Surfaces away from horizons are not thermodynamic

Abstract

Since the 1970's it has been known that black hole (and other) horizons are truly thermodynamic in nature. More generally, surfaces which are not horizons have also been conjectured to behave thermodynamically. Initially, for surfaces microscopically expanded from a horizon to so-called stretched horizons, and more recently, for more general ordinary surfaces in the emergent gravity program. To test these conjectures we ask whether such surfaces satisfy an analogue to the first law of thermodynamics (as do horizons). For static asymptotically-flat spacetimes we find that such a first law holds on horizons. We rigorously prove that this law remains an excellent approximation for stretched horizons, but perhaps counter-intuitively this result illustrates the insufficiency of the laws of black hole mechanics alone from implying truly thermodynamic behavior. For surfaces away from horizons in the emergent gravity program the first law fails (with the exception of fully spherically symmetric scenarios) thus undermining the key thermodynamic assumption of this program.

arXiv comment12 pages, 2 figures, Published in Nature Communications

References in corpus (3)

• Thermodynamics of Spacetime: The Einstein Equation of State
• On the Origin of Gravity and the Laws of Newton
• First law of thermodynamics on holographic screens in entropic force frame

Cited by in corpus (12)

• From galactic bars to the Hubble tension: weighing up the astrophysical evidence for Milgromian gravity
• Holographic dark energy from the laws of thermodynamics with Rényi entropy
• Analysis of a regular black hole in Verlinde's gravity
• How Barrow Entropy Modifies Gravity: With Comments on Tsallis Entropy
• Three little paradoxes: making sense of semiclassical gravity
• A simple link of information entropy of quantum and classical systems with Newtonian $r^{-2}$ dependence of Verlinde's entropic force
• Generalized Entropy Implies Varying-G: Horizon Area Dependent Field Equations and Black Hole-Cosmology Coupling
• On the breakdown of space-time in general relativity
• The Hawking temperature of dynamical black holes via conformal transformations
• Surface gravity from tidal acceleration
• Thermodynamics of the most generalized form of Holographic Dark Energy and some particular cases with Corrected Entropies
• Classical spacetime as a gravitational condensate: USMEG-EFT emergence in comparison to Verlinde's entropic gravity