A Case against a Significant Detection of Precession in the Galactic Warp

Abstract

Recent studies of warp kinematics using Gaia DR2 data have produced detections of warp precession for the first time, which greatly exceeds theoretical predictions of models. However, this detection assumes a warp model derived for a young population (few tens of megayears) to fit velocities of an average older stellar population of the thin disk (several gigayears) in Gaia-DR2 observations, which may lead to unaccounted systematic errors. Here, we recalculate the warp precession with the same approach and Gaia DR2 kinematic data, but using different warp parameters based on the fit of star counts of the Gaia DR2 sample, which has a much lower warp amplitude than the young population. When we take into account this variation of the warp amplitude with the age of the population, we find that there is no need for precession. We find the value of warp precession $\beta =4_{-4}^{+6}$ km s${}^{-1}$ kpc${}^{-1}$, which does not exclude nonprecessing warp.

arXiv comment12 pages, 8 figures, accepted to be published in ApJ

References in corpus (38)

• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• The Gaia mission
• Gaia Data Release 2: The astrometric solution
• The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
• The Sixteenth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Surveys: First Release from the APOGEE-2 Southern Survey and Full Release of eBOSS Spectra
• Gaia Data Release 2: Catalogue validation
• Evidence for a systematic offset of -80 micro-arcseconds in the Gaia DR2 parallaxes
• Outer structure of the Galactic warp and flare: explaining the Canis Major over-density
• Old stellar Galactic disc in near-plane regions according to 2MASS: scales, cut-off, flare and warp
• Gaia Radial Velocity Spectrometer
• StarHorse: A Bayesian tool for determining stellar masses, ages, distances, and extinctions for field stars
• Gaia Data Release 2: Properties and validation of the radial velocities
• A three-dimensional map of the Milky Way using classical Cepheid variable stars
• From the bulge to the outer disc: StarHorse stellar parameters, distances, and extinctions for stars in APOGEE DR16 and other spectroscopic surveys
• Confirmation of the $Gaia$ DR2 parallax zero-point offset using asteroseismology and spectroscopy in the $Kepler$ field
• Gaia Data Release 2: The catalogue of radial velocity standard stars
• Gaia Data Release 2: Processing the spectroscopic data
• The Milky Way's external disc constrained by 2MASS star counts
• An intuitive 3D map of the Galactic warp's precession traced by classical Cepheids
• Warps and Cosmic Infall
• The Galactic warp revealed by Gaia DR2 kinematics
• Warped Galaxies From Misaligned Angular Momenta
• Evidence of a dynamically evolving Galactic warp
• Evolution over time of the Milky Way's disc shape
• Generation of galactic disc warps due to intergalactic accretion flows onto the disc
• Revised Geometric Estimates of the North Galactic Pole and the Sun's Height Above the Galactic Midplane
• Warps and Bars from the External Tidal Torques of Tumbling Dark Halos
• A catalog of warps in spiral and lenticular galaxies in the Southern hemisphere
• Formation of Warped Disks by Galactic Fly-by Encounters. I. Stellar Disks
• Exploring the Galactic Warp Through Asymmetries in the Kinematics of the Galactic Disk
• 3D Asymmetrical motions of the Galactic outer disk with LAMOST K giant stars
• Mapping the Galactic disk with the LAMOST and Gaia Red clump sample. VI: An evidence for the long lived non-steady warp of non-gravitational scenarios
• Gaia-DR2 extended kinematical maps. Part I: Method and application
• Exploring the pertubed Milky Way disk and the substructures of the outer disk
• Vertical velocities from proper motions of red clump giants
• Gaia-DR2 extended kinematical maps. Part II: Dynamics in the Galactic disk explaining radial and vertical velocities
• Structure of the outer Galactic disc with Gaia-DR2
• Galactic Warps in Triaxial Halos

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Tracing the Milky Way warp and spiral arms with classical Cepheids
• The Flare and Warp of the Young Stellar Disk traced with LAMOST DR5 OB-type stars
• A twisted and precessing Cepheid warp in the outer Milky Way disc
• Warp and flare of the old Galactic disc as traced by the red clump stars
• The Great Wave: Evidence of a large-scale vertical corrugation propagating outwards in the Galactic disc
• The tangled warp of the Milky Way
• A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galactic disk warp
• Evidence for Populations-dependent vertical motions and the Long-lived Non-Steady Lopsided Milky Way Warp
• Warped Disk Galaxies. I. Linking U type Warps in Groups/Clusters to Jellyfish Galaxies
• 3-D kinematics of classical Cepheids according to Gaia, EDR3 catalog
• Three-Dimensional Kinematics of Classical Cepheids
• Modeling the vertical distribution of the Milky Way's flat subsystem objects