Confrontation of Observation and Theory: High Frequency QPOs in X-ray Binaries, Tidal Disruption Events, and Active Galactic Nuclei

Abstract

We compile observations of high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) around black holes, both stellar and supermassive, and compare their positions in the parameter space of black hole mass, spin, and oscillation frequency. We find that supermassive black holes occupy a separate region of parameter space than stellar, and further, that QPOs seen around tidal disruption events rather than Seyfert-type AGN occupy an entirely different space. We then compare these results to the orbital resonance, diskoseismic, warped disk, and disk-jet coupling theoretical models for the origin of high-frequency QPOs. We find that while oscillations around stellar mass black holes are generally consistent with the above models, supermassive black holes are decidedly not. Oscillations seen in tidal disruption events are consistent with oscillations near the frequency of the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO), while QPOs in AGN are not accounted for by any of the physical models in consideration. This indicates that despite the scale invariance of accretion processes implied by a decades-wide correlation between QPO frequency and black hole mass, any theory of high frequency QPOs must relate the frequency to more than just the mass and spin.

arXiv comment9 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables. Accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal

References in corpus (74)

• A Fundamental Relation Between Supermassive Black Holes and Their Host Galaxies
• X-ray Properties of Black-Hole Binaries
• General Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of Magnetically Choked Accretion Flows around Black Holes
• The Spin of the Near-Extreme Kerr Black Hole GRS 1915+105
• A precise determination of angular momentum in the black hole candidate GRO J1655-40
• Constraining Black Hole Spin Via X-ray Spectroscopy
• Correlations in the QPO Frequencies of Low Mass X-Ray Binaries and the Relativistic Precession Model
• A simple test for periodic signals in red noise
• Estimating the Spin of Stellar-Mass Black Holes via Spectral Fitting of the X-ray Continuum
• The AGN Black Hole Mass Database
• A New Simple Model for High Frequency Quasi Periodic Oscillations in Black Hole Candidates
• False periodicities in quasar time-domain surveys
• The Simultaneous Optical-to-X-ray Spectral Energy Distribution of Soft X-ray Selected AGN observed by Swift
• A Parallax Distance to the Microquasar GRS 1915+105 and a Revised Estimate of its Black Hole Mass
• Stellar-mass Black Hole Spin Constraints from Disk Reflection and Continuum Modeling
• Black Hole Growth to z = 2 - I: Improved Virial Methods for Measuring M_BH and L/L_Edd
• Broad iron L-line and X-ray reverberation in 1H0707-495
• X-ray variability of 104 active galactic nuclei. XMM-Newton power-spectrum density profiles
• A 400 solar mass black hole in the Ultraluminous X-ray source M82 X-1 accreting close to its Eddington limit
• Evidence for Harmonic Relationships in the High Frequency QPOs of XTE J1550-564 and GRO J1655-40
• 'Stable' QPOs and Black Hole Properties from Diskoseismology
• The Spin of the Black Hole Microquasar XTE J1550-564 via the Continuum-Fitting and Fe-Line Methods
• An Improved Dynamical Model for the Microquasar XTE J1550-564
• Non-linear resonance in nearly geodesic motion in low-mass X-ray binaries
• A radio jet from the optical and x-ray bright stellar tidal disruption flare ASASSN-14li
• High-Frequency Quasi-Periodic Oscillations in black-hole binaries
• Suzaku observations of the hard X-ray variability of MCG-6-30-15: the effects of strong gravity around a Kerr black hole
• High- and low-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations in the X-ray light curves of the black hole transient H1743-322
• Discovery of a Second High Frequency QPO from the Microquasar GRS 1915+105
• Relativistic Diskoseismology. I. Analytical Results for 'Gravity Modes'
• NuSTAR Spectroscopy of GRS 1915+105: Disk Reflection, Spin, and Connections to Jets
• The quiescent light curve and evolutionary state of GRO J1655-40
• Orbital Parameters for the Black Hole Binary XTE J1650-500
• Quasi periodic oscillations in black hole binaries
• High frequency quasi-periodic oscillations in the black hole X-ray transient XTE J1650-500
• A 200-s Quasi-Periodicity Following the Tidal Disruption of a Star by a Dormant Black Hole
• Narrow Iron K$\alpha$ Lines in Active Galactic Nuclei: Evolving Populations?
• Black Hole Mass of the Ultraluminous X-ray source M82 X-1
• The not-so-massive black hole in the microquasar GRS1915+105
• Measuring the Spin of GRS 1915+105 with Relativistic Disk Reflection
• The importance of discovering a 3:2 twin-peak QPO in a ULX or how to solve the puzzle of intermediate mass black holes
• Evidence for an Intermediate Mass Black Hole in NGC 5408 X-1
• Supermassive black holes, pseudobulges, and the narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies
• A Remarkably Loud Quasi-Periodicity after a Star is Disrupted by a Massive Black Hole
• Discovery of a ~2 hr high frequency X-ray QPO and iron K alpha reverberation in the active galaxy MS 2254.9-3712
• On the time variability of geometrically-thin black hole accretion disks I : the search for modes in simulated disks
• Identification of black hole power spectral components across all canonical states
• Quasi-Periodic Oscillations from Rayleigh-Taylor and Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability at a Disk-Magnetosphere Interface
• A ~3.8 hour Periodicity from an Ultrasoft Active Galactic Nucleus Candidate
• A soft X-ray reverberation lag in the AGN ESO 113-G010
• Detection of a possible X-ray Quasi-periodic Oscillation in the Active Galactic Nucleus 1H~0707-495
• High-frequency Quasi-Periodic Oscillations from GRS 1915+105 in its C state
• Possible ~ 1 hour quasi-periodic oscillation in narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxy MCG--06--30--15
• A Reverberation-Based Black Hole Mass for MCG-06-30-15
• Determining the spectroscopic mass ratio in interacting binaries: Application to X-Ray Nova Sco 1994
• X-ray and Radio Constraints on the Mass of the Black Hole in Swift J164449.3+573451
• An X-ray periodicity of $\sim$1.8 hours in a narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxy Mrk 766
• Universal scaling of the 3:2 twin-peak quasi-periodic oscillation frequencies with black hole mass and spin revisited
• The mass of the black hole in RE J1034+396
• Evidence for an Optical Low-frequency Quasi-Periodic Oscillation in the Kepler Light Curve of an Active Galaxy
• Detection of an X-ray periodicity in the Narrow-line Seyfert 1 Galaxy Mrk 766 with XMM-Newton
• Weak nonlinear coupling between epicyclic modes in slender tori
• A Relativistic Disc Reflection Model for 1H0419-577: Multi-Epoch Spectral Analysis with XMM-Newton and NuSTAR
• Relativistic Diskoseismology. III. Low-Frequency Fundamental p-Modes
• Models of high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations and black hole spin estimates in Galactic microquasars
• X-ray reflection from the inner disk of the AGN Ton S180
• An Extreme Ultraviolet Explorer Atlas of Seyfert Galaxy Light Curves: Search for Periodicity
• A variable-frequency HFQPO in GRS 1915+105 as observed with Astrosat
• On the Time Variability of Geometrically-Thin Black Hole Accretion Disks II: Viscosity-Induced Global Oscillation Modes in Simulated Disks
• NuSTAR observations of Mrk 766: distinguishing reflection from absorption
• HFQPOs and discoseismic mode excitation in eccentric, relativistic discs. II. Magnetohydrodynamic simulations
• Swift J164449.3+573451 and Swift J2058.4+0516: Black hole mass estimates for tidal disruption event sources
• Discovery of a 23.8h QPO in the SWIFT light curve of XMMU J134736.6+173403
• High-Frequency QPOs and Overstable Oscillations of Black-Hole Accretion Disks

