Facing the problems on the determination of stellar temperatures and gravities: Galactic globular clusters

Abstract

We analysed red giant branch stars in 16 Galactic globular clusters, computing their atmospheric parameters both from the photometry and from excitation and ionisation balances. The spectroscopic parameters are lower than the photometric ones and this discrepancy increases decreasing the metallicity, reaching, at [Fe/H]~-2.5 dex, differences of ~350 K in effective temperature and ~1 dex in surface gravity. We demonstrate that the spectroscopic parameters are inconsistent with the position of the stars in the colour-magnitude diagram, providing too low temperatures and gravities, and predicting that the stars are up to about 2.5 magnitudes brighter than the observed magnitudes. The parameter discrepancy is likely due to the inadequacies of the adopted physics, in particular the assumption of 1-dimensional geometry can be the origin of the observed slope between iron abundances and excitation potential that leads to low temperatures. However, the current modelling of 3D/NLTE radiative transfer for giant stars seems to be not able to totally erase this slope. We conclude that the spectroscopic parameters are wrong for metallicity lower than -1.5 dex and for these red giant stars photometric temperatures and gravities should be adopted. We provide a simple relation to correct the spectroscopic temperatures in order to put them onto a photometric scale.

arXiv commentaccepted for publication in A&A, 12 pages, 9 figures, 4 tables

References in corpus (50)

• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• The Gaia mission
• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• The SIMBAD astronomical database
• The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database
• First stars V - Abundance patterns from C to Zn and supernova yields in the early Galaxy
• Color Transformations for the 2MASS Second Incremental Data Release
• ASPCAP: The Apogee Stellar Parameter and Chemical Abundances Pipeline
• An absolutely calibrated effective temperature scale from the InfraRed Flux Method
• Intrinsic iron spread and a new metallicity scale for Globular Clusters
• Na-O Anticorrelation and HB. VIII. Proton-capture elements and metallicities in 17 globular clusters from UVES spectra
• The angular size of dwarf stars and subgiants - Surface brightness relations calibrated by interferometry
• A new implementation of the infrared flux method using the 2MASS catalogue
• NLTE line formation of Fe for late-type stars. I. Standard stars with 1D and <3D> model atmospheres
• NLTE line formation of Fe in late-type stars II: 1D spectroscopic stellar parameters
• The Most Metal-Poor Stars. II. Chemical Abundances of 190 Metal-Poor Stars Including 10 New Stars With [Fe/H] < -3.5
• The Stagger-grid: A Grid of 3D Stellar Atmosphere Models - I. Methods and General Properties
• DAOSPEC: an automatic code for measuring equivalent widths in high-resolution stellar spectra
• Abundances of 30 elements in 23 metal-poor stars
• The effective temperature scale of FGK stars. I. Determination of temperatures and angular diameters with the infrared flux method
• 3D Hydrodynamical Simulations of Surface Convection in Red Giant Stars. Impact on spectral line formation and abundance analysis
• Both accurate and precise gf-values for FeII lines
• Non-LTE line formation of Fe in late-type stars - III. 3D non-LTE analysis of metal-poor stars
• Homogeneous Analysis of Globular Clusters from the APOGEE Survey with the BACCHUS Code. II. The Southern Clusters and Overview
• APOGEE Data Releases 13 and 14: Stellar Parameter and Abundance Comparisons With Independent Analyses
• Multi-Element Abundance Measurements from Medium-Resolution Spectra. I. The Sculptor Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy
• Radiative transfer with scattering for domain-decomposed 3D MHD simulations of cool stellar atmospheres
• The Ital-FLAMES survey of the Sagittarius dwarf Spheroidal galaxy. I. Chemical abundances of bright RGB stars
• Exploring Anticorrelations and Light Element Variations in Northern Globular Clusters Observed by the APOGEE Survey
• New Extremely Metal-Poor Stars in the Galactic Halo
• Homogeneous photometry VII. Globular clusters in the Gaia era
• Deriving Stellar Effective Temperatures of Metal-Poor Stars with the Excitation Potential Method
• The Lazy Giants: APOGEE Abundances Reveal Low Star Formation Efficiencies in the Magellanic Clouds
• GALA: an automatic tool for the abundance analysis of stellar spectra
• A homogeneous analysis of globular clusters from the APOGEE survey with the BACCHUS code. I. The Northern clusters
• The radii and limb darkenings of Alpha Centauri A and B - Interferometric measurements with VLTI/PIONIER
• Unveiling systematic biases in 1D LTE excitation-ionisation balance of Fe for FGK stars. A novel approach to determination of stellar parameters
• NLTE Chemical abundances in Galactic open and globular clusters
• The origin of the spurious iron spread in the globular cluster NGC 3201
• Atomic diffusion and mixing in old stars VI: The lithium content of M30
• Angular Diameters of the G Subdwarf $\mu$ Cassiopeiae A and the K Dwarfs $\sigma$ Draconis and HR 511 from Interferometric Measurements with the CHARA Array
• Three-dimensional hydrodynamical CO5BOLD model atmospheres of red giant stars. III. Line formation in the atmospheres of giants located close to the base of RGB
• Influence of departures from LTE on calcium, titanium, and iron abundance determinations in cool giants of different metallicities
• The chemical composition of a regular halo globular cluster: NGC 5897
• FLAMES and XSHOOTER spectroscopy along the two BSS sequences of M30
• Using the CIFIST grid of CO5BOLD 3D model atmospheres to study the effects of stellar granulation on photometric colours. I. Grids of 3D corrections in the UBVRI, 2MASS, Hipparcos, Gaia, and SDSS systems
• NGC 5694: another foster son of the Galactic Halo
• The Search for Stellar Companions to Exoplanet Host Stars Using the CHARA Array
• Confirming the presence of second population stars and the iron discrepancy along the AGB of the globular cluster NGC 6752

