Homophily based on few attributes can impede structural balance

Abstract

Two complementary mechanisms are thought to shape social groups: homophily between agents and structural balance in connected triads. Here we consider $N$ fully connected agents, where each agent has $G$ underlying attributes, and the similarity between agents in attribute space (i.e., homophily) is used to determine the link weight between them. To incorporate structural balance we use a triad-updating rule where only one attribute of one agent is changed intentionally in each update, but this also leads to accidental changes in link weights and even link polarities. The link weight dynamics in the limit of large $G$ is described by a Fokker-Planck equation from which the conditions for a phase transition to a fully balanced state with all links positive can be obtained. This "paradise state" of global cooperation is, however, difficult to achieve requiring $G>O(N^2)$ and $p>0.5$, where the parameter $p$ captures a willingness to consensus. Allowing edge weights to be a consequence of attributes naturally captures homophily and reveals that many real-world social systems would have a subcritical number of attributes necessary to achieve structural balance.

arXiv comment6 pages, 5 figures

References in corpus (16)

• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• Multirelational Organization of Large-scale Social Networks in an Online World
• Modeling echo chambers and polarization dynamics in social networks
• Dynamics of Social Balance on Networks
• Analysis of a continuous-time model of structural balance
• Abrupt Desynchronization and Extensive Multistability in Globally Coupled Oscillator Simplices
• The energy landscape of social balance
• The Heider balance - a continuous approach
• Is there negative social influence? Disentangling effects of dissimilarity and disliking on opinion shifts
• Statistical Physics of Balance Theory
• Epidemic spreading on evolving signed networks
• Competing Effects of Social Balance and Influence
• Neural networks with redundant representation: detecting the undetectable
• Giant catalytic effect of altruists in Schelling's segregation model
• Bounded Confidence under Preferential Flip: A Coupled Dynamics of Structural Balance and Opinions
• Characterizing ground and thermal states of few-body Hamiltonians

Cited by in corpus (16)

• Social nucleation: Group formation as a phase transition
• Homophily-based social group formation in a spin-glass self-assembly framework
• Transitions between polarization and radicalization in a temporal bilayer echo chambers model
• Modeling social resilience: Questions, answers, open problems
• Heider and coevolutionary balance: From discrete to continuous phase transition
• Mean-field approximation for structural balance dynamics in heat-bath
• Reply to "Comment on 'Phase transition in a network model of social balance with Glauber dynamics' "
• Hybrid balance theory: Heider balance under higher order interactions
• How does homophily shape the topology of a dynamic network?
• Thermal properties of structurally balanced systems on diluted and densified triangulations
• Second to first order phase transition; coevolutionary versus structural balance
• Catalyzing collaborations: Prescribed interactions at conferences determine team formation
• Effects of homophily and heterophily on preferred-degree networks: mean-field analysis and overwhelming transition
• Response of the competitive balance model to the external field
• Empirical validation of the polarization transition in a double-random field model of elections
• Relationship between Heider links and Ising spins