Cited by in corpus (20)

• Epicyclic oscillations in spinning particle motion around Kerr black hole applied in models fitting the quasi-periodic oscillations observed in quasars and microquasars
• Epicyclic Oscillations around Simpson-Visser Regular Black Holes and Wormholes
• Nozzle Shocks, Disk Tearing and Streamers Drive Rapid Accretion in 3D GRMHD Simulations of Warped Thin Disks
• Disk Tearing Leads to Low and High Frequency Quasi Periodic Oscillations in a GRMHD Simulation of a Thin Accretion Disk
• Geodesic Model of HF QPOs Tested for Black Holes in Spacetimes Reflecting the Effect of Surrounding Dark Matter
• Optical Quasi-periodic Oscillations in the TESS light curves of three blazars
• Searching for Quasi-periodic Oscillations in Active Galactic Nuclei of the Chandra Deep Field South
• Search for X-ray Quasi-periodicity of six AGNs using Gaussian Process method
• Simple analytic formula relating the mass and spin of accreting compact objects to their rapid X-ray variability
• The detection of possible $\gamma$-ray quasi-periodic modulation with $\sim$600 days from the blazar S2 0109+22
• Research on high-frequency quasi-periodic oscillations in black bounce-type spacetime
• Modeling HF-QPOs in Microquasars and AGNs: Charged Particles around Black Holes with CDM Halos
• Observational constraints on the Kerr and its several single-parameter modified spacetimes using quasi-periodic oscillation data
• Accretion tori around rotating neutron stars II: Oscillations and precessions
• QPO-Based Bayesian Constraints on Charged Particle Dynamics Around Magnetized Schwarzschild Black Holes
• Can we disentangle between the emission of an accretion disc around a single black hole and a circumbinary disc ?
• A supermassive black hole under the radar: Repeating X-ray variability in a Seyfert galaxy
• X-ray Quasi-Periodic Oscillations in Active Galactic Nuclei and Their Implications for the Changing Look Phenomenon
• Supermassive black holes surrounded by dark matter modeled as anisotropic fluid: epicyclic oscillations and their fitting to observed QPOs
• Evolution of a Mode of Oscillation Within Turbulent Accretion Disks