Black-hole spectroscopy, the no-hair theorem and GW150914: Kerr vs. Occam

Abstract

The "no-hair" theorem states that astrophysical black holes are fully characterised by just two numbers: their mass and spin. The gravitational-wave emission from a perturbed black-hole consists of a superposition of damped sinusoids, known as \textit{quasi-normal modes}. Quasi-normal modes are specified by three integers $(\ell ,m,n)$: the $(\ell ,m)$ integers describe the angular properties and $(n)$ specifies the (over)tone. If the no-hair theorem holds, the frequencies and damping times of quasi-normal modes are determined uniquely by the mass and spin of the black hole, while phases and amplitudes depend on the particular perturbation. Current tests of the no-hair theorem, attempt to identify these modes in a semi-agnostic way, without imposing priors on the source of the perturbation. This is usually known as \textit{black-hole spectroscopy}. Applying this framework to GW150914, the measurement of the first overtone led to the confirmation of the theorem to $20\%$ level. We show, however, that such semi-agnostic tests cannot provide strong evidence in favour of the no-hair theorem, even for extremely loud signals, given the increasing number of overtones (and free parameters) needed to fit the data. This can be solved by imposing prior assumptions on the origin of the perturbed black hole that can further constrain the explored parameters: in particular, our knowledge that the ringdown is sourced by a binary black hole merger. Applying this strategy to GW150914 we find a natural log Bayes factor of $\sim 6.5$ in favour of the Kerr nature of its remnant, indicating that the hairy object hypothesis is disfavoured with $<1:600$ with respect to the Kerr black-hole one.

12 pages, 4 figures, Version Accepted for publication in Phys.Rev.D

References in corpus (15)

• Advanced LIGO
• GW190814: Gravitational Waves from the Coalescence of a 23 M${}_{\odot }$ Black Hole with a 2.6 M${}_{\odot }$ Compact Object
• GW190521: A Binary Black Hole Merger with a Total Mass of $150M_{\odot }$
• GW190412: Observation of a Binary-Black-Hole Coalescence with Asymmetric Masses
• BayesWave: Bayesian Inference for Gravitational Wave Bursts and Instrument Glitches
• Model Waveform Accuracy Standards for Gravitational Wave Data Analysis
• GW190521: orbital eccentricity and signatures of dynamical formation in a binary black hole merger signal
• Observational Black Hole Spectroscopy: A time-domain multimode analysis of GW150914
• Reducing phase error in long numerical binary black hole evolutions with sixth order finite differencing
• Testing the no-hair theorem with black hole ringdowns using TIGER
• Ringdown overtones, black hole spectroscopy, and no-hair theorem tests
• Gravitational-wave observations of binary black holes: Effect of non-quadrupole modes
• Spectroscopy of binary black hole ringdown using overtones and angular modes
• Challenges testing the no-hair theorem with gravitational waves
• Revisiting non-linearity in binary black hole mergers

Cited by in corpus (63)

