Detailed analysis of excited state systematics in a lattice QCD calculation of
arXiv:2104.05226 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.105.065203
Abstract
Excited state contamination remains one of the most challenging sources of systematic uncertainty to control in lattice QCD calculations of nucleon matrix elements and form factors: early time separations are contaminated by excited states and late times suffer from an exponentially bad signal-to-noise problem. High-statistics calculations at large time separations fm are commonly used to combat these issues. In this work, focusing on , we explore the alternative strategy of utilizing a large number of relatively low-statistics calculations at short to medium time separations (0.2--1 fm), combined with a multi-state analysis. On an ensemble with a pion mass of approximately 310 MeV and a lattice spacing of approximately 0.09 fm, we find this provides a more robust and economical method of quantifying and controlling the excited state systematic uncertainty. A quantitative separation of various types of excited states enables the identification of the transition matrix elements as the dominant contamination. The excited state contamination of the Feynman-Hellmann correlation function is found to reduce to the 1% level at approximately 1 fm while for the more standard three-point functions, this does not occur until after 2 fm. Critical to our findings is the use of a global minimization, rather than fixing the spectrum from the two-point functions and using them as input to the three-point analysis. We find that the ground state parameters determined in such a global analysis are stable against variations in the excited state model, the number of excited states, and the truncation of early-time or late-time numerical data.
arXiv commentv2: updates based on referee comments and some community response, consistent with published version; v1: 13 pages plus appendices. The correlation function data and analysis code accompanying this publication can be accessed at this github repository: https://github.com/callat-qcd/project_fh_vs_3pt
References in corpus (87)
- A Method for Simulating Chiral Fermions on the Lattice
- On the Viability of Lattice Perturbation Theory
- The Chroma Software System for Lattice QCD
- Chiral Fermions from Lattice Boundaries
- FLAG Review 2019
- Axial symmetries in lattice QCD with Kaplan fermions
- Solving Lattice QCD systems of equations using mixed precision solvers on GPUs
- Highly Improved Staggered Quarks on the Lattice, with Applications to Charm Physics
- Lattice QCD ensembles with four flavors of highly improved staggered quarks
- Constrained Curve Fitting
- Nucleon structure from mixed action calculations using 2+1 flavors of asqtad sea and domain wall valence fermions
- Energy dependence of the ρ resonance in ππ elastic scattering from lattice QCD
- Coupled scattering in -wave and the resonance from lattice QCD
- A percent-level determination of the nucleon axial coupling from Quantum Chromodynamics
- Measurement of the Weak Axial-Vector Coupling Constant in the Decay of Free Neutrons Using a Pulsed Cold Neutron Beam
- Neutral B Meson Mixing in Unquenched Lattice QCD
- Light hadron spectroscopy using domain wall valence quarks on an Asqtad sea
- -mixing matrix elements from lattice QCD for the Standard Model and beyond
- Resonance Parameters of the rho-Meson from Lattice QCD
- Coupled channel analysis of the rho meson decay in lattice QCD
- Determination of the Weak Axial Vector Coupling from a Measurement of the Beta-Asymmetry Parameter A in Neutron Beta Decay
- Lattice QCD Calculation of the Meson Decay Width
- Axial, Scalar and Tensor Charges of the Nucleon from 2+1+1-flavor Lattice QCD
- Isovector Charges of the Nucleon from 2+1+1-flavor Lattice QCD
- The nucleon axial charge in full lattice QCD
- The nucleon axial charge from lattice QCD with controlled errors
- Nucleon Charges and Electromagnetic Form Factors from 2+1+1-Flavor Lattice QCD
- Nucleon form factors with 2+1 flavor dynamical domain-wall fermions
- Nucleon isovector couplings from lattice QCD
- Axial Vector Form Factors of the Nucleon from Lattice QCD
- Nucleon axial charge in 2+1 flavor dynamical lattice QCD with domain wall fermions
