Matter really does matter, or Why $f(R,\mathrm{Matter})$ type theories are significant for gravitational physics and cosmology

Abstract

In a recent paper (Lacombe, Mukohyama, and Seitz, JCAP {\bf 2024}, 05, 064 (2024)), the authors provided an in-depth analysis of a class of modified gravity theories, generally called $f(R,\mathrm{Matter})$ theories, which assume the existence of a non-minimal coupling between geometry and matter. It was argued that if the matter sector consists of Standard Model particles, then these theories suffer from the presence of ghosts, or are just scalar/vector-tensor theories. Hence, the relevance of these theories for cosmology was questioned. It is the goal of the present work to carefully analyze, discuss, and assess the line of arguments proposed in Lacombe et al. JCAP {\bf 2024}, 05, 064 (2024). After a qualitative critical discussion of the five general arguments proposed for the validity of a gravitational theory, we present the theoretical foundations of the $f(R,\mathrm{Matter})$ theories, including their possible relations with quantum gravity, and discuss in detail the role of matter. The matter source discussed in Lacombe et al., consisting predominantly of a massless scalar field, is extremely restrictive, and rather irrelevant for cosmology and the description of the observational data. We also devote a detailed discussion of the problem of the energy scales of the $f(R,\mathrm{Matter})$ theories. To test the observational relevance of this type of theories we present the comparison of a simple theoretical model with a small set of observational data and with the $\Lambda$CDM paradigm. We conclude by pointing out that the analysis of Lacombe et al., JCAP {\bf 2024}, 05, 064 (2024), even very useful for the understanding of some limited aspects of the $f(R,\mathrm{Matter})$ theories, and of their theoretical foundations, cannot be considered as a valid or definite criticism of these approaches to gravity.

20 pages, 3 figures

References in corpus (15)

• f(R,T) gravity
• Extra force in $f(R)$ modified theories of gravity
• f(R,L_m) gravity
• Hubble parameter measurement constraints on the redshift of the deceleration-acceleration transition, dynamical dark energy, and space curvature
• On the consistency of universally non-minimally coupled $f(R,T,R_{\mu \nu }{T}^{\mu \nu })$ theories
• New derivation of the Lagrangian of a perfect fluid with a barotropic equation of state
• Curvature scalar instability in f(R) gravity
• Modified gravity from the nonperturbative quantization of a metric
• Fermi gas and modified gravity
• Higher mass limits of neutron stars from the equation of states in curved spacetime
• The first variation of the matter energy-momentum tensor with respect to the metric, and its implications on modified gravity theories
• Warm Inflation in $f(R,T)$ gravity
• Unbiased interpolated neutron-star EoS at finite T for modified gravity studies
• Are $f(R,\mathrm{Matter})$ theories really relevant to cosmology?
• Equation of states in the curved spacetime of slowly rotating degenerate stars

Cited by in corpus (5)

• Modified Gravity with Nonminimal Curvature-Matter Couplings: A Framework for Gravitationally Induced Particle Creation
• Gravitational baryogenesis beyond the spectator approximation
• Density perturbations in nonminimally coupled gravity: symptoms of Lagrangian density ambiguity
• Lagrangian Identity and Mass Evolution of Particle-like Objects in Nonminimally Coupled Gravity
• Wormhole Solutions and Pre-inflationary Epoch in $F(R,T)$ Gravity with Axion Fields