Sub-Chandrasekhar-mass detonations are in tension with the observed $t_0-M_{\text{Ni56}}$ relation of type Ia supernovae

Abstract

Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) are likely the thermonuclear explosions of carbon-oxygen (CO) white-dwarf (WD) stars, but their progenitor systems remain elusive. Recent studies have suggested that a propagating detonation within a thin helium shell surrounding a sub-Chandrasekhar mass CO core can subsequently trigger a detonation within the core (the double-detonation model, DDM). The outcome of this explosion is similar to a central ignition of a sub-Chandrasekhar mass CO WD (SCD). While SCD is consistent with some observational properties of SNe Ia, several computational challenges prohibit a robust comparison to the observations. We focus on the observed $t_0-M_{\text{Ni56}}$ relation, where $t_0$ (the $\gamma$-rays' escape time from the ejecta) is positively correlated with $M_{\text{Ni56}}$ (the synthesized ${}^{56}$Ni mass). We apply our recently developed numerical scheme to calculate SCD and show that the calculated $t_0-M_{\text{Ni56}}$ relation, which does not require radiation transfer calculations, converges to an accuracy of a few percent. We find a clear tension between our calculations and the observed $t_0-M_{\text{Ni56}}$ relation. SCD predicts an anti-correlation between $t_0$ and $M_{\text{Ni56}}$, with $t_0\approx 30\text{day}$ for luminous ($M_{\text{Ni56}}\gtrsim 0.5M_{\odot }$) SNe Ia, while the observed $t_0$ is in the range of $35-45\text{day}$. We show that this tension is larger than the uncertainty of the results, and that it exists in all previous studies of the problem. Our results hint that more complicated models are required, but we argue that DDM is unlikely to resolve the tension with the observations.

arXiv comment24 pages, 20 figures. Main results in the first 3 pages with 1 figure. Minor revisions following referee's report

