Revisiting the compatibility problem between the gauge principle and the observability of the canonical orbital angular momentum in the Landau problem
arXiv:2104.10885 · doi:10.1016/j.aop.2021.168647
Abstract
As is widely-known, the eigen-functions of the Landau problem in the symmetric gauge are specified by two quantum numbers. The first is the familiar Landau quantum number , whereas the second is the magnetic quantum number , which is the eigen-value of the canonical orbital angular momentum (OAM) operator of the electron. The eigen-energies of the system depend only on the first quantum number , and the second quantum number does not correspond to any direct observables. This seems natural since the canonical OAM is generally believed to be a {\it gauge-variant} quantity, and observation of a gauge-variant quantity would contradict a fundamental principle of physics called the {\it gauge principle}. In recent researches, however, Bliohk et al. analyzed the motion of helical electron beam along the direction of a uniform magnetic field, which was mostly neglected in past analyses of the Landau states. Their analyses revealed highly non-trivial -dependent rotational dynamics of the Landau electron, but the problem is that their papers give an impression that the quantum number in the Landau eigen-states corresponds to a genuine observable. This compatibility problem between the gauge principle and the observability of the quantum number in the Landau eigen-states was attacked in our previous letter paper. In the present paper, we try to give more convincing answer to this delicate problem of physics, especially by paying attention not only to the {\it particle-like} aspect but also to the {\it wave-like} aspect of the Landau electron.
arXiv commentSlightly compactified version to appear in Annals of Physics
References in corpus (23)
- Gauge-Invariant Decomposition of Nucleon Spin and Its Spin-Off
- The angular momentum controversy: What's it all about and does it matter?
- Theory and applications of free-electron vortex states
- Semiclassical Dynamics of Electron Wave Packet States with Phase Vortices
- Electron vortex beams in a magnetic field: A new twist on Landau levels and Aharonov-Bohm states
- Imaging the dynamics of free-electron Landau states
- On Gauge-Invariant Decomposition of Nucleon Spin
- Quark and Gluon Orbital Angular Momentum and Spin in Hard Processes
- Is gauge-invariant complete decomposition of the nucleon spin possible ?
- Parton Orbital Angular Momentum and Final State Interactions
- Gauge- and frame-independent decomposition of nucleon spin
- Justifying the Naive Partonic Sum Rule for Proton Spin
- The issue of gauge choice in the Landau problem and the physics of canonical and mechanical orbital angular momenta
- Peculiar Rotation of Electron Vortex Beams
- Parallel axis theorem for free-space electron wavefunctions
- The physics of helical electron beam in a uniform magnetic field as a testing ground of gauge principle
- The role of electron orbital angular momentum in the Aharonov-Bohm effect revisited
- Unravelling the physical meaning of the Jaffe-Manohar decomposition of the nucleon spin
- On the two remaning issues in the gauge-invariant decomposition problem of the nucleon spin
- Angular momentum in the fractional quantum Hall effect
- Dynamic structure factors of a strongly interacting Fermi superfluid near an orbital Feshbach resonance across the phase transition from BCS to Sarma superfluid
- Role of guiding center in Landau level system and mechanical and pseudo orbital angular momenta
- Vortex particles in axially symmetric fields and applications of the quantum Busch theorem