Why engineers are right to avoid the quantum reality offered by the orthodox theory?

Abstract

A proper knowledge of the reality of a physical theory is important to get an understanding of empirical phenomena. Despite its extraordinary predictive successes, the orthodox (also known as the Copenhagen) theory provides an indigestible definition of quantum reality: objects (such as electrons) become part of a nebulous many-particle wave function with no properties at all, unless the property is explicitly measured. To make matters worse, orthodox theory does not define measurements in a clear way. This view of reality is foreign to most modern engineers who assume that quantum objects, like classical objects, always have real properties, independent of any measurement. Despite being contrary to the orthodox theory, the intuition of engineers is not in conflict with other quantum theories, where the observer plays no fundamental role. Good quantum intuition needs to be based on a correct knowledge of the fundamental elements of the quantum theory that is being used. We argue that engineers are actually led to the natural quantum reality offered by these alternative approaches.

arXiv comment6 pages and 2 figures

References in corpus (5)

• Weak Values from Displacement Currents in Multiterminal Electron Devices
• Dynamics of Current, Charge and Mass
• Natural classical limit for the center of mass of many-particle quantum systems
• Quantum time-dependent Monte Carlo simulation of electron devices with 2D linear-band materials: a genuine TeraHertz signature for graphene
• Noise and charge discreteness as ultimate limit for the THz operation of ultra-small electronic devices

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Resonant tunneling diodes in semiconductor microcavities: modeling polaritonic features in the THz displacement current
• Can Wigner distribution functions with collisions satisfy complete positivity and energy conservation?
• Harmonizing de Broglie-Bohm's Causal Interpretation with the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics
• Bohmian Mechanics as a Practical Tool