A comparison of Galactic electron density models using PyGEDM

Abstract

Galactic electron density distribution models are crucial tools for estimating the impact of the ionised interstellar medium on the impulsive signals from radio pulsars and fast radio bursts. The two prevailing Galactic electron density models are YMW16 (Yao et al., 2017) and NE2001 (Cordes & Lazio, 2002). Here, we introduce a software package PyGEDM which provides a unified application programming interface (API) for these models and the YT20 (Yamasaki & Totani, 2020) model of the Galactic halo. We use PyGEDM to compute all-sky maps of Galactic dispersion measure (DM) for YMW16 and NE2001, and compare the large-scale differences between the two. In general, YMW16 predicts higher DM values toward the Galactic anticentre. YMW16 predicts higher DMs at low Galactic latitudes, but NE2001 predicts higher DMs in most other directions. We identify lines of sight for which the models are most discrepant, using pulsars with independent distance measurements. YMW16 performs better on average than NE2001, but both models show significant outliers. We suggest that future campaigns to determine pulsar distances should focus on targets where the models show large discrepancies, so future models can use those measurements to better estimate distances along those line of sight. We also suggest that the Galactic halo should be considered as a component in future GEDMs, to avoid overestimating the Galactic DM contribution for extragalactic sources such as FRBs.

13 pages, 7 figures. Accepted to PASA

References in corpus (32)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• The NumPy array: a structure for efficient numerical computation
• A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
• The ATNF Pulsar Catalogue
• HI4PI: A full-sky HI survey based on EBHIS and GASS
• A New Electron Density Model for Estimation of Pulsar and FRB Distances
• A census of baryons in the Universe from localized fast radio bursts
• The Parkes multibeam pulsar survey: VI. Discovery and timing of 142 pulsars and a Galactic population analysis
• CHIME/FRB Detection of Eight New Repeating Fast Radio Burst Sources
• On the mass-to-light ratio of the local Galactic disc and the optical luminosity of the Galaxy
• The Vertical Structure of Warm Ionised Gas in the Milky Way
• The Large-scale Bipolar Wind in the Galactic Center
• The observed spiral structure of the Milky Way
• On Pulsar Distance Measurements and their Uncertainties
• Precision Astrometry with the Very Long Baseline Array: Parallaxes and Proper Motions for 14 Pulsars
• Microarcsecond VLBI pulsar astrometry with PSR$\pi$ II. parallax distances for 57 pulsars
• An HST/COS legacy survey of high-velocity ultraviolet absorption in the Milky Way's circumgalactic medium and the Local Group
• Estimating the dark matter halo mass of our Milky Way using dynamical tracers
• PsrPopPy: An open-source package for pulsar population simulations
• The Galactic Halo Contribution to the Dispersion Measure of Extragalactic Fast Radio Bursts
• The Extension of the Transition Temperature Plasma into the Lower Galactic Halo
• Spatial distribution of the Milky Way hot gaseous halo constrained by Suzaku X-ray observations
• XMM-Newton Survey of Local O VII Absorption Lines in the Spectra of Active Galactic Nuclei
• Electron Density Structure of the Local Galactic Disk
• Study of open clusters within 1.8 kpc and understanding the Galactic structure
• Exploring the dispersion measure of the Milky Way halo
• On the Use of Fast Radio Burst Dispersion Measures as Distance Measures
• A Data-Driven Technique Using Millisecond Transients to Measure the Milky Way Halo
• Synthesizing the intrinsic FRB population using frbpoppy
• A Survey of the Galactic Plane for Dispersed Pulses with the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder
• Empirical estimates of the Galactic halo contribution to the dispersion measures of extragalactic fast radio bursts using X-ray absorption
• Fruitbat: A Python Package for Estimating Redshifts of Fast Radio Bursts

Cited by in corpus (36)

• The Coherent Magnetic Field of the Milky Way
• An FRB Sent Me a DM: Constraining the Electron Column of the Milky Way Halo with Fast Radio Burst Dispersion Measures from CHIME/FRB
• The emission of interpulses by a 6.45-hour period coherent radio transient
• Spectropolarimetric variability in the repeating fast radio burst source FRB 20180301A
• An Observationally-Derived Kick Distribution for Neutron Stars in Binary Systems
• Disentangling the Faraday rotation sky
• CHIME/FRB/Pulsar discovery of a nearby long period radio transient with a timing glitch
• NE2001p: A Native Python Implementation of the NE2001 Galactic Electron Density Model
• Probing Cosmology with 92 Localized Fast Radio Bursts and DESI BAO
• Green Bank Telescope Discovery of the Redback Binary Millisecond Pulsar PSR J0212+5321
• The Thousand-Pulsar-Array programme on MeerKAT VII: Polarisation properties of pulsars in the Magellanic Clouds
• On Detecting Interstellar Scintillation in Narrowband Radio SETI
• Improving Distances to Binary Millisecond Pulsars with Gaia
• Reinvestigation of Fast Radio Burst Host Galaxy and Event Rate Density
• Improving Binary Millisecond Pulsar Distances with Gaia
• TRAPUM search for pulsars in supernova remnants and pulsar wind nebulae -- I. Survey description and initial discoveries
• NE2025: An Updated Electron Density Model for the Galactic Interstellar Medium
• The BINGO Project IX: Search for Fast Radio Bursts -- A Forecast for the BINGO Interferometry System
• How limiting is optical follow-up for fast radio burst applications? Forecasts for radio and optical surveys
• Short Timescale Evolution of the Polarized Radio Jet during V404 Cygni's 2015 Outburst
• Modeling the Cosmic Dispersion Measure in the D < 120 Mpc Local Universe
• Comprehensive analysis of the Apertif Fast Radio Burst sample: similarities with young, energetic neutron stars
• The Galactic population of magnetars : a simulation-based inference study
• Modeling Current and Future High-Cadence Surveys of Repeating FRB Populations
• Seeking the nearest neutron stars using a new local electron density map
• Constraining the Milky Way's Dispersion Measure Using FRB and X-ray Data
• Revealing the nature of long-period transients with space-based gravitational-wave interferometers
• Scintillation Bandwidth Measurements from 23 Pulsars from the AO327 Survey
• On the Deepest Search for Galactic Center Pulsars and an Examination of an Intriguing Millisecond Pulsar Candidate
• Discovery of a millisecond pulsar associated with Terzan 6
• Checking the Empirical Relations with the Current Localized Fast Radio Bursts
• A Search for Low-frequency Radio Pulses from Long Gamma-ray Bursts with the Murchison Widefield Array
• A Target Search for Fast Radio Bursts Associated with Two Fast Blue Optical Transients: AT2018cow and CSS161010
• The Northern High Time Resolution Universe pulsar survey: III. Single-pulse search continuation, follow-up observations, and initial results
• Discovery and Timing Follow-Up of Two FAST-Discovered Pulsars from the FAST CRAFTS Survey
• 50-250 MHz Pulsar Census with an SKA-Low prototype station: Spectra and Polarization