- Nucleon and pion structure with lattice QCD simulations at physical value of the pion mass
- Scattering in the pion-nucleon negative parity channel in lattice QCD
- Axial Vector Form Factors from Lattice QCD that Satisfy the PCAC Relation
- Nucleon axial, tensor and scalar charges and -terms in lattice QCD
- Nucleon axial form factors using lattice QCD simulations with a physical value of the pion mass
- Axial Nucleon form factors from lattice QCD
- Quark spins and Anomalous Ward Identity
- Precision Measurement of the Neutron Beta-Decay Asymmetry
- Precision Nucleon Charges and Form Factors Using 2+1-flavor Lattice QCD
- Proton-proton fusion and tritium -decay from lattice quantum chromodynamics
- Clebsch-Gordan Construction of Lattice Interpolating Fields for Excited Baryons
- Quark mass dependence of the nucleon axial-vector coupling constant
- Baryon Axial Charge in a Finite Volume
- Group-theoretical construction of extended baryon operators in lattice QCD
- Nucleon axial structure from lattice QCD
- Calculation of the heavy-hadron axial couplings g_1, g_2, and g_3 using lattice QCD
- Nucleon Structure from Lattice QCD Using a Nearly Physical Pion Mass
- Towards grounding nuclear physics in QCD
- Iso-vector axial form factors of the nucleon in two-flavour lattice QCD
- Heavy-light mesons with staggered light quarks
- Nucleon isovector charges and twist-2 matrix elements with dynamical Wilson quarks
- Nucleon axial charge and pion decay constant from two-flavor lattice QCD
- On the Feynman-Hellmann Theorem in Quantum Field Theory and the Calculation of Matrix Elements
- On the computation of hadron-to-hadron transition matrix elements in lattice QCD
- Two-nucleon S-wave interactions at the flavor-symmetric point with : a first lattice QCD calculation with the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method
- Nucleon axial, scalar, and tensor charges using lattice QCD at the physical pion mass
- Isovector charges of the nucleon from 2+1-flavor QCD with clover fermions
- Disconnected contributions to the spin of the nucleon
- from decay and four-flavor lattice QCD
- Improved determination of the - angular correlation coefficient in free neutron decay with the SPECT spectrometer
- On the extraction of zero momentum form factors on the lattice
- Measurement of the Proton Asymmetry Parameter C in Neutron Beta Decay
- Precision Study of Excited State Effects in Nucleon Matrix Elements
- A Feynman-Hellmann approach to the spin structure of hadrons
- Chiral extrapolation of g_A with explicit Delta(1232) degrees of freedom
- from Möbius domain-wall fermions solved on gradient-flowed HISQ ensembles
- Nucleon-pion-state contribution in lattice calculations of the nucleon charges and
- Nucleon-pion-state contribution to nucleon two-point correlation functions
- Axial couplings and strong decay widths of heavy hadrons
- Baryon Masses and Axial Couplings in the Combined 1/Nc and Chiral Expansions
- Consistency checks for two-body finite-volume matrix elements: I. Conserved currents and bound states
- Time Dependence of Nucleon Correlation Functions in Chiral Perturbation Theory
- Chiral Corrections to Nucleon Two- and Three-Point Correlation Functions
- Chiral perturbation theory and nucleon-pion-state contaminations in lattice QCD
- Scale setting the Möbius Domain Wall Fermion on gradient-flowed HISQ action using the omega baryon mass and the gradient-flow scales and
- Möbius domain-wall fermions on gradient-flowed dynamical HISQ ensembles
- Renormalization of the baryon axial vector current in large-N_c chiral perturbation theory
- Lattice QCD Determination of
- Excited-state contribution to the axial-vector and pseudo-scalar correlators with two extra pions
- Delocalization of the axial charge in the chiral limit
- On the axial-vector form factor of the nucleon and chiral symmetry
- -states and the projection method for the nucleon axial and pseudoscalar form factors
- Excited states in nucleon structure calculations
- The extraction of the axial coupling from finite volume systems: The long and short of it
- Job Management and Task Bundling
- EspressoDB: A scientific database for managing high-performance computing workflow