Constraining Global Coronal Models with Multiple Independent Observables

Abstract

Global coronal models seek to produce an accurate physical representation of the Sun's atmosphere which can be used, for example, to drive space weather models. Assessing their accuracy is a complex task and there are multiple observational pathways to provide constraints and tune model parameters. Here, we combine several such independent constraints, defining a model-agnostic framework for standardized comparison. We require models to predict the distribution of coronal holes at the photosphere, and neutral line topology at the model outer boundary. We compare these predictions to extreme ultraviolet (EUV) observations of coronal hole locations, white-light Carrington maps of the streamer belt and the magnetic sector structure measured \textit{in situ} by Parker Solar Probe and 1AU spacecraft. We study these metrics for Potential Field Source Surface (PFSS) models as a function of source surface height and magnetogram choice, as well as comparing to the more physical Wang-Sheeley-Arge (WSA) and the Magnetohydrodynamics Algorithm outside a Sphere (MAS) models. We find that simultaneous optimization of PFSS models to all three metrics is not currently possible, implying a trade-off between the quality of representation of coronal holes and streamer belt topology. WSA and MAS results show the additional physics they include addresses this by flattening the streamer belt while maintaining coronal hole sizes, with MAS also improving coronal hole representation relative to WSA. We conclude that this framework is highly useful for inter- and intra-model comparisons. Integral to the framework is the standardization of observables required of each model, evaluating different model aspects.

Accepted to ApJ 4/9/2022

References in corpus (19)

• PLUTO: a Numerical Code for Computational Astrophysics
• Advancements in the ADAPT Photospheric Flux Transport Model
• Magnetic connectivity of the ecliptic plane within 0.5 AU : PFSS modeling of the first PSP encounter
• Automated Coronal Hole Detection using Local Intensity Thresholding Techniques
• The Temperature and Density Structure of the Solar Corona. I. Observations of the Quiet Sun with the EUV Imaging Spectrometer (EIS) on Hinode
• Relating streamer flows to density and magnetic structures at the Parker Solar Probe
• Statistics and Polarization of Type III Radio Bursts Observed in the Inner Heliosphere
• Predicting the Structure of the Solar Corona and Inner Heliosphere during Parker Solar Probe's First Perihelion Pass
• Coronal Magnetic Field Topology From Total Solar Eclipse Observations
• Global solar magnetic field organization in the outer corona: influence on the solar wind speed and mass flux over the cycle
• Magnetograph Saturation and the Open Flux Problem
• Using Parker Solar Probe observations during the first four perihelia to constrain global magnetohydrodynamic models
• Variations in Finite Difference Potential Fields
• The active region source of a type III radio storm observed by Parker Solar Probe during Encounter 2
• Validation scheme for solar coronal models -- constraints from multi-perspective observations in EUV and white-light
• Global Coronal Equilibria with Solar Wind Outflow
• Periodicities in an active region correlated with Type III radio bursts observed by Parker Solar Probe
• An elliptic expansion of the potential field source surface model
• Comparing extrapolations of the coronal magnetic field structure at 2.5 solar radii with multi-viewpoint coronagraphic observations

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Defining the Middle Corona
• Prediction and Verification of Parker Solar Probe Solar Wind Sources at 13.3 R${}_{\odot }$
• COCONUT, a novel fast-converging MHD model for solar corona simulations: II. Assessing the impact of the input magnetic map on space-weather forecasting at minimum of activity
• Observational Evidence of S-Web Source of the Slow Solar Wind
• Variability of the slow solar wind: New insights from modelling and PSP-WISPR observations
• Compositional metrics of fast and slow Alfvenic solar wind emerging from coronal holes and their boundaries
• Implications of Different Solar Photospheric Flux-Transport Models for Global Coronal and Heliospheric Modeling
• The multi-spacecraft high-energy solar particle event of 28 October 2021
• Tracing magnetic switchbacks to their source: An assessment of solar coronal jets as switchback precursors
• Nested active regions anchor the heliospheric current sheet and stall the reversal of the coronal magnetic field
• Magnetic connectivity from the Sun to the Earth with MHD models I. Impact of the magnetic modelling for connectivity validation
• What Determines the Brightness of the Magnetically Open Solar Corona?: Insights from Three-dimensional Radiative Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations and Observations