Can quantum gravity be both consistent and complete?
arXiv:2505.11773 · doi:10.1142/S0218271825440171
Abstract
General relativity, despite its profound successes, fails as a complete theory due to presence of singularities. While it is widely believed that quantum gravity has the potential to be a complete theory, in which spacetime consistently emerges from quantum degrees of freedom through computational algorithms, we argue that this goal could be fundamentally unattainable. We examine how this limitation could emerge in various contexts, depending on whether or not every mathematically valid result is physically realized. In the first case, Godel's incompleteness theorems, along with related results by Tarski and Chaitin, imply that no theory formulated as a formal axiomatic system can be complete, and that within any computational framework, a fully consistent internal truth predicate is impossible. In the second case, if only a subset of mathematical truths is realized in nature, we argue that this selection cannot be determined by any purely computational process. Hence, a meta-theoretical approach based on non-algorithmic understanding is indispensable in every case. We discuss some possible consequences of this observation for describing physical systems and note that a non-algorithmic approach should be essential for any theory of everything.
This paper received an Honorable Mention in the 2025 Gravity Research Foundation Essay Competition
References in corpus (44)
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
- The Ekpyrotic Universe: Colliding Branes and the Origin of the Hot Big Bang
- Quantum Nature of the Big Bang: Improved dynamics
- The fuzzball proposal for black holes: an elementary review
- Absence of Singularity in Loop Quantum Cosmology
- The entropy of Hawking radiation
- The Spin Foam Approach to Quantum Gravity
- Generalized metric formulation of double field theory
- A Geometry for Non-Geometric String Backgrounds
- Spectral Dimension of the Universe
- Fixed points of quantum gravity
- Holographic duality from random tensor networks
- The Mathematical Universe
- Horizon formation and far-from-equilibrium isotropization in supersymmetric Yang-Mills plasma
- Undecidability of the Spectral Gap (short version)
- Coarse graining methods for spin net and spin foam models
- Matrix product operators and states: NP-hardness and undecidability
- Experimental Evidence of Quantum Randomness Incomputability
- Tunneling into fuzzball states
- Analogue simulations of quantum gravity with fluids
- Quantum measurement occurrence is undecidable
- Undecidability of the fate of relaxation in one-dimensional quantum systems
- Undecidability in quantum thermalization
- Physics Without Physics: The Power of Information-theoretical Principles
- Emergence of Spacetime in a restricted Spin-foam model
- Ising Spin Network States for Loop Quantum Gravity: a Toy Model for Phase Transitions
- Logical independence and quantum randomness
- From Heisenberg to Goedel via Chaitin
- Uncomputability of Phase Diagrams
- Measurement-based quantum computation and undecidable logic
- Undecidable problems in quantum field theory
- Quantum logic is undecidable
- Third quantization of -type gravity
- Third quantization of -type gravity II - General case -
- Consequences of Godel Theorems on Third Quantized Theories Like String Field Theory and Group Field Theory
- Uncomputably Complex Renormalisation Group Flows
- Implications of Tarski's Undefinability Theorem on the Theory of Everything
- Wheeler's It from Bit Proposal in Loop Quantum Gravity
- Comparing Quantum Gravity Models: String Theory, Loop Quantum Gravity, and Entanglement gravity versus -QGR
- Information Theoretical Approach to Detecting Quantum Gravitational Corrections
- Uncertainty Principle in Loop Quantum Cosmology by Moyal Formalism
- The end of spacetime
- Spontaneous collapse models lead to the emergence of classicality of the Universe
- Incompleteness Theorems for Observables in General Relativity