Classical pendulum clocks break the thermodynamic uncertainty relation

Abstract

The thermodynamic uncertainty relation expresses a seemingly universal trade-off between the cost for driving an autonomous system and precision in any output observable. It has so far been proven for discrete systems and for overdamped Brownian motion. Its validity for the more general class of underdamped Brownian motion, where inertia is relevant, was conjectured based on numerical evidence. We now disprove this conjecture by constructing a counterexample. Its design is inspired by a classical pendulum clock, which uses an escapement to couple the motion of an oscillator to another degree of freedom (a "hand") driven by an external force. Considering a thermodynamically consistent, discrete model for an escapement mechanism, we first show that the oscillations of an underdamped harmonic oscillator in thermal equilibrium are sufficient to break the thermodynamic uncertainty relation. We then show that this is also the case in simulations of a fully continuous underdamped system with a potential landscape that mimics an escaped pendulum.

6 pages, 3 figures + supplementary information

References in corpus (7)

• Thermodynamic uncertainty relation for biomolecular processes
• Proof of the Finite-Time Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation for Steady-State Currents
• Discrete-time thermodynamic uncertainty relation
• Cost and Precision of Brownian Clocks
• Effect of a magnetic field on the thermodynamic uncertainty relation
• Universal form of thermodynamic uncertainty relation for Langevin dynamics
• Finite-time thermodynamic uncertainty relation do not hold for discrete-time Markov process

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Unified thermodynamic-kinetic uncertainty relation
• Unifying speed limit, thermodynamic uncertainty relation and Heisenberg principle via bulk-boundary correspondence
• Direct Route to Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relations and Their Saturation
• Thermodynamic cost for precision of general counting observables
• On the stochastic thermodynamics of fractional Brownian motion
• Fundamental bounds on precision and response for quantum trajectory observables
• The Impact of Imperfect Timekeeping on Quantum Control
• Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation in Interacting Many-Body Systems
• Universal bounds on the performance of information-thermodynamic engine
• Optimal time estimation and the clock uncertainty relation for stochastic processes
• Coherence of oscillations in the weak-noise limit
• Thermodynamic correlation inequality
• Thermodynamic bounds on generalized transport: From single-molecule to bulk observables
• Beat of a current
• Conceptual and practical approaches for investigating irreversible processes
• Characterization and optimization of heat engines: Pareto-optimal fronts and universal features
• Entropy bound for time reversal markers
• Heat production in a stochastic system with nonlinear time-delayed feedback
• Bounds on skewness and kurtosis of steady state currents
• Powering an autonomous clock with quantum electromechanics
• Noise and Thermodynamic Uncertainty Relation in "Underwater" Molecular Junctions
• Inverse thermodynamic uncertainty relation and entropy production
• Inertia Tames Fluctuations in Autonomous Stationary Heat Engines
• The superconducting clock-circuit: Improving the coherence of Josephson radiation beyond the thermodynamic uncertainty relation
• Entropic costs of extracting classical ticks from a quantum clock
• A Quantum Mechanical Pendulum Clock