Interpreting Internal Consistency of DES Measurements

Abstract

Bayesian evidence ratios are widely used to quantify the statistical consistency between different experiments. However, since the evidence ratio is prior dependent, the precise translation between its value and the degree of concordance/discordance requires additional information. The most commonly adopted metric, the Jeffreys scale, can falsely suggest agreement between datasets when priors are chosen to be sufficiently wide. In this work, we examine evidence ratios in a DES-Y1 simulated analysis, focusing on the internal consistency between weak lensing and galaxy clustering. We study two scenarios using simulated data in controlled experiments. First, we calibrate the expected evidence ratio distribution given noise realizations around the best fit DES-Y1 $\Lambda$CDM cosmology. Second, we show the behavior of evidence ratios for noiseless fiducial data vectors simulated using a modified gravity model, which generates internal tension in the $\Lambda$CDM analysis. We show that the choice of prior could conceal the discrepancies between weak lensing and galaxy clustering induced by such models and that the evidence ratio in a DES-Y1 study is, indeed, biased towards agreement.

19 figures

References in corpus (13)

• Large Magellanic Cloud Cepheid Standards Provide a 1% Foundation for the Determination of the Hubble Constant and Stronger Evidence for Physics Beyond LambdaCDM
• Wide-Field InfrarRed Survey Telescope-Astrophysics Focused Telescope Assets WFIRST-AFTA 2015 Report
• Planck evidence for a closed Universe and a possible crisis for cosmology
• The Cosmic Linear Anisotropy Solving System (CLASS) I: Overview
• Dark energy constraints from cosmic shear power spectra: impact of intrinsic alignments on photometric redshift requirements
• Report of the Dark Energy Task Force
• CMB-S4 Science Book, First Edition
• The Wide Field Infrared Survey Telescope: 100 Hubbles for the 2020s
• Dark Energy Survey Year 1 Results: Multi-Probe Methodology and Simulated Likelihood Analyses
• SPTpol: an instrument for CMB polarization measurements with the South Pole Telescope
• anesthetic: nested sampling visualisation
• Findings of the Joint Dark Energy Mission Figure of Merit Science Working Group
• The linear growth rate of structure in Parametrized Post Friedmannian Universes

Cited by in corpus (3)

• Assessing tension metrics with Dark Energy Survey and Planck data
• Accelerating cosmological inference with Gaussian processes and neural networks -- an application to LSST Y1 weak lensing and galaxy clustering
• Growth and Geometry Split in Light of the DES-Y3 Survey