Estimating trajectories of meteors: an observational Monte Carlo approach -- II. Results

Abstract

In the first paper of this series we examined existing methods of optical meteor trajectory estimation and developed a novel method which simultaneously uses both the geometry and the dynamics of meteors to constrain their trajectories. We also developed a simulator which uses an ablation model to generate realistic synthetic meteor trajectories which we use to test meteor trajectory solvers. In this second paper, we perform simulation validation to estimate radiant and velocity accuracy which may be achieved by various meteor observation systems as applied to several meteor showers. For low-resolution all-sky systems, where the meteor deceleration is generally not measurable, the multi-parameter fit method assuming a constant velocity better reproduces the radiant and speed of synthetic meteors. For moderate field of view systems, our novel method performs the best at all convergence angles, while multi-parameter fit methods generally produce larger speed errors. For high-resolution, narrow field of view systems, we find our new method of trajectory estimation reproduces radiant and speed more accurately than all other methods tested. The ablation properties of meteoroids are commonly found to be the limiting factor in velocity accuracy. We show that the true radiant dispersion of meteor showers can be reliably measured with moderate field of view (or more precise) systems provided appropriate methods of meteor trajectory estimation are employed. Finally, we compare estimated and real angular radiant uncertainty and show that for the solvers tested the real radiant error is on average underestimated by a factor of two.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in MNRAS, 16 pages

References in corpus (10)

• Identification of meteorite source regions in the Solar System
• Observation of metre-scale impactors by the Desert Fireball Network
• Discovery of a new branch of the Taurid meteoroid stream as a real source of potentially hazardous bodies
• Estimating trajectories of meteors: an observational Monte Carlo approach -- I. Theory
• Modeling the measurement accuracy of pre-atmosphere velocities of meteoroids
• 3D Meteoroid Trajectories
• Radar Observations of the 2011 October Draconid Outburst
• The 2011 October Draconids outburst. I. Orbital elements, meteoroid fluxes and 21P/Giacobini-Zinner delivered mass to Earth
• Spectral, photometric, and dynamic analysis of eight Draconid meteors
• Enhanced activity of the Southern Taurids in 2005 and 2015

Cited by in corpus (8)

• The Global Meteor Network -- Methodology and First Results
• High precision meteor observations with the Canadian Automated Meteor Observatory -- Data reduction pipeline and application to meteoroid mechanical strength measurements
• The Hamburg Meteorite Fall: Fireball trajectory, orbit and dynamics
• Direct measurement of decimeter-sized rocky material in the Oort cloud
• A new method for measuring the meteor mass index: application to the 2018 Draconid meteor shower outburst
• Realistic gravitational focusing of meteoroid streams
• Accuracy of meteor positioning from space-and ground-based observations
• Error dependencies in the space-based CNEOS fireball database