Long route to consensus: Two stage coarsening in a binary choice voting model

Abstract

Formation of consensus, in binary yes/no type of voting, is a well defined process. However, even in presence of clear incentives, the dynamics involved can be incredibly complex. Specifically, formations of large groups of similarly opinionated individuals could create a condition of `support-bubbles' or spontaneous polarization that renders consensus virtually unattainable (e.g., the question of the UK exiting the EU). There have been earlier attempts in capturing the dynamics of consensus formation in societies through simple $Z_2$-symmetric models hoping to capture the essential dynamics of average behaviorof a large number of individuals in a statistical sense. However, in absence of external noise, they tend to reach a frozen state with fragmented and polarized states i.e., two or more groups of similarly opinionated groups with frozen dynamics. Here we show in a kinetic exchange opinion model (KEM) considered on $L\times L$ square lattices, that while such frozen states could be avoided, an exponentially slow approach to consensus is manifested. Specifically, the system could either reach consensus in a time that scales as $L^2$ or a long lived metastable state (termed a domain-wall state) for which formation of consensus takes a time scaling as $L^{3.6}$. The latter behavior is comparable to some voter-like models with intermediate states studied previously. The late-time anomaly in the time scale is reflected in the persistence probability of the model. Finally, the interval of zero-crossing of the average opinion i.e., the time interval over which the average opinion does not change sign is shown to follow a scale free distribution, which is compared with that seen in the opinion surveys regarding Brexit and associated issues in the last 40 years. The issue of minority spreading is also addressed by calculating the exit probability.

10 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (43)

• Power-law distributions in empirical data
• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Opinion evolution in closed community
• Voter Model on Heterogeneous Graphs
• Persistence and First-Passage Properties in Non-equilibrium Systems
• Voter model dynamics in complex networks: Role of dimensionality, disorder and degree distribution
• Incomplete ordering of the voter model on small-world networks
• Coarsening and persistence in the voter model
• Freezing and Slow Evolution in a Constrained Opinion Dynamics Model
• Comparison of voter and Glauber ordering dynamics on networks
• Ordering dynamics with two non-excluding options: Bilingualism in language competition
• Fate of Zero-Temperature Ising Ferromagnets
• Majority Rule Dynamics in Finite Dimensions
• Disorder induced phase transition in kinetic models of opinion dynamics
• Opinion formation in the kinetic exchange models: Spontaneous symmetry breaking transition
• Dynamics of Non-Conservative Voters
• Role of conviction in nonequilibrium models of opinion formation
• Consensus and ordering in language dynamics
• A new model of binary opinion dynamics: coarsening and effect of disorder
• Kinetic models of opinion formation in the presence of personal conviction
• Mean field solutions of kinetic exchange opinion models
• Disorder induced phase transition in an opinion dynamics model: results in 2 and 3 dimensions
• Interface Motion and Pinning in Small World Networks
• Some new results on one-dimensional outflow dynamics
• Phase transition in kinetic exchange opinion models with independence
• Dynamics of Confident Voting
• Algebraic coarsening in voter models with intermediate states
• Freezing in random graph ferromagnets
• Critical noise can make the minority candidate win: The US Presidential Election cases
• Persistence in the two dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model
• Non-conservative kinetic exchange model of opinion dynamics with randomness and bounded confidence
• Opinion dynamics in two dimensions: domain coarsening leads to stable bi-polarization and anomalous scaling exponents
• Opinion dynamics model with weighted influence: Exit probability and dynamics
• A stochastic opinion dynamics model with domain size dependent dynamic evolution
• Exit probability in inflow dynamics: nonuniversality induced by range, asymmetry and fluctuation
• Effect of the nature of randomness on quenching dynamics of Ising model on complex networks
• Interplay of interfacial noise and curvature driven dynamics in two dimensions
• Zero temperature coarsening in Ising model with asymmetric second neighbour interaction in two dimensions
• Noise driven dynamic phase transition in a a one dimensional Ising-like model
• Absorbing states of zero-temperature Glauber dynamics in random networks
• Exit Probability in Generalised Kinetic Ising Model
• Kinetic exchange opinion model: solution in the single parameter map limit
• Frozen states and active-absorbing phase transitions of the Ising model on networks

Cited by in corpus (13)

• Curvature-driven growth and interfacial noise in the voter model with self-induced zealots
• Block size dependence of coarse graining in discrete opinion dynamics model: Application to the US presidential elections
• Double transition in kinetic exchange opinion models with activation dynamics
• Opinion dynamics: Public and private
• Virtual walks inspired by a mean field kinetic exchange model of opinion dynamics
• Non-equilibrium dynamics in a three state opinion formation model with stochastic extreme switches
• The Ising universality class of kinetic exchange models of opinion dynamics
• Order-disorder transition in the zero-temperature Ising model on random graphs
• Virtual walks and phase transitions in two dimensional BChS model with extreme switches
• Coarsening in the Persistent Voter Model: analytical results
• Opinion formation models with extreme switches and disorder: critical behaviour and dynamics
• Approach to zigzag and checkerboard patterns in spatially extended systems
• Non-equilibrium dynamics in Ising like models with biased initial condition