Nucleon-nucleon potentials from Delta-full chiral effective-field-theory and implications

Abstract

We closely investigate NN potentials based upon the Delta-full version of chiral effective field theory. We find that recently constructed NN potentials of this kind, which (when applied together with three-nucleon forces) were presented as predicting accurate binding energies and radii for a range of nuclei from A=16 to A=132 and providing accurate equations of state for nuclear matter, yield a chi^2/datum of 60 for the reproduction of the pp data below 100 MeV laboratory energy. This chi^2 is more than three times what the Hamada-Johnston potential of the year of 1962 achieved already some 60 years ago. We perceive this historical fact as concerning in view of the current emphasis on precision. We are able to trace the very large chi^2 as well as the apparent success of the potentials in nuclear structure to unrealistic predictions for P-wave states, in which the Delta-full NNLO potentials are off by up to 40 times the NNLO truncation errors. In fact, we show that, the worse the description of the P-wave states, the better the predictions in nuclear structure. Thus, these potentials cannot be seen as the solution to the outstanding problems in current miscroscopic nuclear structure physics.

arXiv comment18 pages, 4 figures, 7 tables. Abstract language tamed upon recommendation by referee; all results and all conclusions unchanged

References in corpus (40)

• Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces
• The high-precision, charge-dependent Bonn nucleon-nucleon potential (CD-Bonn)
• Chiral effective field theory and nuclear forces
• Accurate Charge-Dependent Nucleon-Nucleon Potential at Fourth Order of Chiral Perturbation Theory
• Improved nuclear matter calculations from chiral low-momentum interactions
• The Two-Nucleon Potential from Chiral Lagrangians
• Nuclear effective field theory: status and perspectives
• The In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group: A Novel Ab Initio Method for Nuclei
• Improved chiral nucleon-nucleon potential up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order
• Peripheral Nucleon-Nucleon Phase Shifts and Chiral Symmetry
• High-quality two-nucleon potentials up to fifth order of the chiral expansion
• Chiral interactions up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order and nuclear saturation
• Semilocal momentum-space regularized chiral two-nucleon potentials up to fifth order
• Quantifying truncation errors in effective field theory
• Similarity-Transformed Chiral NN+3N Interactions for the Ab Initio Description of 12-C and 16-O
• Peripheral NN-Scattering: Role of Delta-Excitation, Correlated Two-Pion and Vector Meson Exchange
• Structure of the lightest tin isotopes
• Is nuclear matter perturbative with low-momentum interactions?
• Saturation with chiral interactions and consequences for finite nuclei
• Ab Initio Path to Heavy Nuclei
• Novel chiral Hamiltonian and observables in light and medium-mass nuclei
• Accurate bulk properties of nuclei from $A=2$ to $\infty$ from potentials with $\Delta$ isobars
• Light-nuclei spectra from chiral dynamics
• Improving the convergence of the chiral expansion for nuclear forces I: Peripheral phases
• Nuclear forces with Delta-excitations up to next-to-next-to-leading order I: peripheral nucleon-nucleon waves
• Three-Nucleon Forces: Implementation and Applications to Atomic Nuclei and Dense Matter
• Coarse grained Potential analysis of neutron-proton and proton-proton scattering below pion production threshold
• Reconciling threshold and subthreshold expansions for pion-nucleon scattering
• Family of Chiral Two- plus Three-Nucleon Interactions for Accurate Nuclear Structure Studies
• Delta isobars and nuclear saturation
• Auxiliary field diffusion Monte Carlo calculations of light and medium-mass nuclei with local chiral interactions
• Essential elements for nuclear binding
• Pion-nucleon scattering in an effective chiral field theory with explicit spin-3/2 fields
• Chiral EFT based nuclear forces: Achievements and challenges
• Variational calculation of the ground state of closed-shell nuclei up to $A=40$
• Comparison of potential models with the pp scattering data below 350 MeV
• Probing chiral interactions up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order in medium-mass nuclei
• Historical perspective and future prospects for nuclear interactions
• Exploring the relationship between nuclear matter and finite nuclei with chiral two- and three-nucleon forces
• Elastic pion-nucleon scattering in chiral perturbation theory: Explicit $\Delta$(1232) degrees of freedom

Cited by in corpus (10)

• What is ab initio in nuclear theory?
• Wavefunction matching for solving quantum many-body problems
• Nuclear Forces for Precision Nuclear Physics -- a collection of perspectives
• Benchmark calculations of infinite neutron matter with realistic two- and three-nucleon potentials
• Local position-space two-nucleon potentials from leading to fourth order of chiral effective field theory
• What is ab initio?
• Sign-Problem-Free Nuclear Quantum Monte Carlo Simulation
• The nuclear symmetry energy from relativistic Brueckner-Hartree-Fock model
• Revisiting proton-proton fusion in chiral effective field theory
• Enhancement of deltaful two-pion exchange nuclear forces