Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae -- III. The statistical analysis of physico-chemical parameters and excitation mechanisms

Abstract

Nearly 30 years after the first detailed studies of low-ionization structures (LISs) in planetary nebulae (PNe), we perform a statistical analysis of their physical, chemical and excitation properties, by collecting published data in the literature. The analysis was made through the contrast between LISs and high-ionization structures -- rims or shells -- for a large sample of PNe, in order to highlight significant differences between these structures. Our motivation was to find robust results based on the largest sample of LISs gathered so far. (i) Indeed, LISs have lower electron densities (N${}_e$[S~II]) than the rims/shells. (ii) The nitrogen electron temperatures (T${}_e$[N~II]) are similar between the two groups, while a bimodal distribution is observed for the T${}_e$ based on [O~III] of the rims/shells, although the high- and low-ionization structures have T${}_e$[O~III] of similar median values. (iii) No significant variations are observed in total abundances of He, N, O, Ne, Ar, Cl and S between the two groups. (iv) Through the analysis of several diagnostic diagrams, LISs are separated from rims/shells in terms of excitation. From two large grids of photoionization and shock models, we show that there is an important overlap between both mechanisms, particularly when low-ionization line-ratios are concerned. We found a good tracer of high-velocity shocks, as well as an indicator of high- and low-velocity shocks that depends on temperature-sensitive line ratios. In conclusion, both excitation mechanisms could be present, however shocks cannot be the main source of excitation for most of the LISs of PNe.

arXiv comment17 pages, 10 figures

References in corpus (42)

• The MAPPINGS III Library of Fast Radiative Shock Models
• A grid of synthetic ionizing spectra for very hot compact stars from NLTE model atmospheres
• Planetary Nebulae: Observational Properties, Mimics, and Diagnostics
• Effects of Pre-ionisation in Radiative Shocks I: Self-Consistent Models
• Ionization Correction Factors for Planetary Nebulae: I- Using optical spectra
• Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae: confronting models with observations
• The Necklace: equatorial and polar outflows from the binary central star of the new planetary nebula IPHASXJ194359.5+170901
• Knots in the Helix Nebula found in H2
• New Galactic supernova remnants discovered with IPHAS
• ETHOS 1: A high latitude planetary nebula with jets forged by a post common envelope binary central star
• Extensive Online Shock Model Database
• IRAC Observations of Planetary Nebulae
• A diagnostic tool for the identification of Supernova Remnants
• Analysis of chemical abundances in planetary nebulae with [WC] central stars. II. Chemical abundances and the abundance discrepancy factor
• H2 formation on PAHs in photodissociation regions: a high-temperature pathway to molecular hydrogen
• A multi-wavelength study of Supernova Remnants in six nearby galaxies. II. New optically selected Supernova Remnants
• Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae - I: physical, kinematic and excitation properties
• Multiple and Precessing Collimated Outflows in the Planetary Nebula IC 4634
• Near Infrared Spectra of Compact Planetary Nebulae
• The physical parameters, excitation and chemistry of the rim, jets and knots of the planetary nebula NGC 7009
• H${}_2$ in low-ionization structures of planetary nebulae
• Models of the Mass-Ejection Histories of pre Planetary Nebulae, IV. Magnetized Winds and the Origins of Jets, Bullets, and FLIERs
• FLIERs as stagnation knots from post-AGB winds with polar momentum deficiency
• Extended Structures of Planetary Nebulae Detected in H${}_2$ Emission
• Low-ionization pairs of knots in planetary nebulae: physical properties and excitation
• K 4-47: a planetary nebula excited by photons and shocks
• Hu1-2: a metal-poor bipolar planetary nebula with fast collimated outflows
• Space Velocity and Time Span of Jets in Planetary Nebulae
• The MUSE view of the planetary nebula NGC 3132
• Unveiling the structure of the planetary nebula M 2-48: Kinematics and physical conditions
• Exploring the differences of integrated and spatially resolved analysis using integral field unit data: The case of Abell 14
• Spatially resolved physical and chemical properties of the planetary nebula NGC 3242
• H${}_2$ emission in the low-ionisation structures of the Planetary Nebulae NGC 7009 and NGC 6543
• Spitzer mid-infrared spectroscopic observations of planetary nebulae
• IFU spectroscopy of Southern Planetary Nebulae V: Low-ionization structures
• Fast, low-ionization emission regions of the planetary nebula M2-42
• KCWI observations of the extended nebulae in Mrk 273
• Spectroscopic Analysis Tool for intEgraL fieLd unIt daTacubEs (satellite): Case studies of NGC 7009 and NGC 6778 with MUSE
• A multispectral analysis of the northeastern shell of IC 443
• Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae -- II. Densities, temperatures, abundances and excitation of 6 PNe
• Observational Study of the Multistructured Planetary Nebula NGC 7354
• The population of planetary nebulae near the Galactic centre: chemical abundances

Cited by in corpus (6)

• Detection of the [C I] $\lambda$8727 emission line. Low-ionization structures in NGC 7009
• Dissecting the Planetary Nebula NGC 4361 with MUSE
• ASKAP-EMU radio continuum detection of planetary nebula NGC 5189: the "Infinity" nebula
• Is the nitrogen-rich source PN K4-47 a true planetary nebula?
• Low-ionization structures in planetary nebulae -- IV. The molecular hydrogen counterpart
• [Fe II] 1.644$\mu$m imaging survey of planetary nebulae with low-ionisation structures