Validity of the Background Subtraction Method for Black Hole Thermodynamics in Matter-Coupled Gravity Theories

Abstract

The background subtraction method has long served as a practical tool for computing the Euclidean action and thermodynamic quantities of black holes. While its equivalence to the Iyer--Wald formalism is well understood in pure gravity theories, its validity in matter-coupled theories remains less clear and has even been questioned in the literature. In this work, we revisit this issue and demonstrate that the equivalence between the Euclidean action method and the Iyer--Wald formalism persists in matter-coupled scenarios. We apply the resulting formulation to two representative examples of such theories, and in both cases, the Euclidean approach performs smoothly. We further identify situations where the method may encounter subtleties due to the special properties of certain matter fields. Our results clarify when background subtraction remains reliable beyond pure gravity and when additional care is necessary.

9 pages, no figures, version accepted by PRD

References in corpus (24)

• Black Hole Entropy is Noether Charge
• Some Properties of Noether Charge and a Proposal for Dynamical Black Hole Entropy
• A Stress Tensor for Anti-de Sitter Gravity
• Holographic Renormalization
• The First Law of Thermodynamics for Kerr-Anti-de Sitter Black Holes
• A comparison of Noether charge and Euclidean methods for Computing the Entropy of Stationary Black Holes
• Coupling Constant Dependence in the Thermodynamics of N=4 Supersymmetric Yang-Mills Theory
• Thermodynamics of Asymptotically Locally AdS Spacetimes
• Lorentz violation with an antisymmetric tensor
• Covariant phase space with boundaries
• Black Hole Entropy and Viscosity Bound in Horndeski Gravity
• On Euclidean and Noetherian Entropies in AdS Space
• Surface term, corner term, and action growth in F(Riemann) gravity theory
• A Novel Derivation of the Boundary Term for the Action in Lanczos-Lovelock Gravity
• On Thermodynamics of AdS Black Holes with Scalar Hair
• Notes on thermodynamics of Schwarzschild-like bumblebee black hole
• Holography of Charged Black Holes with $R{F}^2$ Corrections
• Higher-Derivative Gravity with Non-minimally Coupled Maxwell Field
• Exact black hole solutions in gravity with a background Kalb-Ramond field
• Background subtraction method is not only much simpler, but also as applicable as covariant counterterm method
• Higher derivative corrections to Kerr-AdS black hole thermodynamics
• First order corrections to black hole thermodynamics: a simple approach enhanced
• Quadratic curvature corrections to 5-dimensional Kerr-AdS black hole thermodynamics by background subtraction method
• Equivalence of Noether charge and Hilbert action boundary term formulas for the black hole entropy in $F(R_{abcd})$ gravity theory