry
• An anti-correlation between X-ray luminosity and H-alpha equivalent width in X-ray binaries
• Up and Down the Black Hole Radio/X-ray Correlation: the 2017 mini-outbursts from Swift J1753.5-0127
• X-ray binaries in Sculptor
• The discovery of X-ray binaries in the Sculptor Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy
• Identification of 5 Interacting Binaries in the Galactic Bulge Survey
• An X-ray-UV correlation in Cen X-4 during quiescence
• An accreting millisecond pulsar with black hole-like X-ray variability: IGR J00291+5934
• The Low Quiescent X-Ray Luminosity of the Transient X-Ray Burster EXO 1747-214
• Formation of Black Hole Low-Mass X-ray Binaries
• The Ultraviolet Spectral Energy Distributions of Quiescent Black Holes and Neutron Stars
• 'Disc-jet' coupling in black hole X-ray binaries and active galactic nuclei
• Localization of the X-ray Source in the Globular Cluster G1 with Chandra
• Swift J174540.7-290015: a new accreting binary in the Galactic Center
• A broadband look at the old and new ULXs of NGC 6946
• An XMM-Newton observation of the neutron star X-ray transient 2S 1803-245 in quiescence
• Polarized synchrotron emission in quiescent black hole X-ray transients
• Response to Comment on "A Non-Interacting Low-Mass Black Hole -- Giant Star Binary System"
• XMM-Newton detection of Nova Muscae 1991 in Quiescence
• Long-term optical/infrared variability in the quiescent X-ray transient V404 Cyg
• Testing General Relativity with High-Resolution Imaging of Sgr A*
• What is the closest black hole to the Sun?
• On the Final State of Spherical Gravitational Collapse
• Optical and J,K-photometry of black hole X-ray nova A0620-00 in passive and active stages of quiescence
• Chandra detection of XTE J1650-500 in quiescence and the minimum luminosity of black hole X-ray binaries
• Selection Effects on the Orbital Period Distribution of Low Mass Black Hole X-ray Binaries
• NuSTAR and Chandra observations of new X-ray transients in the central parsec of the Galaxy
• The X-ray quiescence of Swift J195509.6+261406 (GRB 070610): an optical bursting X-ray binary?
• XMM-Newton and INTEGRAL observations of the very faint X-ray transient IGRJ17285-2922/XTEJ1728-295 during the 2010 outburst
• Possibility of a White Dwarf as the Accreting Compact Star in CI Cam (= XTE J0421+560)
• Variability of Optical Counterparts in the Chandra Galactic Bulge Survey
• Uncovering the Nature of the X-ray Transient 4U 1730-22: Discovery of X-ray Emission from a Neutron Star in Quiescence with Chandra
• Two new bursting neutron star low-mass X-ray binaries: Swift J185003.2-005627 and Swift J1922.7-1716
• Holonomy invariance, orbital resonances, and kilohertz QPOs
• The enigmatic black-hole candidate and X-ray transient IGR J17091-3624 in its quiescent state as seen with XMM-Newton
• Investigating CXOU J163802.6-471358: a new pulsar wind nebula in the Norma region?
• GS 2000+25: The Least Luminous Black Hole X-ray Binary
• Quiescent X-Ray/Optical Counterparts of the Black Hole Transient H 1705-250
• MAXI and NuSTAR observations of the faint X-ray transient MAXI J1848-015 in the GLIMPSE-C01 Cluster
• Very low luminosities from the accretion-driven millisecond X-ray pulsar SAX J1808.4-3658 during quiescence
• Galactic Sources Detected in the NuSTAR Serendipitous Survey
• Radio emission and jets from microquasars
• On the recurrence times of neutron star X-ray binary transients and the nature of the Galactic Centre quiescent X-ray binaries
• Energy Spectra and Normalized Power Spectral Densities of X-Ray Nova GS 2000+25
• Quiescent NIR and optical counterparts to candidate black hole X-ray binaries
• An X-ray Transient and Optical Counterpart in the M31 Bulge
• Spherical accretion: the influence of inner boundary and quasi-periodic oscillations
• Unsupervised spectral decomposition of X-ray binaries with application to GX 339-4
• Nonthermal processes and neutrino emission from the black hole GRO J0422+32 in a bursting state
• SWIFT J1749.4-2807: A neutron or quark star?
• Robust Models for Phase Shifts in Accreting Binary Stars
• Eclipses of jets and discs of X-ray binaries as a powerful tool for understanding jet physics and binary parameters
• Outliers: multicolour photometry guiding the search for evolved binary systems in the globular cluster 47 Tucanae
• The advection-dominated accretion flow for the origin of the thermal soft X-ray component in low-level accreting neutron stars
• XMM-Newton observation of 4U 1543-475: the X-ray spectrum of a stellar-mass black-hole at low luminosity
• An updated gamma-ray analysis of the Be-BH binary HD~215227
• Atomic X-ray Spectroscopy of Accreting Black Holes
• ROSAT/Chandra Observations of a Bright Transient in M81
• Hot accretion flow around neutron stars
• Lithium production on a low-mass secondary in a black hole soft X-ray transient
• I-band photometry of the quiescent black hole X-ray nova GROJ0422+32=V518 Per: modelling of the orbital light curve and estimation of the black hole mass
• How To Distinguish Neutron Star and Black Hole X-ray Binaries? Spectral index and Quasi-Periodic Oscillation Frequency Correlation
• High-resolution radio observations of X-ray binaries
• Two-temperature radiative hot accretion flow around neutron stars
• The black hole X-ray binary MAXI J1348$-$630 in quiescence
• Constraints on horizonless objects after the EHT observation of Sagittarius A*