Gravitational Effective Field Theory Islands, Low-Spin Dominance, and the Four-Graviton Amplitude

Abstract

We analyze constraints from perturbative unitarity and crossing on the leading contributions of higher-dimension operators to the four-graviton amplitude in four spacetime dimensions, including constraints that follow from distinct helicity configurations. We focus on the leading-order effect due to exchange by massive degrees of freedom which makes the amplitudes of interest infrared finite. In particular, we place a bound on the coefficient of the $R^3$ operator that corrects the graviton three-point amplitude in terms of the $R^4$ coefficient. To test the constraints we obtain nontrivial effective field-theory data by computing and taking the large-mass expansion of the one-loop minimally-coupled four-graviton amplitude with massive particles up to spin 2 circulating in the loop. Remarkably, we observe that the leading EFT coefficients obtained from both string and one-loop field-theory amplitudes lie in small islands. The shape and location of the islands can be derived from the dispersive representation for the Wilson coefficients using crossing and assuming that the lowest-spin spectral densities are the largest. Our analysis suggests that the Wilson coefficients of weakly-coupled gravitational physical theories are much more constrained than indicated by bounds arising from dispersive considerations of $2\to 2$ scattering. The one-loop four-graviton amplitudes used to obtain the EFT data are computed using modern amplitude methods, including generalized unitarity, supersymmetric decompositions and the double copy.

arXiv commentMinor corrections in Fig. 8, ancillary files, and text -- 123 pages, 23 figures, 2 Mathematica ancillary files

References in corpus (92)

