Assessing the theory-data tension in neutrino-induced charged pion production: the effect of final-state nucleon distortion

Abstract

Pion production on nuclei constitutes a significant part of the total cross section in experiments involving few-GeV neutrinos. Combined analyses of data on deuterium and heavier nuclei points to tensions between the bubble chamber data and the data of the MINER$\nu$A experiment, which are often ascribed to unspecified nuclear effects. To understand the origin of these tensions, a microscopic quantum mechanical framework is needed to compute nuclear matrix elements. We use the local approximation to the relativistic distorted wave impulse approximation (RDWIA) to assess the role of final-state nucleon distortion. To perform this comparison under conditions relevant to neutrino experiments, we compute cross sections for the MINER$\nu$A and T2K charged pion production datasets. The inclusion of nucleon distortion leads to a reduction of the cross section up to 10\%, but to no significant change in shape of the flux-averaged cross sections. Results with and without distortion compare favorably to experimental data, with the exception of the low-$Q^2$ MINER$\nu$A ${\pi }^{+}$ data. We point out that hydrogen target data from BEBC is also overpredicted at low-$Q^2$, and that the discrepancy is similar in shape and magnitude to what is found in comparison to MINER$\nu$A data. Including nucleon distortion alone cannot explain the overprediction of low-$Q^2$ cross sections measured by MINER$\nu$A. The similar overprediction of BEBC data on hydrogen means that it is impossible to ascribe this discrepancy solely to a nuclear effect. Axial couplings and their $Q^2$ dependence should ideally be derived from more precise data on hydrogen and deuterium.

References in corpus (15)

• Unitary Isobar Model - MAID2007
• Weak Pion Production off the Nucleon
• Electron- and neutrino-nucleus scattering from the quasielastic to the resonance region
• A study of the $P_{11}(1440)$ and $D_{13}(1520)$ resonances from CLAS data on $ep\to e^{\prime }{\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{-}{p}^{\prime }$
• Resonance production by neutrinos: The second resonance region
• Reanalysis of bubble chamber measurements of muon-neutrino induced single pion production
• N-Delta(1232) axial form factors from weak pion production
• Pion production within the hybrid relativistic plane wave impulse approximation model at MiniBooNE and MINERvA kinematics
• Adjusting Neutrino Interaction Models and Evaluating Uncertainties using NOvA Near Detector Data
• Neutrino energy reconstruction from semi-inclusive samples
• Final state interactions in semi-inclusive neutrino-nucleus scattering: Application to T2K and MINER$\nu$A experiments
• Assessing the accuracy of the GENIE event generator with electron-scattering data
• Neutrino induced threshold production of two pions and N^*(1440) electroweak form factors
• Implementation of the CRPA model in the GENIE event generator and analysis of nuclear effects in low-energy transfer neutrino-nucleus interactions
• Single pion production in electron-proton interactions