Pulsar radio emission mechanisms: a critique

Abstract

We consider critically the three most widely favored pulsar radio emission mechanisms: coherent curvature emission (CCE), beam-driven relativistic plasma emission (RPE) and anomalous Doppler emission (ADE). We assume that the pulsar plasma is one dimensional (1D), streaming outward with a bulk Lorentz factor ${\gamma }_{\mathrm{s}}\gg ⟨\gamma ⟩-1\gtrsim 1$, where $⟨\gamma ⟩$ is the intrinsic spread in the rest frame of the plasma. We argue that the formation of beams in a multi-cloud model is ineffective in the intrinsically relativistic case for plausible parameters, because the overtaking takes too long. We argue that the default choice for the particle distribution in the rest frame is a J{ü}ttner distribution and that relativistic streaming should be included by applying a Lorentz transformation to the rest-frame distribution, rather than the widely assumed relativistically streaming Gaussian distribution. We find that beam-driven wave growth is severely restricted by (a) the wave properties in pulsar plasma, (b) a separation condition between beam and background, and (c) the inhomogeneity of the plasma in the pulsar frame. The growth rate for the kinetic instability is much smaller and the bandwidth of the growing waves is much larger for a J{ü}ttner distribution than for a relativistically streaming Gaussian distribution. No reactive instability occurs at all for a J{ü}ttner distribution. We conclude that none of CCE, RPE and ADE in tenable as the generic pulsar radio emission mechanism for ``plausible'' assumptions about the pulsar plasma.

Accepted for publication (MNRAS)

References in corpus (14)

• Coherent Emission Mechanisms in Astrophysical Plasmas
• Time-dependent pair cascades in magnetospheres of neutron stars I. Dynamics of the polar cap cascade with no particle supply from the neutron star surface
• Ab-initio pulsar magnetosphere: three-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations of oblique pulsars
• Profile and polarization characteristics of energetic pulsars
• An empirical model for the beams of radio pulsars
• Pulsar Radio Emission Mechanism: Radio Nanoshots as a Low Frequency Afterglow of Relativistic Magnetic Reconnection
• Polar-cap accelerator and radio emission from pulsars
• Multi-frequency integrated profiles of pulsars
• Unraveling the nature of coherent pulsar radio emission
• Light-curve modelling constraints on the obliquities and aspect angles of the young Fermi pulsars
• The Nature of Coherent Radio Emission from Pulsars
• On the adiabatic walking of plasma waves in a pulsar magnetosphere
• A model for double notches and bifurcated components in radio profiles of pulsars and magnetars - Evidence for the parallel acceleration maser in pulsar magnetosphere
• The Free Electron Maser in Pulsar Magnetospheres

Cited by in corpus (36)

• Searches for Continuous-Wave Gravitational Radiation
• Repeating Fast Radio Bursts from Collapses of the Crust of a Strange Star
• A polarization census of bright pulsars using the Ultra-Wideband Receiver on the Parkes radio telescope
• Evolutionary implications of a magnetar interpretation for GLEAM-X J162759.5-523504.3
• Status Report on Global Pulsar-Timing-Array Efforts to Detect Gravitational Waves
• Evidence for Coherent Curvature Radiation in PSR J1645$-$0317 with Disordered Distribution of Polarization Position Angle
• Electric field screening in pair discharges and generation of pulsar radio emission
• Pulsar Emission Beam Geometry of Radio Broadband Arecibo Sources
• Submillimeter pulsations from the magnetar XTE J1810-197
• Radio Emission by Soliton Formation in Relativistically Hot Streaming Pulsar Pair Plasmas
• Radiation by the superluminally moving current sheet in the magnetosphere of a neutron star
• The polarization of the drifting sub-pulses from PSR B1919+21
• Ring momentum distributions as a general feature of Vlasov dynamics in the synchrotron dominated regime
• Poynting flux transport channels formed in polar cap regions of neutron star magnetospheres
• Testing afterglow models of FRB 200428 with early post-burst observations of SGR 1935+2154
• PSR J0026-1955: A curious case of evolutionary subpulse drifting and nulling
• Does the gamma-ray binary LS I +61°303 harbor a magnetar?
• Coherent Curvature Radiation Spectrum by Dynamically Fluctuating Bunches in Magnetospheres
• Linear acceleration emission of pulsar relativistic streaming instability and interacting plasma bunches
• A stacked search for spatial coincidences between IceCube neutrinos and radio pulsars
• Brightness temperature constraints on coherent processes in magnetospheres of neutron stars
• A Multifrequency Census of 100 Pulsars below 100 MHz with LWA: A Systematic Study of Flux Density, Spectra, Timing, Dispersion, Polarization, and Its Variation from a Decade of Observations
• Particle-in-cell simulations of electron-positron cyclotron maser forming pulsar radio zebras
• Relativistic Gas: Invariant Lorentz Distribution for the velocities
• Radio Emission of Pulsars. II. Coherence Catalyzed by Cerenkov-Unstable Shear Alfvén Waves
• Radio spectra of pulsars fitted with the spectral distribution function of the emission from their current sheet
• Streaming instability in neutron star magnetospheres: No indication of soliton-like waves
• Gamma-ray spectra of the Crab, Vela and Geminga pulsars fitted with SED of the emission from their current sheet
• Origin of radio polarization in pulsar polar caps
• Superdense beaming of axion dark matter in the vicinity of the light cylinder of pulsars
• Search of nearby resolved neutron stars among optical sources
• An alternative interpretation of magnetars' traits deduced from the observational data on their outburst fluxes and spectra
• Bunch Expansion as a cause for Pulsar Radio Emissions
• Application of Efron-Petrosian method to radio pulsar fluxes
• Relativistic Lévy processes
• Independent discovery of a nulling pulsar with unusual sub-pulse drifting properties with the Murchison Widefield Array