Cited by in corpus (29)

• Exploiting the Gaia EDR3 photometry to derive stellar temperatures
• The Most Metal-poor Stars in the Magellanic Clouds are $r$-process Enhanced
• Tracing Pop III supernovae with extreme energies through the Sculptor dwarf spheroidal galaxy
• The complex stellar system M 22: confirming abundance variations with high precision differential measurements
• Discovery of a thin lithium plateau among metal-poor red giant branch stars
• The chemical DNA of the Magellanic Clouds -- I. The chemical composition of 206 Small Magellanic Cloud red giant stars
• Chemical Evolution of R-process Elements in Stars (CERES). I. Stellar parameters and chemical abundances from Na to Zr
• Cepheid Metallicity in the Leavitt Law (C- MetaLL) survey: II.High-resolution spectroscopy of the most metal poor Galactic Cepheids
• A homogeneous comparison between the chemical composition of the Large Magellanic Cloud and the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy
• The Most Metal-poor Stars in the Inner Bulge
• Young giants of intermediate mass Evidence of rotation and mixing
• A comparison between X-shooter spectra and PHOENIX models across the HR-diagram
• High-precision abundances of first population stars in NGC 2808: confirmation of a metallicity spread
• SPECIES II. Stellar parameters of the EXPRESS program giant star sample
• NGC 1261: an $r$-process enhanced globular cluster from the Gaia-Enceladus event
• The metallicity distribution in the core of the Sagittarus dwarf spheroidal: minimising the metallicity biases
• A new set of chisels for Galactic archaeology: Sc, V and Zn as taggers of accreted globular clusters
• Neutron-capture elements in dwarf galaxies III: A homogenized analysis of 13 dwarf spheroidal and ultra-faint galaxies
• Intrinsic Metallicity Variation in the Intermediate Mass Type II Globular Cluster NGC 1261
• Lithium in the lower red giant branch of 5 Galactic globular clusters
• Chemodynamical study of two CEMP-no stars from the Hamburg/ESO Survey
• RR Lyrae stars as probes of the outer Galactic halo: Chemical and kinematic analysis of a pilot sample
• The true nature of HE0057-5959, the most metal-poor Li-rich star
• High speed stars: III. Detailed abundances and binary nature of the extreme speed star GHS143
• Curiouser and curiouser: the peculiar chemical composition of the Li/Na-rich star in Omega Centauri
• A chemical close-up of the main body of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy
• The chemical DNA of the Magellanic Clouds V. R-process dominates neutron capture elements production in the oldest SMC stars
• Chemical Composition of a Palomar 12 Blue Straggler
• Purveyors of fine halos III. Chemical abundance analysis of a potential omega Cen associate