Exactly solvable two-terminal heat engine with asymmetric Onsager coefficients: Origin of the power-efficiency bound

Abstract

An engine producing a finite power at the ideal (Carnot) efficiency is a dream engine, which is not prohibited by the thermodynamic second law. Some years ago, a two-terminal heat engine with {\em asymmetric} Onsager coefficients in the linear response regime was suggested by Benenti, Saito, and Casati [Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 106}, 230602 (2011)], as a prototypical system to make such a dream come true with non-divergent system parameter values. However, such a system has never been realized in spite of many trials. Here, we introduce an exactly solvable two-terminal Brownian heat engine with the asymmetric Onsager coefficients in the presence of a Lorenz (magnetic) force. Nevertheless, we show that the dream engine regime cannot be accessible even with the asymmetric Onsager coefficients, due to an instability keeping the engine from reaching its steady state. This is consistent with recent trade-off relations between the engine power and efficiency, where the (cyclic) steady-state condition is implicitly presumed. We conclude that the inaccessibility to the dream engine originates from the steady-state constraint on the engine.

arXiv comment7 pages, 3 figures

References in corpus (22)

• Universal trade-off between power, efficiency, and constancy in steady-state heat engines
• The power of a critical heat engine
• Universal trade-off relation between power and efficiency for heat engines
• Thermodynamic Bounds on Efficiency for Systems with Broken Time-reversal Symmetry
• Strong bounds on Onsager coefficients and efficiency for three terminal thermoelectric transport in a magnetic field
• Cycling tames power fluctuations near optimum efficiency
• Carnot Cycle at Finite Power: Attainability of Maximal Efficiency
• The Brownian gyrator: a minimal heat engine on the nano-scale
• Non-equilibrium and information: the role of cross-correlations
• Entropic bounds on currents in Langevin systems
• Power-efficiency-dissipation relations in linear thermodynamics
• Onsager coefficients in periodically driven systems
• Multi-terminal Thermoelectric Transport in a Magnetic Field: Bounds on Onsager Coefficients and Efficiency
• Electrical Autonomous Brownian Gyrator
• Effect of a magnetic field on the thermodynamic uncertainty relation
• Carnot efficiency at divergent power output
• Efficiency at maximum power and efficiency fluctuations in a linear Brownian heat engine model
• Carnot efficiency is reachable in an irreversible process
• A Classical Nernst Engine
• Nonequilibrium steady states in Langevin thermal systems
• Non-equilibrium driven by an external torque in the presence of a magnetic field
• Carnot efficiency and zero-entropy-production rate do not guarantee reversibility of a process

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Speed limit for a highly irreversible process and tight finite-time Landauer's bound
• Achieving Carnot efficiency in a finite-power Brownian Carnot cycle with arbitrary temperature difference
• Maximum Power of Coupled-Qubit Otto Engines
• Power-efficiency trade-off for finite-time quantum harmonic Otto heat engine via phase-space approach
• Energy conversion theorems for some linear steady-states
• Thermodynamic uncertainty relation for systems with active Ornstein-Uhlenbeck particles
• Casimir-Onsager matrix for weakly driven processes
• Thermodynamic uncertainty relation in the overdamped limit with a magnetic Lorentz force