References in corpus (51)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions
• Type Ia Supernova Explosion Models
• Observational clues to the progenitors of Type-Ia supernovae
• SALT2: using distant supernovae to improve the use of Type Ia supernovae as distance indicators
• The Supernova Legacy Survey 3-year sample: Type Ia Supernovae photometric distances and cosmological constraints
• Explosion Models for Type Ia Supernovae: A Comparison with Observed Light Curves, distances, H_o and q_o
• Radiative Transfer Simulations for Neutron Star Merger Ejecta
• Double-detonation sub-Chandrasekhar supernovae: can minimum helium shell masses detonate the core?
• Faint Thermonuclear Supernovae from AM Canum Venaticorum Binaries
• Detonations in Sub-Chandrasekhar Mass C+O White Dwarfs
• Time Dependent Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer Calculations For 3-Dimensional Supernova Spectra, Lightcurves, and Polarization
• On Variations in the Peak Luminosity of Type Ia Supernovae
• Sub-Chandrasekhar Mass Models For Type Ia Supernovae
• Extensible Component Based Architecture for FLASH, A Massively Parallel, Multiphysics Simulation Code
• Double-detonation sub-Chandrasekhar supernovae: synthetic observables for minimum helium shell mass models
• Head-on collisions of white dwarfs in triple systems could explain type Ia supernova
• Sub-Chandrasekhar-mass white dwarf detonations revisited
• New cooling sequences for old white dwarfs
• Double-detonation supernovae of sub-Chandrasekhar mass white dwarfs
• Synthetic Spectra of Hydrodynamic Models of Type Ia Supernovae
• STARLIB: A Next-Generation Reaction-Rate Library for Nuclear Astrophysics
• Observational Predictions for Sub-Chandrasekhar Mass Explosions: Further Evidence for Multiple Progenitor Systems for Type Ia Supernovae
• Equation of state of fully ionized electron-ion plasmas
• Constraints on the Progenitor Systems of Type Ia Supernovae
• The Ignition of Carbon Detonations via Converging Shock Waves in White Dwarfs
• The Initiation and Propagation of Helium Detonations in White Dwarf Envelopes
• Type Ia supernova bolometric light curves and ejected mass estimates from the Nearby Supernova Factory
• One-dimensional delayed-detonation models of Type Ia supernovae: Confrontation to observations at bolometric maximum
• Gamma-Ray Transfer and Energy Deposition in Supernovae
• Spontaneous Initiation of Detonations in White Dwarf Environments: Determination of Critical Sizes
• Evidence for sub-Chandrasekhar-mass progenitors of Type Ia supernovae at the faint end of the width-luminosity relation
• Type Ia Supernovae from Merging White Dwarfs I. Prompt Detonations
• Double Detonations with Thin, Modestly Enriched Helium Layers Can Make Normal Type Ia Supernovae
• Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer
• Type Ia Supernovae with Bi-Modal Explosions Are Common -- Possible Smoking Gun for Direct Collisions of White-Dwarfs
• New full evolutionary sequences of H and He atmosphere massive white dwarf stars using MESA
• Type Ia supernovae have two physical width-luminosity relations and they favor sub-Chandrasekhar and direct collision models. I. Bolometric
• SNR-calibrated Type Ia supernova models
• The Effects of Curvature and Expansion on Helium Detonations on White Dwarf Surfaces
• The $\gamma$-ray deposition histories of core-collapse supernovae
• Possible in situ Tests of the Evolution of Elemental and Isotopic Abundances in the Solar Convection Zone
• A Significantly off-center Ni56 Distribution for the Low-Luminosity Type Ia Supernova SN 2016brx from the 100IAS survey
• Type Ia supernovae have two physical width-luminosity relations and they favor sub-Chandrasekhar and direct collision models - II. Color evolution
• An accurate and efficient numerical calculation of detonation waves in multidimensional supernova simulations using a burning limiter and adaptive quasi-statistical equilibrium
• Signatures of Bimodality in Nebular Phase Type Ia Supernova Spectra
• Screening of fusion reactions from the principle of detailed balance and application to the $pep$ reaction
• Quantifying How Density Gradients and Front Curvature Affect Carbon Detonation Strength During Type Ia Supernovae
• The structure of detonation waves in supernovae revisited

Cited by in corpus (16)

• Double detonations of sub-Chandrasekhar mass CO white dwarfs: Can different core and He shell masses explain variations of Type Ia supernovae?
• On the fate of the secondary white dwarf in double-degenerate double-detonation Type Ia supernovae
• Non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium Radiative Transfer Simulations of Sub-Chandrasekhar-Mass White Dwarf Detonations
• Multi-Dimensional Parameter Study of Double Detonation Type Ia Supernovae Originating from Thin-Helium-Shell White Dwarfs
• Multi-Dimensional Radiative Transfer Calculations of Double Detonations of Sub-Chandrasekhar-Mass White Dwarfs
• Stable nickel production in Type Ia supernovae: A smoking gun for the progenitor mass?
• Exploring the diversity of double detonation explosions for type Ia supernovae: Effects of the post-explosion helium shell composition
• Delayed Detonation Thermonuclear Supernovae With An Extended Dark Matter Component
• AT2018lqh and the nature of the emerging population of day-scale duration optical transients
• Type Ia Supernova Magnitude Step from the local Dark Matter Environment
• Confronting double-detonation sub-Chandrasekhar models with the low-luminosity suppression of Type Ia supernovae
• The $\gamma$-ray deposition histories of Calcium-rich supernovae
• Off-centre ignition of sub-Chandrasekhar white dwarfs does not resolve the tension with the observed $t_0$-$M_{\mathrm{Ni}56}$ relation of type Ia supernovae
• All known Type Ia supernovae models fail to reproduce the observed bolometric luminosity-width correlation
• What triggers type Ia supernovae: Prompt detonations from primordial black holes or companion stars?
• All known Type Ia supernovae models fail to reproduce the observed $t_0-M_{\text{Ni56}}$ correlation