Detailed analysis of excited state systematics in a lattice QCD calculation of $g_A$

Abstract

Excited state contamination remains one of the most challenging sources of systematic uncertainty to control in lattice QCD calculations of nucleon matrix elements and form factors: early time separations are contaminated by excited states and late times suffer from an exponentially bad signal-to-noise problem. High-statistics calculations at large time separations $\gtrsim 1$ fm are commonly used to combat these issues. In this work, focusing on $g_A$, we explore the alternative strategy of utilizing a large number of relatively low-statistics calculations at short to medium time separations (0.2--1 fm), combined with a multi-state analysis. On an ensemble with a pion mass of approximately 310 MeV and a lattice spacing of approximately 0.09 fm, we find this provides a more robust and economical method of quantifying and controlling the excited state systematic uncertainty. A quantitative separation of various types of excited states enables the identification of the transition matrix elements as the dominant contamination. The excited state contamination of the Feynman-Hellmann correlation function is found to reduce to the 1% level at approximately 1 fm while for the more standard three-point functions, this does not occur until after 2 fm. Critical to our findings is the use of a global minimization, rather than fixing the spectrum from the two-point functions and using them as input to the three-point analysis. We find that the ground state parameters determined in such a global analysis are stable against variations in the excited state model, the number of excited states, and the truncation of early-time or late-time numerical data.

v2: updates based on referee comments and some community response, consistent with published version; v1: 13 pages plus appendices. The correlation function data and analysis code accompanying this publication can be accessed at this github repository: https://github.com/callat-qcd/project_fh_vs_3pt

References in corpus (24)

• Highly Improved Staggered Quarks on the Lattice, with Applications to Charm Physics
• Measurement of the Weak Axial-Vector Coupling Constant in the Decay of Free Neutrons Using a Pulsed Cold Neutron Beam
• Neutral B Meson Mixing in Unquenched Lattice QCD
• Light hadron spectroscopy using domain wall valence quarks on an Asqtad sea
• Nucleon isovector couplings from $N_f=2$ lattice QCD
• Precision Measurement of the Neutron Beta-Decay Asymmetry
• Precision Nucleon Charges and Form Factors Using 2+1-flavor Lattice QCD
• Calculation of the heavy-hadron axial couplings g_1, g_2, and g_3 using lattice QCD
• Two-nucleon S-wave interactions at the $SU(3)$ flavor-symmetric point with $m_{ud}\simeq m_s^{\mathrm{phys}}$: a first lattice QCD calculation with the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method
• Nucleon axial, scalar, and tensor charges using lattice QCD at the physical pion mass
• Measurement of the Proton Asymmetry Parameter C in Neutron Beta Decay
• A Feynman-Hellmann approach to the spin structure of hadrons
• Chiral extrapolation of g_A with explicit Delta(1232) degrees of freedom
• $F_K/F_{\pi }$ from Möbius domain-wall fermions solved on gradient-flowed HISQ ensembles
• Consistency checks for two-body finite-volume matrix elements: I. Conserved currents and bound states
• Chiral Corrections to Nucleon Two- and Three-Point Correlation Functions
• Time Dependence of Nucleon Correlation Functions in Chiral Perturbation Theory
• Chiral perturbation theory and nucleon-pion-state contaminations in lattice QCD
• Scale setting the Möbius Domain Wall Fermion on gradient-flowed HISQ action using the omega baryon mass and the gradient-flow scales $t_0$ and $w_0$
• Renormalization of the baryon axial vector current in large-N_c chiral perturbation theory
• Lattice QCD Determination of $g_A$
• On the axial-vector form factor of the nucleon and chiral symmetry
• $N\pi$-states and the projection method for the nucleon axial and pseudoscalar form factors
• Excited states in nucleon structure calculations

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Constraining beyond the Standard Model nucleon isovector charges
• Opportunities and open questions in modern $\beta$ decay
• Worldline Monte Carlo method for few body nuclear physics
• Proton momentum and angular momentum decompositions with overlap fermions