• A Large Mass Hierarchy from a Small Extra Dimension
• An Alternative to Compactification
• The Hierarchy Problem and New Dimensions at a Millimeter
• A bound on chaos
• The String Landscape, Black Holes and Gravity as the Weakest Force
• One-Loop n-Point Gauge Theory Amplitudes, Unitarity and Collinear Limits
• On the Geometry of the String Landscape and the Swampland
• New Relations for Gauge-Theory Amplitudes
• Fusing Gauge Theory Tree Amplitudes Into Loop Amplitudes
• Causality, Analyticity and an IR Obstruction to UV Completion
• Perturbative Quantum Gravity as a Double Copy of Gauge Theory
• The Swampland: Introduction and Review
• Multi-Parton Amplitudes in Gauge Theories
• Dimensionally Regulated Pentagon Integrals
• Causality Constraints on Corrections to the Graviton Three-Point Coupling
• The Pomeron and Gauge/String Duality
• Algorithm FIRE -- Feynman Integral REduction
• One-Loop Amplitudes for e^+ e^- to Four Partons
• On the Relationship between Yang-Mills Theory and Gravity and its Implication for Ultraviolet Divergences
• An Automated Implementation of On-Shell Methods for One-Loop Amplitudes
• One-Loop Corrections to Five-Gluon Amplitudes
• Massive Loop Amplitudes from Unitarity
• Dimensionally Regulated One-Loop Integrals
• Direct extraction of one-loop integral coefficients
• Progress in One-Loop QCD Computations
• Two-Loop g -> gg Splitting Amplitudes in QCD
• One-Loop Corrections to Two-Quark Three-Gluon Amplitudes
• Energy's and amplitudes' positivity
• Factorization in One-Loop Gauge Theory
• Scattering into the fifth dimension of N=4 super Yang-Mills
• Supersymmetric Regularization, Two-Loop QCD Amplitudes and Coupling Shifts
• Two-Loop Helicity Amplitudes for Gluon-Gluon Scattering in QCD and Supersymmetric Yang-Mills Theory
• Positivity Bounds for Scalar Theories
• Theoretical Constraints on the Higgs Effective Couplings
• Softness and Amplitudes' Positivity for Spinning Particles
• String-Based Methods in Perturbative Gravity
• Calculation of Graviton Scattering Amplitudes using String-Based Methods
• Ultraviolet Properties of N = 8 Supergravity at Five Loops
• UV complete me: Positivity Bounds for Particles with Spin
• An effective formalism for testing extensions to General Relativity with gravitational waves
• The Complete Four-Loop Four-Point Amplitude in N=4 Super-Yang-Mills Theory
• The Duality Between Color and Kinematics and its Applications
• Signs of Analyticity in Single-Field Inflation
• Basics of Generalized Unitarity
• Infrared Consistency and the Weak Gravity Conjecture
• Quantum Gravity Constraints from Unitarity and Analyticity
• Collinear and Soft Divergences in Perturbative Quantum Gravity
• Scattering Amplitudes For All Masses and Spins
• Strings from Massive Higher Spins: The Asymptotic Uniqueness of the Veneziano Amplitude
• Inconsistencies of Massive Charged Gravitating Higher Spins
• Convex Geometry Perspective to the (Standard Model) Effective Field Theory Space
• Positivity of Curvature-Squared Corrections in Gravity
• Higgs-regularized three-loop four-gluon amplitude in N=4 SYM: exponentiation and Regge limits
• Eikonal methods applied to gravitational scattering amplitudes
• Falsifying Models of New Physics Via WW Scattering
• Beyond $a=c$: Gravitational Couplings to Matter and the Stress Tensor OPE
• Nonperturbative Mellin Amplitudes: Existence, Properties, Applications
• Causality in Curved Spacetimes: The Speed of Light & Gravity
• Massive amplitudes on the Coulomb branch of N=4 SYM
• Gravitational-Wave Constraints on an Effective Field-Theory Extension of General Relativity
• More loops and legs in Higgs-regulated N=4 SYM amplitudes
• Second Order Fermions in Gauge Theories
• On higher-derivative effects on the gravitational potential and particle bending
• Tree-Level Unitarity Constraints on the Gravitational Couplings of Higher-Spin Massive Fields
• The Five-Loop Four-Point Amplitude of N=4 super-Yang-Mills Theory
• No triangles on the moduli space of maximally supersymmetric gauge theory
• A Conformal Collider for Holographic CFTs
• Massive and Massless Spin-2 Scattering and Asymptotic Superluminality
• A Bound on Massive Higher Spin Particles
• Einstein gravity from ANEC correlators
• Elastic positivity vs extremal positivity bounds in SMEFT: a case study in transversal electroweak gauge-boson scatterings
• Causality Constrains Higher Curvature Corrections to Gravity
• Dual conformal symmetry at loop level; massive regularization
• Supersymmetry Relations Between Contributions To One-Loop Gauge Boson Amplitudes
• SCET approach to regularization-scheme dependence of QCD amplitudes
• Massive Spin-5/2 Fields Coupled to Gravity: Tree-Level Unitarity vs. the Equivalence Principle
• Causal vs. Analytic constraints on anomalous quartic gauge couplings
• Consistent Non-Minimal Couplings of Massive Higher-Spin Particles
• The Two-Loop Four-Graviton Scattering Amplitudes
• Dispersion Relation for CFT Four-Point Functions
• A Basis of Analytic Functionals for CFTs in General Dimension
• Massive Supergravity and Deconstruction
• Constructing $\mathcal{N}=4$ Coulomb Branch Superamplitudes
• First Massive State of the Superstring in Superspace
• Massive Higher Spin States in String Theory and the Principle of Equivalence
• Massive On-Shell Supersymmetric Scattering Amplitudes
• Superspace Action for the First Massive States of the Superstring
• External leg corrections in the unitarity method
• Integrands for QCD rational terms and N=4 SYM from massive CSW rules
• Loop Amplitudes in an Extended Gravity Theory
• Higher Derivative Theories for Interacting Massless Gravitons in Minkowski Spacetime
• Classifying and constraining local four photon and four graviton S-matrices

Cited by in corpus (86)