• Destabilizing the Fundamental Mode of Black Holes: The Elephant and the Flea
• Analysis of Ringdown Overtones in GW150914
• Agnostic black hole spectroscopy: Quasinormal mode content of numerical relativity waveforms and limits of validity of linear perturbation theory
• No-Hair Theorem in the Wake of Event Horizon Telescope
• Constraints on quasi-normal-mode frequencies with LIGO-Virgo binary-black-hole observations
• GW250114: testing Hawking's area law and the Kerr nature of black holes
• Extracting linear and nonlinear quasinormal modes from black hole merger simulations
• Searching for a Ringdown Overtone in GW150914
• Quasinormal-mode filters: a new approach to analyze the gravitational-wave ringdown of binary black-hole mergers
• Generation and propagation of nonlinear quasi-normal modes of a Schwarzschild black hole
• Role of black hole quasinormal mode overtones for ringdown analysis
• Possible Causes of False General Relativity Violations in Gravitational Wave Observations
• Using rational filters to uncover the first ringdown overtone in GW150914
• Black hole spectroscopy by mode cleaning
• Quasinormal Modes of Black Holes with Non-Linear-Electrodynamic sources in Rastall Gravity
• Neural Posterior Estimation with guaranteed exact coverage: the ringdown of GW150914
• Thermal Ringdown of a Kerr Black Hole: Overtone Excitation, Fermi-Dirac Statistics and Greybody Factor
• Nonlinear quasinormal mode detectability with next-generation gravitational wave detectors
• The Lunar Gravitational-wave Antenna: Mission Studies and Science Case
• Black hole spectroscopy horizons for current and future gravitational wave detectors
• Searching for ringdown higher modes with a numerical relativity-informed post-merger model
• Theory-agnostic Reconstruction of Potential and Couplings from Quasi-Normal Modes
• First gravitational-wave search for intermediate-mass black hole mergers with higher order harmonics
• Solving the Teukolsky equation with physics-informed neural networks
• On the detectability of higher harmonics with LISA
• Constraining modifications of black hole perturbation potentials near the light ring with quasinormal modes
• Bekenstein-Hod Universal Bound on Information Emission Rate Is Obeyed by LIGO-Virgo Binary Black Hole Remnants
• Quadratic Quasi-Normal Modes of a Schwarzschild Black Hole
• Parametrized Black Hole Quasinormal Ringdown Formalism for Higher Overtones
• Parameter Estimation for Stellar-Origin Black Hole Mergers In LISA
• Quasi-Normal Modes of Loop Quantum Black Holes Formed from Gravitational Collapse
• Effect of Noise Estimation in Time-Domain Ringdown Analysis: A Case Study with GW150914
• Striking the right tone: toward a self-consistent framework for measuring black hole ringdowns
• Odd-parity perturbations of the wormhole-like geometries and quasi-normal modes in Einstein-Æther theory
• Nonlinear effect of absorption on the ringdown of a spinning black hole
• Iterative extraction of overtones from black hole ringdown
• Impact of ringdown higher-order modes on black-hole mergers in dense environments: the scalar field case, detectability and parameter biases
• Parametrized spin-precessing inspiral-merger-ringdown waveform model for tests of general relativity
• Measuring quasi-normal mode amplitudes with misaligned binary black hole ringdowns
• Linear vs. nonlinear modeling of black hole ringdowns
• Gravitational-wave parameter inference with the Newman-Penrose scalar ${\psi }_4$
• Quasinormal Modes in Modified Gravity using Physics-Informed Neural Networks
• Bounds on tidal charges from gravitational-wave ringdown observations
• Reanalyzing the ringdown signal of GW150914 using the F-statistic method
• Gravitational wave ringdown analysis using the $\mathcal{F}$-statistic
• Comparison between time-domain and frequency-domain Bayesian inferences to inspiral-merger-ringdown gravitational-wave signals
• Theory-agnostic searches for non-gravitational modes in black hole ringdown
• Gravitational-wave memory effects in the Damour-Esposito-Farèse extension of Brans-Dicke theory
• Gravitational-wave signatures of mirror (a)symmetry in binary black hole mergers: measurability and correlation to gravitational-wave recoil
• Ten years of extreme gravity tests of general theory of relativity with gravitational-wave observations
• Self-consistent treatment of thermal effects in neutron-star post-mergers: observational implications for third-generation gravitational-wave detectors
• The landscape of massive black-hole spectroscopy with LISA and Einstein Telescope
• Modeling the frequency-domain ringdown amplitude of comparable-mass mergers with greybody factors
• Modeling the BMS transformation induced by a binary black hole merger
• A gating-and-inpainting perspective on GW150914 ringdown overtone: understanding the data analysis systematics
• First Overtone Mode in the Ringdown Signal of GW231028
• GW250114 reveals black hole horizon signatures
• Applying higher-modes consistency test on GW190814 : lessons on no-hair theorem, nature of the secondary compact object and waveform modeling
• Impact of Detector Calibration Accuracy on Black Hole Spectroscopy
• Comparing Bayes factors and hierarchical inference for testing general relativity with gravitational waves
• Charged black holes in de Sitter space: superradiant amplification of charged scalar waves and resonant hyperradiation
• On the ease of excitation of black hole ringing: Quantifying the importance of overtones by the excitation factors
• Waveform stability of black hole ringdown with stochastic horizon structure