Non-equivalence of quasilinear dynamical systems and their statistical closures

Abstract

It is widely believed that statistical closure theories for dynamical systems provide statistics equivalent to those of the governing dynamical equations from which the former are derived. Here, we demonstrate counterexamples in the context of the widely used mean-field quasilinear (QL) approximation applied to 2D fluid dynamical systems. We compare statistics of QL numerical simulations with those obtained by direct statistical simulation via a cumulant expansion closed at second order (CE2). We observe that, though CE2 is an exact statistical closure for QL dynamics, its predictions disagree with the statistics of the QL solution for identical parameter values. These disagreements are attributed to instabilities, which we term rank instabilities, of the second cumulant dynamics within CE2 that are unavailable in the QL equations.

arXiv comment12 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (14)

• Direct Statistical Simulation of Out-of-Equilibrium Jets
• A Multiscale Dynamo Model Driven by Quasi-geostrophic Convection
• Statistics of an Unstable Barotropic Jet from a Cumulant Expansion
• Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics via Direct Statistical Simulation
• A statistical state dynamics-based study of the structure and mechanism of large-scale motions in plane Poiseuille flow
• Recent Developments in Theories of Inhomogeneous and Anisotropic Turbulence
• Statistical state dynamics of jet/wave coexistence in barotropic beta-plane turbulence
• Statistics of the General Circulation from Cumulant Expansions
• Statistics of the stochastically-forced Lorenz attractor by the Fokker-Planck equation and cumulant expansions
• Dimensional Reduction of Direct Statistical Simulation
• Direct Statistical Simulation of Jets and Vortices in 2D Flows
• Joint Instability and Abrupt Nonlinear Transitions in a Differentially Rotating Plasma
• Marginally-Stable Thermal Equilibria of Rayleigh-Bénard Convection
• Improved assessment of the statistical stability of turbulent flows using extended Orr-Sommerfeld stability analysis