• Causality constraints on corrections to Einstein gravity
• Gravitational ringing of rotating black holes in higher-derivative gravity
• Into the EFThedron and UV constraints from IR consistency
• Rigorous Bounds on Light-by-Light Scattering
• Causality Constraints on Gravitational Effective Field Theories
• Reverse Bootstrapping: IR lessons for UV physics
• Crossing Symmetric Spinning S-matrix Bootstrap: EFT bounds
• Natural Selection Rules: New Positivity Bounds for Massive Spinning Particles
• Off-Shell Color-Kinematics Duality for Chern-Simons
• Bootstrapping Pions at Large $N$
• Bounding Violations of the Weak Gravity Conjecture
• Causal Effective Field Theories
• Graviton partial waves and causality in higher dimensions
• Gravitational Regge bounds
• Causality Constraints on Black Holes beyond GR
• Composing Effective Prediction at Five Points
• Classical vs Quantum Eikonal Scattering and its Causal Structure
• Cornering Large-$N_c$ QCD with Positivity Bounds
• Triple crossing positivity bounds for multi-field theories
• Positivity and Geometric Function Theory Constraints on Pion Scattering
• Veneziano Variations: How Unique are String Amplitudes?
• Gravitational Causality and the Self-Stress of Photons
• SMEFTs living on the edge: determining the UV theories from positivity and extremality
• Massive Gravity is not Positive
• Generalized Veneziano and Virasoro amplitudes
• Moments for positivity: using Drell-Yan data to test positivity bounds and reverse-engineer new physics
• Rigorous bounds on the Analytic $S$-matrix
• QFT, EFT and GFT
• The Stringy S-matrix Bootstrap: Maximal Spin and Superpolynomial Softness
• On the unitarity and low energy expansion of the Coon amplitude
• A cautionary case of casual causality
• UV graviton scattering and positivity bounds from IR dispersion relations
• Accumulation-Point Amplitudes in String Theory
• UV-Complete Gravity Amplitudes and the Triple Product
• Properties of infinite product amplitudes: Veneziano, Virasoro, and Coon
• Bell inequalities in 2-2 scattering
• Swampland Conditions for Higher Derivative Couplings from CFT
• Unitarity Cuts of the Worldsheet
• The SAGEX Review on Scattering Amplitudes, Chapter 7: Positive Geometry of Scattering Amplitudes
• Running Love Numbers and the Effective Field Theory of Gravity
• Bootstrap Principle for the Spectrum and Scattering of Strings
• On the positivity of Coon amplitude in D=4
• Bounds on photon scattering
• The Color-Dual Fates of $F^3$, $R^3$, and $\mathcal{N}=4$ Supergravity
• Virtues of a symmetric-structure double copy
• Spinning Sum Rules for the Dimension-Six SMEFT
• RG of GR from On-shell Amplitudes
• The EFT Bootstrap at Finite $M_{PL}$
• Celestial insights into the S-matrix bootstrap
• On (Scalar QED) Gravitational Positivity Bounds
• Causality and quasi-normal modes in the GREFT
• Positivity Bounds on parity-violating scalar-tensor EFTs
• Effective Field Theory Islands from Perturbative and Nonperturbative Four-Graviton Amplitudes
• Positivity bounds in vector theories
• Positivity Bounds on Massive Vectors
• Non-Forward UV/IR Relations
• Uniqueness Criteria for the Virasoro-Shapiro Amplitude
• Multipositivity Bounds for Scattering Amplitudes
• Locality and Analyticity of the Crossing Symmetric Dispersion Relation
• Feynman Integrals from Positivity Constraints
• Gravity-Induced Photon Interactions and Infrared Consistency in any Dimensions
• Positivity Bounds in Scalar Effective Field Theories at One-loop Level
• Positivity, low twist dominance and CSDR for CFTs
• Positivity of the Hypergeometric Coon Amplitude
• Coon unitarity via partial waves or: how I learned to stop worrying and love the harmonic numbers
• Dispersion relations, knot polynomials and the $q$-deformed harmonic oscillator
• On-shell Supersymmetry and higher-spin amplitudes
• Positivity bounds at one-loop level: the Higgs sector
• Lectures in Quantum Gravity
• Next-to-MHV Yang-Mills kinematic algebra
• Conservative Dynamics of Relativistic Binaries Beyond Einstein Gravity
• Generalized unitarity method for unstable particles
• A Celestial Route to AdS Bulk Locality
• Unitarity and unstable-particle scattering amplitudes
• On the number of Regge trajectories for dual amplitudes
• Positivity bounds in scalar-QED EFT at one-loop level
• Strings from Almost Nothing
• Spectral Constraints on Theories of Colored Particles and Gravity
• Primal S-matrix bootstrap with dispersion relations
• Massive Two-Loop Heavy Particle Diagrams
• Unitarity, Causality, and Solar System Bounds May Significantly Limit the Use of Gravitational Waves to Test General Relativity
• Exploring gravitational impulse via quantum Boltzmann equation
• The Rise of Linear Trajectories
• Constructing the general partial waves and renormalization in EFT
• Leading singularities in higher-derivative Yang-Mills theory and quadratic gravity
• The IR-Side of Positivity Bounds