Absorbing detectors meet scattering theory

Abstract

Any proposed solution to the "screen problem" in quantum mechanics -- the challenge of predicting the joint distribution of particle arrival times and impact positions -- must align with the extensive data obtained from scattering experiments. In this paper, we conduct a direct consistency check of the Absorbing Boundary Condition (ABC) proposal, a prominent approach to address the screen problem, against the predictions derived from scattering theory (ST). Through a series of exactly solvable one- and two-dimensional examples, we demonstrate that the ABC proposal's predictions are in tension with the well-established results of ST. Specifically, it predicts sharp momentum- and screen-orientation-dependent detection probabilities, along with secondary reflections that contradict existing experimental data. We conclude that while it remains possible that physical detectors described by the ABC proposal could be found in the future, the proposal is empirically inadequate as a general solution to the screen problem, as it is inconsistent with the behavior of detectors in standard experimental settings.

11 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (13)

• A measurement-based approach to quantum arrival times
• Quantum Dynamics under continuous projective measurements: non-Hermitian description and the continuous space limit
• Distribution of the Time at Which an Ideal Detector Clicks
• Path Integral Analysis of Arrival Times with a Complex Potential
• The Dirichlet-to-Robin Transform
• Detection Time Distribution for Several Quantum Particles
• Exact Energy-Time Uncertainty Relation for Arrival Time by Absorption
• Can the double-slit experiment distinguish between quantum interpretations?
• Time-delay of classical and quantum scattering processes: a conceptual overview and a general definition
• Absorbing Boundary Condition as Limiting Case of Imaginary Potentials
• Existence of Schrodinger Evolution with Absorbing Boundary Condition
• On a Derivation of the Absorbing Boundary Rule
• Detecting screens modeled by Schrödinger operators that generate $C_0$ contraction semigroups

Cited by in corpus (1)

• Detection Time Distribution Predicted Using Absorbing Boundary Conditions and Imaginary Potentials